I don't understand. If the Apple TV doesn't have any component output now and only HDMI, why does it have an optical audio output right next to the HDMI? Doesn't HDMI carry video AND audio? What's the purpose is connecting both an HDMI cable and a Tos-link cable for the same source?
I probably wouldn't buy the new AppleTV if it didn't have one.
My HDMI receiver has 2 HDMI inputs.
They are currently being used by my Xbox and PS3.
I can hook up my ApplyTV to my TV directly with HDMI and since it doesn't use hidef audio, it isn't necessary to waste an input on my receiver.
Doesn't mean I don't want 5.1 sound.
I have plenty of optical inputs on my receiver.