Exactly the MBA I'm on... so how does the new machine compare overall to the trusted old 2011 MBA?
Well you already know about dongle life!
- no SD card reader (I've purchased the Apple TV adapter with HDMI, USB3 and USB-C but I completely forgot photos and docs I've stored on a few SD cards ... ARRG.
recommended viewing:
Typing:
(let me preface this with that fact I'm 45yrs old, been typing since I've been 8yrs old first on manual typewriters, touch-typing).
When I type ... there seems to be a rhythm, some habit formed from manual typewriters, then transitioned to Commoder Pet, Vic20 (home), Apple ][e, Tandy (some junk at home), Macintosh, several windows desktop computers to my first laptop, a Compaq, Apple Ti_Book G4, MacBook Air 11" swapped for 13" for a few years, then Lenovo X240/T450s/460s/X1 Carbon 5th generation.
I wish I had a better description. Typing in the Apple store on a 2017 MBP 13" seems like almost typing on glass, hardly any travel, no rebound, and this cause me to double enter keys in any app when I typed. Again this was in the store, so no real adjustment time for me. The BEST laptop keyboard I've ever typed on was the X1 Carbon due to the familiarity of key travel on the defending (key press) that I've had for over 30yrs. VERY close is my current MBP 2018 13". I actually love the rebound (the key return after being pressed and lifting the finger), which allows me to quickly type again - if using the same or any other key because my muscle memory is quickly adjusting.
For those that complain about the TouchBar ... I say many are just winers and a few actual rely on the day to day muscle memory (something I was never taught in typing or computer classes, and yes I worked 3yrs on AS/400 3270 sessions daily). The TouchBar can be customized per application or a default set, while also be set to persistently have the Function (Fn) keys.
Great how to tips/tricks video here:
All in all if you liked the TouchBar and 2016/2017 MBP keyboard design (it's the same pretty much), you'll do just fine with a smile. If you disliked the keys ... you'll need to adjust or stop worrying or being aggrevated, take a deep breath and just do the work you want/need to do .. the aggravation will eventually fade away.
FYI:
MBA - slightly better keyboard because so many of us are used to it.
MBA - SD Card reader/writer slot
MBA - USB-A 2.0 ports x2
MBA - MiniDisplayPort (if you have adapters/LCD that relies on it)
MBP - Faster processing for just about anything (with current mid-2018 model comparison vs MBA)
MBP - Cleaner and better screen resolution, True Tone (which can be quickly disabled)
MBP - having a Fn key row that adapts to the application you're using (which can be customized) is very productive if you just open your mind and give it a try over a week or two. We all still glance at the keys so you'll see the benefit soon enough. Have iTunes playing in it's own desktop space you'll see why.
MBP - smaller in terms of dimensional size and volume for carrying, yet although lighter ... "seems" a tiny bit heavier (I have no ideal why I'm perceiving this).
MBP - will continue to evolve.
MBA will soon be fully replaced and or merged into the tiny MacBook.
If you're still not sure ... save your money, or invest it to grow, and take your time practicing in the store or wait until mid-september for Apple to update the MacBook or the MacBook Air.
Cheers.