Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

profmjh

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Mar 7, 2015
1,734
1,800
UK
So, having sworn that I wouldn’t cave and buy an X, I did what I always do and bought one.

Two things happened. First, I saw one in real life (one of my clients has one) and I was impressed. Second, I randomly checked John Lewis and they had stock. So I went for it. Two days later, I’m now the proud owner of a 64GB grey iPhone X.

I read a lot of the threads on the X and there were many critical ones — or at least, ones complaining of problems. But then people started posting positive reviews and I got encouraged.

So . . . to my experience.

Look and feel

It is absolutely as beautiful as everyone says. It really does feel like high quality. The grey is darker than in pictures. It’s similar to my jet black iPhone 7+, but it changes colour in different lighting and there’s definitely a greyness to it. It goes very nicely with my grey ceramic Apple Watch.

It’s visibly thicker than the 7+, but obviously smaller. It feels heavy — I’m guessing it’s denser than the 7+ — but not in bad way. Heavy in a block of gold type way rather than a lump of lead type way.

The size is great. Because of the width, I held my 7+ by balancing it on my thumb and resting it against my palm. This got uncomfortable after a while. But the X is that much slimmer in width, so my hand naturally grabbed it at both sides: much more comfortable.

The screen is stunning. Better than the 7+. No doubt. Brighter, crisper, clearer, sharper, more vivid, more colourful. I find it much easier to see with my glasses on — with my 7+ I got into the habit of taking my glasses off to get a clear view of the screen. (I’m short-sighted.) I don’t feel the need to do this half as much with the X. I’m not seeing weird colours or tints. I don’t see drastic changes when I change my viewing angle. No green lines . . .

Face ID

Face ID is a game changer. It makes you realise what backwards, last century technology the home button and Touch ID was. It’s fast. I don’t know what other people are talking about when they say it’s slower than Touch ID. By the time I’ve looked at the screen — at the time or notifications or just at how lovely it is — the padlock has unlocked. No waiting around. It’s done.

You then scroll up, which I much prefer. I had my 7+ set up so that as soon as I touched the home button, I was in the home screen and I missed all my notifications. Now they’re there until I dismiss them. Even better, because I’ve been verified by Face ID, I can interact with the notifications immediately. So much better.

We’re so used to swiping left and right that swiping up and down is just a natural, logical extension. Clunkily clicking a button (and having to move your hand down to that button) seems like such an old fashioned, awkward thing to do.

I admit I still forget and find myself searching for a button to click, but I’ve only had the phone a few hours. And a few times I’ve clicked the side button because it’s a button and my brain is saying “click something to get the home screen — click anything!”

Set-up

This was mostly incredibly smooth thanks to some new features. My iPhone 7+ magically detected the presence of my brand new X and asked me if I wanted to set it up. It then transferred all the settings and whatnot to the X. The X realised it needed to update the system software, so I did so. All this in one slick manoeuvre. It transferred over my Apple Pay info, and it tried (but sadly failed) to transfer over my Apple Watch. (That marred an otherwise flawless and vastly improved procedure.) And everything seem to load onto the phone so quickly. No going off to have a cup of tea waiting for all the apps to load, for example.

Apps

More apps than I expected are iPhone X compatible, which was great. I was surprised slash angry about some that weren’t. Google Maps isn’t. Amazon Prime isn’t. What? These are a couple of the biggest companies in the world and they can’t be arsed to update their apps? Well, Google Maps is gone from my phone. Forget it.

Some of my banking apps were native, some not. (I have a weirdly large number of accounts.) (I just picked up my phone to check which ones. As I picked it up the phone woke up. The notifications were there, but no detail. A fraction of a second later, the detail appeared as Face ID recognised I was looking at the phone. Brilliant. Love it.)

Microsoft Excel is native, so is Facebook and Twitter. And BBC News, Overcast, BBC iPlayer, Netflix, TSB banking app, Tesco banking app, Clydesdale B banking app, EE app, . . . even Scottish Power! Tumblr, Instagram, Quora, Plex, Dropbox . . .

But not Sky, HSBC, Kindle, Amex, MBNA, Barclaycard — big, lazy companies.

Non-native apps open in a rectangular window, so the X basically turns into a regular iPhone 7, with black strips top and bottom.

Oh yeah. This thing is fast. It doesn’t make you wait for anything.

The notch (and other horrors)

The notch doesn’t bother me at all. Not one bit. Actually, I like it. It lets me know this is an iPhone X. It gives it character. I like how the “ears” are used. I don’t often watch videos on my iPhone. And, if I do, they’re often not widescreen anyway.

The grey bar at the bottom of the keyboard — I wouldn’t even know that was a thing if I hadn’t read about it on these forums. Same goes for a lot of complaints people have made. I just wouldn’t even have noticed them.

Is it weirdly tall and thin? No. It’s elegant and comfortable to hold. Are sideways apps rubbish? No. Calendar now gives you six days when you go sideways instead of five. Perfect!

Conclusion

You’re going to have to pry this thing out of my cold, dead hands. Yes it’s massively expensive. But it’s just so damned good. I have zero regrets. None. My iPhone 7+ is dead to me. It looks like some sad antique. I don’t miss the larger screen. There’s plenty going on on the X screen — and in much more readable, beautiful, clear form. I love how the X looks and how it feels. I love the speed. Honestly, I can’t think of anything I don’t like about it.

I’m very glad I upgraded. It’s a huge upgrade.

I’m back in love with Apple again.

I’ve ordered the Apple folio case and the Apple not-leather-whatever-that-plastic-thing is case. They arrive on Tuesday. I’m not going to bother with a charging pad until the Apple one comes out.
 
Last edited:
Shhhhhhh, don’t let on that you like it, people round these parts don’t take kindly to satisfied customers :D

Seriously, it’s good that you’re pleased with it. It’s always nice to hear something other than complaining.

I’m with you on the gestures. I love them, just feels like such a natural way to get around a touch device.
 
Glad you’re happy with it. Especially coming from a plus. I echo many of your sentiments but I came from a 7. I have had faceid stop working on me a couple of times and had to reset the phone...

Get ready for the “plus is better” folks to poop on your party.
 
Question how is about charging speed? Heat from the phone? BIGGEE...are you using a screen protector?

Mine will be here on Wednesday...very excited to get it...NICE REVIEW. Thanks.

Too early to know anything about the charging speed. Though, to be honest I’m not worried. I always charge my phones to 100% overnight. Then I have a charger in every room if I run out of juice before the end of the day. Indeed, not having the battery percentage indicator might be quite nice. One less thing to stress over.

Heat? Not experience any problems there, despite all the things the phone had to do when it was setting itself up.

Screen protector? Never. Never ever ever ever ever. No. No. No.

I’m trialling the two cases I’ve ordered — I’m not ruling out going naked. Maybe I’ll get AppleCare if I do.

I literally couldn’t be happier. My expectations have been exceeded by this phone.
 
It’s a great phone. I especially like the camera.
...The thing is...it feels a bit like beta for now...small things here and there, especially gestures. For example, I can’t reach the control center with one hand, reachability requires a very precise svipe down, I don’t get why I need to press side button to continue with Face ID in the App Store, Sandbox is kind of glichy/broken in iOS11, etc.

But I believe this all will get better integrater over time.
 
The reason I asked about the screen protector...like you, I have never used one before. But I do have 2 different kinds already here at the house and ready to put on...I have the Anker Karapak and the iCarez. Again...I have used zero screen protectors of the 7 different models I have owned over the years...but kinda leery this year.
 
Since you owned a 7+, if theres one thing you miss from the 7+ or something that it does better, which?

And do you notice a big difference in cam?
 
I've had mine since 11/3, and I love it, too. The screen is gorgeous: I love what HDR does for the color. I came from a 7 Plus, and I love the new form factor. I used to have a jailbreak app where I could swipe up to go back to the home screen from any app, so I'm enjoying not having a home button. Great device.
 
Since you owned a 7+, if theres one thing you miss from the 7+ or something that it does better, which?

And do you notice a big difference in cam?

Haven’t used the camera yet, so no information on that.

What do I miss from my 7+? I have a couple of banking apps that aren’t optimised for the X. This means two things. First, the app is basically regular 7 sized and plonked in the middle of the screen with two big bezels top and bottom. Which is a bit rubbish. Second, with no Touch ID (and they’re not optimised for the X, so no Face ID, either) I have to enter passwords to access them. Which is annoying.

That’s about it.
[doublepost=1511046508][/doublepost]
If I were you I’d snatch up one of these Needified wireless chargers. They’re having a huge sale right now. I have one on my bedside table and just ordered another one for my desk in the office.

https://needified.com/products/add-iphone-8-8-plus-wireless-charger-at-50-off?variant=1845383036958

The one I ordered earlier I found on Facebook and was free with $9.97 shipping. Can’t find the link though. $20 is still a solid deal.

No use to me. I’m in the UK.
 
Thanks for the review. Very interesting to me as I have a 7+ and am awaiting an X on order.

Are you going to keep the 7+ as spare, or sell?
 
I knew you would fold ;)

It was nice to read your excited review! I have to agree with your points. I never really fell away from Apple, but the X certainly has me feeling like I am in love all over again.

Enjoy your X!
 
It is 2 weeks since I got my own X. After 2 days, I was planning to return it and even went to the Apple store to try out the 8+. Coming from a 7+ to X, I was having problems adjusting to the smaller width key board and my text input speed fell dramatically. However after 8 days or so I got used to this. There is no way I would return my X. I love it. In fact, I keep it away when with friends. I don't even want to pass it on to people to see it and thus do not disclose I own an X. The colors are so real, the face ID is so fast, and the phone is really fast. I change phones every year so the incremental changes while welcome are not usually something that thrill me like the X does.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jetcat3
I came from the 7+ too and I absolutely love the X. I don't watch videos on my phone that often so I don't mind that video size from the X is a tiny bit smaller. Looking at my 7+ now I feel like there is so much empty space on the home screen whereas the X is just right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: haruhiko
Great review. Thanks.

Just a guess about the watch backup. You need to unpair the watch on the old phone to get the backup for the watch. Then switch your data to a new phone, then pair the watch to the new phone.
 
Plus is better

.
.
.

Just kidding had a 8 plus and upgraded to the X and no issues here
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.