Why current gen Macbook Pro 15 might be better than next gen

Discussion in 'Buying Tips and Advice' started by RoskO, Oct 5, 2016.

  1. RoskO macrumors member

    Joined:
    Jan 14, 2008
    #1
    I have been one of those waiting for Apple to update the current 15" Retina, however I have my doubts that the new generation will be better and I've started to care less about the refresh lately. In fact, I think the current 2015 model will actually be "better" in some ways for most consumers/pro users. Not that any of this hasn't been stated before, but I wonder if people here are just going to ...buy just to buy it, or if they will take a stand and vote with their wallet?

    The new 15" is supposed to be thinner/marginally lighter than the current 15"
    For me, I really don't care if the 15" is much thinner. My current retina 15 is thin enough for a 15" machine, if I want lighter I usually use my 13". To make it much lighter they'd have to drop the battery weight (and lose some whr).

    The new 15" is supposed to have 4? USB C/Thunderbolt ports and dropping other ports
    I think this is a big mistake by Apple. I use Macs/Windows/SDcards/old USB drives etc, I don't mind them including USB C, but don't take away USB 2, headphone, and SDCard ports, all of which I use dongle free.

    The new 15" will sport skylake CPUs
    This is just not a big deal. Even the current 15" retina with Haswell will likely perform on par with the skylake counterparts. Skylake has proven to be marginally better on battery life, so we might see a bump of 30-40 minutes in the real world, but almost all tests show Skylake just isn't really that much better, if at all. This is probably a big reason why Apple wasn't in a hurry to refresh.

    The new 15" will have an OLED touchbar
    This might be neat but it's not going to make or break whether I buy one or not. I don't interface that often with the function keys....just occasionally.

    The new 15" will have a new keyboard
    The current keyboard is good enough for me, I like the feedback, though not as good as a thinkpad, it's plenty good.

    Furthermore, the current gen 15" already uses an extremely fast PCIE SSD. There are a few new SSDs that are faster now, Apple could potentially upgrade it, but you'd really never notice the difference in anything other than benchmarks.

    They could possibly provide a 32GB DDR4 option, but I rarely need over 16GB.

    It's interesting to think that the current gen might be just as good or better if you are a person that hates carrying dongles with you, or keeping track of them. I suppose there's the crowd that will welcome a slightly smaller format and a small drop in weight, but I'd imagine they aren't going to shave much more than .5lbs, give or take.

    What do you think?
     
  2. cryonicjim macrumors newbie

    Joined:
    Mar 13, 2009
    #2
    I agree with a lot of the points you made, but for me its going to come down to the graphics card options. The 15" retina (and macs in general) are usually behind on GPUs, but it hits even harder because of the retina display. The current 2gb ATI option would be decent/passable if it were driving a 1080p display, but at more than double the pixel count it just doesn't cut it. It may not be a deal breaker if you don't use graphically intensive applications, but for those of us that use it for video editing and gaming- I'm praying for apple to finally break the 2gb mark.
     
  3. RoskO thread starter macrumors member

    Joined:
    Jan 14, 2008
    #3
    You are correct, I really don't use the secondary GPU, I actually prefer my 15" to just use the Iris Pro integrated to save battery, but I'm not doing video editing on the laptop. If I were editing or using a program that had a heavy benefit from the GPU I would care more.
     

Share This Page