Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Would you revisit an Apple Silicon 17" / 18" MBP?

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.
To answer the actual question - screen size alone is not a huge feature to me any more. If it otherwise ticks all the boxes, I might be tempted to return to a 17 or 18 again, but that would depend a lot on the specifics - I'm not going to order a hypoethtical 17" ridiculously thin Air over a 16" high end pro, just because it has a bigger screen.

(Also, why is there no "maybe, it depends" option on the poll?)
 
To answer the actual question - screen size alone is not a huge feature to me any more. If it otherwise ticks all the boxes, I might be tempted to return to a 17 or 18 again, but that would depend a lot on the specifics - I'm not going to order a hypoethtical 17" ridiculously thin Air over a 16" high end pro, just because it has a bigger screen.

(Also, why is there no "maybe, it depends" option on the poll?)
It’s an interesting point. I would not be interested in a 17 inch air either, I think the assumption is that it would be a high-end machine, at least equal to the 16 inch, perhaps even more capable.
 
That's exactly what they did with 15" to 16". There is simply not enough laptop there to make the display even larger, the bezel is already less than 5mm...
They could do it with a combo of a slightly larger case and a slightly smaller bezel to get that extra inch.

17 inches is a thing of beauty and I dream of the day they bring it back. Hopefully some day but no signs of that tomorrow.
 
17/18" is too big and too small for me.

Too big to easily carry around back and forth to work, use on an airplane, etc.

Too small when at a desk. Display small compared to 24" to 27" monitor.

For me, a better match is a smaller and lighter system (13"/14") to carry around, and an external monitor and keyboard on a desk.
 
The fact that there's so few replies compared to even the silliest WWDC gossip thread, says enough about the interest for a 17", IMHO :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.