Wll anyone with a whiny MBP 15 a new MBP 17 Please Answer This For Me?

Nope. Dead silent. I tried it plugged in and also while running on batteries. Just to be sure, I ran photobooth with my ear next to the machine and didn't hear a difference.

I did have a whiny MBP15 and know what it sounds like. So, now whine.

eV

 

Much much cooler! The top doesn't get nearly as hot as MBP15 and is almost cool to the touch. The bottom gets warm, but not scorching like the 15" version. Heat is subjective but relatively speaking, my MBP 17 is about 33% - 50% cooler than the MBP 15 I replaced

eV

 

Yeah, but you failed to ask the most important question...

eVolcre's 17" was DOA

I would guess that doesn't really matter but just so you know

 

LOL. True True.

But, I really think that is a fluke and not indicative of the quality of the MBP 17. Look at the outcry we had on the forums with the MBP15 issues and the relative lack of complaints on this release.

Go forth and multiply (the number of MBP17s I mean)

eV

 

Yeah, I'm sure it was just a fluke thing, but I just found it funny that yours was the only response to the OP's question and yet yours was DOA. Just made me laugh a bit.
My strange sense of humour

 

eV