Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
my friends iphone got the discoloration, without a case. so it does appear that overheating is really an issue.

Pictures. None of this "my friend.." bs Because we're all sooo ready to believe you and your "friend," based on a comment on a forum.
 
What I find bizarre is that people were taking their phones back due to the discoloration which they couldn't even see without taking the case off!
 
my friends iphone got the discoloration, without a case. so it does appear that overheating is really an issue.
What colour is the discolouration? Is your friend a heavy smoker? If a heavy smoker's fingers get yellow, what do you think happens to a white iPhone?
 
What I find bizarre is that people were taking their phones back due to the discoloration which they couldn't even see without taking the case off!
Exactly!

And why on earth would anyone in a right mindset purchase a white iPhone... to put it in a some case?!?
 
I wanted a case for my black iPhone just in case I get butterfingers. For about a year I had a silicone case from more-thing. It eventually got stretched out. I hunted for a new one that wasn't bulky but would protect it well and also allow easy access to the dock connector. I finally found the perfect case at the AT&T store, of all places. It's sleek; I can hardly tell it's there. And it was on close-out for $5. Plus it has the added bonus of fooling people into thinking I got a white iPhone. :cool:

iphone_case.jpg
 
I've been using this OtterBox for a while now and never had this decoloration.

IPHONE-3G-OB2600-LG.jpg


Most of you idiots saying "IT'S UGLY" aren't ever going to need a case that will withstand the abuse snowboarding, camping, paintball, or such things that would demand this extremely abuse-proof case that without would destroy an expensive ass phone. Not to mention it's not like you can't take the phone out if you go to the mall with your preppy friends.
 
I wanted a case for my black iPhone just in case I get butterfingers. For about a year I had a silicone case from more-thing. It eventually got stretched out. I hunted for a new one that wasn't bulky but would protect it well and also allow easy access to the dock connector. I finally found the perfect case at the AT&T store, of all places. It's sleek; I can hardly tell it's there. And it was on close-out for $5. Plus it has the added bonus of fooling people into thinking I got a white iPhone. :cool:

iphone_case.jpg

That thing will get disgustingly dirty. The Incipio Feather in white is known for this.
 
My thoughts exactly. I have never understood the obsession of some iPhone users with keeping their precious device in an ugly case. It's like buying a new car, then leaving it in the garage all the time because you're afraid of a scratch. Both my iPhone and iPhone 3G have survived for year of usage without a case and nothing but very minor scratches.

It's not just cosmetics...I have a matte black snap-on case for the back of my 3GS because it's easier to grip than the glossy black plastic shell.
 
Who isn't going to use a case? Hell who isn't going to buy a Mac without getting a shell for it?

Scratch, fingerprint, and dent city. I need to get some Novus Polish for my MacBook.

Why would i buy such a beautiful product and cover it up with an ugly ass case? Never. I'd rather risk cracking or scratching it. If that happens, just buy a new one. But an ugly case.. never.
 
I've been using this OtterBox for a while now and never had this decoloration.

IPHONE-3G-OB2600-LG.jpg


Most of you idiots saying "IT'S UGLY" aren't ever going to need a case that will withstand the abuse snowboarding, camping, paintball, or such things that would demand this extremely abuse-proof case that without would destroy an expensive ass phone. Not to mention it's not like you can't take the phone out if you go to the mall with your preppy friends.

That's a beast of a case...
 
Maybe I will get a white one after all. Only if the Speck CandyShell doesnt discolor the iphone?
 
I've been using this OtterBox for a while now and never had this decoloration.

IPHONE-3G-OB2600-LG.jpg


Most of you idiots saying "IT'S UGLY" aren't ever going to need a case that will withstand the abuse snowboarding, camping, paintball, or such things that would demand this extremely abuse-proof case that without would destroy an expensive ass phone. Not to mention it's not like you can't take the phone out if you go to the mall with your preppy friends.

Wow, I thought my Otterbox iPhone Armor (1st Gen) was a beast:

otterbox-iphone-armor-case.jpg


Works as advertised. Dropped mine in a muddy river once and it though it took a few minutes to find, the iPhone itself was fine.

In cities/developed country, my iPhone is naked. The way it was meant to be. :)
 
Me. White MacBook and White iPhone are both naked and look great. Why ruin the sexy form of the iPhone with a bulky case? It makes it look ugly.

To each his own but... a case doesn't just protect it's appearance, it may prevent the screen from cracking if dropped, it may increase grip - some of us are butterfingers.

I'm such a klutz that I had my 3G in a bullet-proof Otter Box case for a year. Yes, I dropped it several times. I just sold the 3G a couple of days ago as mint for $325USD and upgraded to the 3GS.
 

Attachments

  • 1942-20.4.17.jpg
    1942-20.4.17.jpg
    102.1 KB · Views: 98
Discolouration on my iPod Touch 1G (Happened last year, after I updated it to 2.0, it started to overheat)

photo2-1.jpg

photo21.jpg

photo31.jpg
 
I've been using this OtterBox for a while now and never had this decoloration...
I would never go extreme without a rescue beeper and my phone (phones have proved to be very helpful in a number of accidents). That case, the size, would however be too much for me.

Note: I am the survivor of both the 1999 avalanche of Galtur and Valzur one day later – I was the fool who tried to prove that he was no chicken and that's when I broke my leg (I tried to outrun the avalanche). I stopped a few years later, when another friend passed away.
 
Who isn't going to use a case? Hell who isn't going to buy a Mac without getting a shell for it?

Scratch, fingerprint, and dent city. I need to get some Novus Polish for my MacBook.

iPhone case: yes

MacBook shell: no
 
Who isn't going to use a case? Hell who isn't going to buy a Mac without getting a shell for it?

I've owned a 1st generation iPhone, and now have a 3GS. I've never used a case for either, and doing so has never been a problem. They slip perfectly into my front jeans pocket, and the phones were never adversely effected.

I've never used a case for any phone, for that matter. Not sure why I should start just because the iPhone is teh shiny.

I've never used a screen protector, either. I've noticed that iPhones owned by case/screen-protector fans always look like ass in comparison.
 
Wirelessly posted (iPhone 3GS (White, 32GB): Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 3_1 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/528.18 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0 Mobile/7C97d Safari/528.16)

LagunaSol said:
I wonder if the TV news programs that aired this "problem" will now run an updated story absolving Apple from blame?

Answer: no.

Exactly. I suspect this news won't be spread NEARLY as fast as the 'Defective 3GS!!' story ... :rolleyes:
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.