Not true. The Verizon iPhone 4 and all versions of the 4S are the same, but the buttons and vibrate switch on the AT&T iPhone 4 are slightly different. So since this case specifies that it will fit only the AT&T iPhone 4, it will not fit the 4S.Yes it will fit. The iPhone 4 and iPhone 4s are physically identical.
the cut out for the mute switch is plenty big to fit the 4s.Don't worry.
I found several documents online that said that the Universal iPhone 4 case works perfectly on the iPhone 4S, so I got one of those instead.
Yes it fit my wife's 4S. However if you have a white iphone you will need to cut-out the plastic were the proximity sensor on the otterbox is, you can search on youtube and find a video on how to do it. When you use your flash you will also have washed out images. (this flaw has been fixed with the new version)http://www.amazon.com/OtterBox-Defender-Case-iPhone-White/dp/B0049MEDAI/ref=pd_ybh_7
I can get it for a cheap price versus the other Otterbox cases and it's full white, which is exactly what I want.