Yosemite helps me to realise the beauty of Mavericks.
I don't know. Apple
does have a way of making their previous UI instantly look
old-fashioned when they come up with
something new. The thing is, personally I'm more concerned with usability rather than looks (that's what I'm telling myself away...
😛 ). If the beauty of a UI actually serves to help me more easily 'parse' the UI then that's good (in my opinion, Mavericks does so in
spades using different shades,gradients,sculpted virtual buttons etc. in order to clearly structure and separate UI from content), but if it's merely
superfluous eye candy that only serves to
distract (how much of that aspect is actually present in Mavericks' UI, I'd only be able to say with a little more distance) , then I think the design should be reduced to simpler elements, as Yosemite appears to attempt. I'm not sure how successful it is actually going to be in that regard, that is to visually simplify without getting rid of helpful affordances, and although I'm more than a little skeptical about the benefit of all of the additional translucency I'm willing to give all of that a chance (after all, it's too late to
substantially change anything at this point anyway, and at least they didn't take away the button shapes …– I feared much worse after iOS 7, and I managed to mostly get used to
that one). I'm pretty sure Yosemite is going to look beautiful, and I'm hopeful that usability-wise it will be (at least) on the same level as Mavericks as well.
<- sorry for this mess of a paragraph...