I had to think for a minute and ended up voting Juliet. Her personality (smile) takes her a loooooong way.
I can't believe Ana Lucia is even an option. Her face reminds me of a melting popsicle and she's more butch than a lot of the guys at my gym.
Kate.
I don't get why so many people have voted for Juliet. I don't watch LOST, so I'm basing my choice purely on looks. I guess for many others, Juliet's personality must have factored into it.