Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Have we not learned from now that the big updates we will have to buy from apple. Either buy it or don't. Are we going to hear this all the time we have to buy the new updates?
 
Presumably there will be a way to dodge paying anyhow, through a reset and getting given the option to get 2.1 - wasn't there a way to do that with the update to 2.0? Anyhow -you might get future 2.x updates for free. A fiver ain't that bad really. Don't have to download and pay if you don't think it's worth it...
 
Angry Geek stop calling people trolls. the legal reason is $$$. You Apple mark.
It's not really a legal reason but you're still a troll. It's accounting as someone else actually stated.

Whether you find value in the upgrade fee or not is entirely up to you. If you own a touch and $10 is hard to come by then I question how responsible you are with your finances overall.
 
Um, "decided to charge for accounting simplification reasons" would be more accurate.

But, yeah, why should people pay to upgrade from 1 to 2.0 but not pay to upgrade from 1 to 2.1?

Lots of potential reasons...
Maybe Apple considers X.y to X.(y+1) upgrades minor, unpaid upgrades, whereas they consider X.y to (X+1).y upgrades major, paid upgrades.

Alternatively, maybe they accounted for the revenue they generated through the 1.x to 2.x upgrade over the course of several years, so that GAP allows them to offer free upgrades subsequently.
 
The charge to iPod Touch owners is obviously bad business. For anyone with a $399 16gb 1st gen Touch who is still running 1.? firmware, you're now going to have to pay another $10 to make your (now $409) Touch almost as good as a new $299 16gb Touch. Double slap in the face.
 
The charge to iPod Touch owners is obviously bad business. For anyone with a $399 16gb 1st gen Touch who is still running 1.? firmware, you're now going to have to pay another $10 to make your (now $409) Touch almost as good as a new $299 16gb Touch. Double slap in the face.

What? Your logic doesn't make any sense. Yes the newer models are cheaper, the price drop has been expected for a while. It costs $10 to upgrade to 2.0 due to accounting purporses, I don't know why anyone would be running 1.xx in the first place, 2.1 is quite stable. Early adopters always get screwed over, that's life.
 
It's not really a legal reason but you're still a troll. It's accounting as someone else actually stated.

Whether you find value in the upgrade fee or not is entirely up to you. If you own a touch and $10 is hard to come by then I question how responsible you are with your finances overall.

That has nothing to do with anything. You don't pay for OSX updates, why pay for an update for an ipod?
 
um... you guys do know that it's free if you already payed for 2.0, right?

Besides, if it's that huge of a deal google ipod 2.1 firmware.

there ya go >.>
 
That has nothing to do with anything. You don't pay for OSX updates, why pay for an update for an ipod?
The 2.0 update is more of an OS upgrade than a bug fix. It's like going from Windows XP to Windows Vista, which you have to pay for. 2.0 to 2.1 is more like a service pack, which is free.
 
I know there are ways around paying for the upgrade, thats not the point.

Were in dangerous territory. Paying to upgrade the firmware on a device? Whats next? Having to pay for updates for itunes?
 
I know there are ways around paying for the upgrade, thats not the point.

Were in dangerous territory. Paying to upgrade the firmware on a device? Whats next? Having to pay for updates for itunes?
Of course not. They sell stuff on iTunes.
 
I know there are ways around paying for the upgrade, thats not the point.

Were in dangerous territory. Paying to upgrade the firmware on a device? Whats next? Having to pay for updates for itunes?

How is that unusual? Maybe not for iTunes, but lots of software does that. You have to pay to upgrade Office:Mac 2004 to 2008. Or, as I just went through recently, you buy version 3.x of software X, they come out with version 4.0, you have to pay to upgrade. 4.1, 4.2, and so on are free updates if you already own 4.0.

Or did you expect to buy a software package once and expect free updates for life?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.