My thinking is no as the notch is very distracting for full screen. Steve always believed in beautiful simplicity with function. I think he would have a thin bezel at top for the camera?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Would Steve Jobs have approved the iPhone X camera notch?
- Thread starter Risco
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I think it’s pointless now because Steve Jobs is...uhmm...dead?
Needs a "it doesn't matter what steve would have thought" option. People tend to act like steve jobs was perfect and never made any poor design decisions, we need to just forget about this whole idolizing the idea of how wonderful apple would be if steve were still with us.
[doublepost=1506181375][/doublepost]
It is not idolising, but more clear as the years go by that Apple have lost their way. Yes, it still functions but the design ethos has been lost.
Steve Jobs had a profound effect on millions of lives.
[doublepost=1506181375][/doublepost]
It is not idolising, but more clear as the years go by that Apple have lost their way. Yes, it still functions but the design ethos has been lost.
Steve Jobs had a profound effect on millions of lives.
Good come back there...from someone like you who posts utter nonsense and asking absolutely pointless questions from behind a keyboard.
I guess there’s no way to know but for the sake of discussion I would have to say no way in hell! He would have either pushed it back, or demanded that his engineers come up with another solution. Tim Cook is not as meticulous and demanding when it comes to design, he’s an operations and distribution guy.
Lost their way according to who? that's the point people act as if Apple wouldn't be releasing this if Steve was still alive despite the fact that we have no way of knowing what would have happened. It is basically the very definition of idolizing him. Lots of people continue to live in this fog of pretending like Apple would be so much better if Steve was alive, but for all we know it could have gotten worse if he was still with us we literally will never know so there is no good reason to constantly speculate.
It also makes me laugh that Steve would always agree with the people who bring this stuff up...
It's an interesting topic I think even though nobody can ever answer it. Personally I have my doubts, I think broad concepts such as symmetry tended to matter more to Jobs. He was also very keen to maintain the user experience across devices and, due to the notch, certain aspects of the UI will be different on the X.
The only thing I feel confident saying Jobs would not have accepted would be a situation with so many different iPhones on offer. The SE, 6s, 7, 8 and X (and the 6s, 7 and 8 all having a normal and a plus sized model) must be confusing to those who aren't avid tech followers like most on here.
It's very hard for a CEO to avoid this. You have marketing people who tell you this or that segment want to spend precisely $550, you have engineers desperate to push whatever creation they were involved with, you have supply chain guys telling you about production lines that might as well be used. It's very seductive which is why it nearly always happens with nearly all companies; sooner or later they lose focus. Jobs on his return to Apple really had to battle the engineers there, men he really respected and loved, because - like many on this board - they love the technology but don't see it from the point of view of the ordinary person.
Would Jobs have insisted on there being just one iPhone at a time in one size? Probably not. But no way he would have accepted the current line up of EIGHT different iPhones, some separated by just $40 or $50 from the next one, some being confusing such as a 7 plus 128gb costing more than an 8 64gb - it really must be a bit unsettling for many average consumers I think.
Jobs used to insist apple computers went into one of four categories - amateur laptop, amateur desktop, professional laptop, professional desktop. I suspect he would do something similar with iPhones - a simpler device in large and normal and then a higher cost device in large and normal. And that would be it.
The only thing I feel confident saying Jobs would not have accepted would be a situation with so many different iPhones on offer. The SE, 6s, 7, 8 and X (and the 6s, 7 and 8 all having a normal and a plus sized model) must be confusing to those who aren't avid tech followers like most on here.
It's very hard for a CEO to avoid this. You have marketing people who tell you this or that segment want to spend precisely $550, you have engineers desperate to push whatever creation they were involved with, you have supply chain guys telling you about production lines that might as well be used. It's very seductive which is why it nearly always happens with nearly all companies; sooner or later they lose focus. Jobs on his return to Apple really had to battle the engineers there, men he really respected and loved, because - like many on this board - they love the technology but don't see it from the point of view of the ordinary person.
Would Jobs have insisted on there being just one iPhone at a time in one size? Probably not. But no way he would have accepted the current line up of EIGHT different iPhones, some separated by just $40 or $50 from the next one, some being confusing such as a 7 plus 128gb costing more than an 8 64gb - it really must be a bit unsettling for many average consumers I think.
Jobs used to insist apple computers went into one of four categories - amateur laptop, amateur desktop, professional laptop, professional desktop. I suspect he would do something similar with iPhones - a simpler device in large and normal and then a higher cost device in large and normal. And that would be it.
Last edited:
I completely agree, the fact is that Apple would be better if Steve was still with us there’s not doubt about that!
[doublepost=1506181375][/doublepost]
It is not idolising, but more clear as the years go by that Apple have lost their way. Yes, it still functions but the design ethos has been lost.
Steve Jobs had a profound effect on millions of lives.
But what’s the point in hypothesising when we will never know the answer? Just seems like procrastination to me. We should all just look forward and wish Apple well under Tim Cook’s leadership.
Who cares about Steve Jobs? He joined the whole telephone party late in the game. When I see today's phones, I put a great deal of thought into whether Alexander Graham Bell would have approved.
Anyone outside of the valley wouldn’t have approved that monstrosity.
And also Steve. Steve wouldn’t have either.
Hopefully it goes away next year.
And also Steve. Steve wouldn’t have either.
Hopefully it goes away next year.
Would Steve Jobs have approved of what I had for lunch today? Hmmmm, I wonder...
Seems like a profit scene nowadays. At least in the jobs era it didn’t feel like you where giving your money towards something with no real innovation.
This year really shows how much they are milking people.
No 128 gig phones.
X model only 64 to 256 for 150 price increase.
50$ increase on the pointless filler 8 8/s models.
It’s just nonsense profit hungry apple
Last edited:
Perfectly sums up my feelings. It’s all for profit, yes while Steve was alive the phones were expensive. However they were truly amazing, the iPhone 4 was miles ahead of the competition.
The amount of leaks don’t help. Yes the iPhone 4 got leaked but Apple threw down the hammer on Gizmodo.
I always, always looked forward to Apple keynote. Now I don’t really care. This is the first phone since 3G I may not bother to upgrade straight away.
I honestly think if Steve was with us today, the iPhone 8 or "X" would still have gotten bigger... but the design would be similar to the iPhone 4 and 5 with the flat glass design and no round edges or camera bump. Apple found its signature look around the time and Apple just threw out Steve’s creation the moment he died.
That's largely because Jobs was a really good salesman. Sometimes I watch his keynote for the original iPhone, and he makes me want to buy the thing today!