Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Pixelmage

macrumors member
Original poster
Aug 22, 2008
46
0
I am looking into buying a new wireless router to replace my aging Belkin G Router (F5D7231-4P). I guess an "N" router is what I should looking at now.

Here are some of the things I liked about it:
1. Mac Friendly
2. Firewall (of course)
3. MAC address filtering
4. WAN Ping Blocking
5. Security (WPA-PSK)
6. Displays DHCP Client List
7. Parental Control
8. Channel and SSID
9. Four Ethernet ports
10. Status lights on the front
11. Decent wireless range

I am still research on what's out there but any recommendations would be greatly appreciated.
 
I love my Airport Extreme. Have a 2tb external hooked up to it to backup most of the info on all my macs. Makes time machine a breeze!
 
I am kind of considering it but I wish the status lights were on the front. Also how is the wireless range? I thought antennas on a router device are important. There none on the Airport.

Are there any screen shots that shows the various levels of the user interface?
 
Airport extreme's have antennas but they are mounted inside the unit.

airportextremedissected.jpg



http://www.flickr.com/photos/47495468@N07/sets/72157623996670811/

Here's screenshots of my airport settings pages.

Range is excellent, I live in a two story 3,000sq ft home and I get great signal throughout the house, even in the back yard.
 
Another vote for Airport Extreme. Was a breeze to set up the printer to the USB and have my wife's PC laptop print wireless to it.
 
I am looking into buying a new wireless router to replace my aging Belkin G Router (F5D7231-4P). I guess an "N" router is what I should looking at now.

Here are some of the things I liked about it:
1. Mac Friendly
2. Firewall (of course)
3. MAC address filtering
4. WAN Ping Blocking
5. Security (WPA-PSK)
6. Displays DHCP Client List
7. Parental Control
8. Channel and SSID
9. Four Ethernet ports
10. Status lights on the front
11. Decent wireless range

I am still research on what's out there but any recommendations would be greatly appreciated.

Sounds like you described the Airport Extreme :D
 
I'd definitely recommend Airport Extreme. I've been through the D-Link, Netgear, Linksys, etc stuff and even if I quit using Mac products tomorrow I'd stick with the Apple network gear.

I'm not sure why you need the status lights up front. They always seemed more annoying than anything. Range is fine. My N devices aren't too far away, but I use my G devices on the 2nd floor of my home with strong signals and great speeds and my AEBS is in my basement.

They are plenty flexible as well.
 
I am still on the fence about the AEBS. I have read plenty of good reviews. However some users found that there is not as much robust features and/or control over certain functions that are normally found in higher-end routers at the same or lessor price. And others question the reliability of the built-in firewall. So I am not sure what to make out of all this.

I certainly like the extra control / functions in my old router but I need to upgrade it soon.

I am also looking at the Cisco Linksys E3000 and Netgear Rangemax WNDR370. Has anyone had any decent experiences with these two?
 
I recently got a dual band Airport Extreme base station and its worked out pretty well. Our old Belkin 54G needed reset constantly and had poor coverage. So far I really don't have any complaints especially since I got it on eBay for $88 shipped.
 
I'm also looking for a new wireless router that'll also work with the occasional Windows 7 boot, and while I like the look of the Airport Extreme, I have one issue with it - and this also goes back to one of the OP's requirements: it only has 3 Ethernet spots, not 4.

Although I have to admit, being able to hook the printer up to the router is very appealing :)
 
I'd also like to hear about anyone's experience with the Linksys E3000 or the Netgear Rangemax mentioned above. I currently have the AEBS (sim dual band) and looking to return it for a router that works better with iPad. I know not everyone has trouble with the AE, but it struggles to maintain a decent signal/connection just one room over, with the iPad anyways. I need the range and like most of the features of said routers. It would be nice to save the $$ difference too. Thx!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.