Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone XS Max Why do you need 5G?
- Thread starter Sledneck52
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Dude, an iPhone 4s has been my daily driver until today. I dropped its Sim into my iPad Air to answer whether 4G sucks as bad as on my 4s. Yes, 4G did suck on the iPhone 4s. I’ll have a couple months to decide if an A14 chip would suck on 4G too.
5G on an iPhone 12 is simply another technology like Apple’s famous NFC technology. Or it could be a future proof release as Apple’s famous iPhone 4s.
The 4S does not have 4G LTE. It's only got HSPA+ or fake 4G. Kinda similar to AT&T's 5GE branding.
Review | The 5G lie: The network of the future is still slow
We speed tested 5G phones against 4G ones. America’s new nationwide 5G networks weren’t much faster — and in some places they were slower.
www.washingtonpost.com
Well, hold on just a minute. 5G may hold promise for the years ahead — but across most of America in 2020, a 5G phone does diddly squat. Testing 5G phones, I’ve been clocking download speeds that are roughly the same as on 4G LTE ones. And in some places, like inside my house and along the California highway, my 5G phones actually have been slower.
Yes, slower.
Asplain morely. What app clip will want to consume high bandwidth at low latency? Not challenging you, trying to stimulate ideas—legit curious.
Best I can think of is ad hoc streaming video of you interacting with a product in more areas than providers want to deploy fiber backhaul.
Last edited:
I didn’t take that as the spirit of the question—rather “what makes you excited/hopeful for”
I’d be more than happy to have an iPhone 12 which is 5G capable on a 4G plan. I certainly don’t want to be charged extra for something I’m not overly bothered about. It’s definitely something I will discuss what negotiating my next contract.
I'm currently using a 4G router for my home network. If 5G is that much faster it's going to be just as good as fiber internet. Where I live it's affordable to get a phone plan with unlimited data ($40 a month), so I just got the carrier to ship an extra sim-card to put in my router.
Imagine using that iPhone 4S on T-Mobile 9 years ago— EDGE speeds only! (Due to not having the bands that T-Mobile used). What was that... 2g? 2.5g? Alas, it was preferable (to me) to any of the Android options at the time. Was HSDPA+ considered 4G? Still should have been much faster than EDGE at the time.
As Tom Cruise said, “I have a need for speed.” I live my life in the fast lane, drive my sports car fast and definitely am a technology early adopter.
Actually that’s not necessarily true. 5G is included in all of AT&T’s unlimited plans. It’s not an add-on.
No one needs 5G. It helps sales because its new. Its a nice to have where ever it already is or might be available. If its “just faster” nobody will even bother to mention 6G whenever it’s out. Also who really needs Bluetooth 6 or mp5?
Don't get me wrong, I am all for faster download speeds but I doubt 5G is going to deliver that much improvement for people living in rural areas like me, one thing I think can make a difference though is that they will use Qualcom modems which generally is better than the intel ones so I am hopeful it will improve 4G as well. I do not need 5G as where I live in Sweden it will take some time before we get any 5G and I buy a new iPhone every year anyway. If the modems are better though it can be worth it in my book but that remains to be seen.
I don't. I used 3G up until this year. My only use cases outside the house are: Navigation, WhatsApp, Looking up some info. 3G is fine for that. I work from home 99% of the time and when I'm out I'm usually at some office or home where there is WiFi. Or I'm in the car and can't use my phone anyway.
I my mind watching videos or playing games is something you do at home anyway. When I'm out it's for meeting people for work or social reasons. That means not playing around with the phone.
One use case might be when I'm in the train. But I find that a good moment for introspection. I never even listen to music when I'm outside. Maybe I'm just old fashioned.
I only have 4G now because the price was the same and I got someone else's iPhone SE over my iPhone 5. I don't really need 4G so I most certainly won't need 5G.
I dó want a new phone however, because my iPad is dead and reading on my phone is doable, but a bigger screen and OLED would be really nice for reading. So an iPhone X will probably be fine. I'm waiting for the iPhone 12 however for the prices of used iPhones to go down
I my mind watching videos or playing games is something you do at home anyway. When I'm out it's for meeting people for work or social reasons. That means not playing around with the phone.
One use case might be when I'm in the train. But I find that a good moment for introspection. I never even listen to music when I'm outside. Maybe I'm just old fashioned.
I only have 4G now because the price was the same and I got someone else's iPhone SE over my iPhone 5. I don't really need 4G so I most certainly won't need 5G.
I dó want a new phone however, because my iPad is dead and reading on my phone is doable, but a bigger screen and OLED would be really nice for reading. So an iPhone X will probably be fine. I'm waiting for the iPhone 12 however for the prices of used iPhones to go down
Personally I am happy to sit out 5G for a couple of years. Sometimes I dont mind being an early adopter of new tech but this roll out (in the UK) is a mess. And its super expensive. 4G for me is plenty fast enough, even when transferring large files it is often as fast as my home wifi.
If/when 5G is able to replace my home broadband for a lower cost, then I will be interested.
Right now Verizon isn’t charging for it, on their unlimited plans. When they eventually do start to charge for it then I’ll deal with the extra cost.
It will be great on large concerts or sports events, so everybody can post selfies on social networks instead of watching the event.
Other than that 99% of people that currently have decent LTE connection don’t need it. And if your current connection is crap, 5G will most probably be even worse.
On the other hand - more speed never hurts
Other than that 99% of people that currently have decent LTE connection don’t need it. And if your current connection is crap, 5G will most probably be even worse.
On the other hand - more speed never hurts
I’ve said this is many forums. I need T-Mobile’s low band 5G for coverage where I live. I average maybe 2 bars of service and some places I go I have no signal with LTE. My fastest download speeds are 40 mbps. With 5G I’ll get the same coverage around here I did when Verizon first rolled out their 700 MHz LTE. I really don’t care about gigabyte speeds so mmWave isn’t important to me.
This is a repeated case back in 2010s. People only streamed 240p or 360p videos in their mobiles, 3G was decent, and then mobile screen went to high res, 300ppi or more, so LTE was a must in order to stream 720p or 1080p smoothly.
I think most of us don’t need 5g yet unless mobile’s screen resolution goes up to 4k and streaming 4k is common in smartphones. Maybe in 2022 when 4k smartphones are ubiquitous.
I think most of us don’t need 5g yet unless mobile’s screen resolution goes up to 4k and streaming 4k is common in smartphones. Maybe in 2022 when 4k smartphones are ubiquitous.
Last edited: