Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
How does one stream Apple Music to a Google Home speaker!!!!??
 
How does one stream Apple Music to a Google Home speaker!!!!??

I've yet to figure that out. I was trying to send music to a friend's google home and couldn't do it.

I know you can add Apple Music to google home, if you own/manage the speaker, but not if you are just wanting to send it to someone else's speaker.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pinkyyy 💜🍎
the fact that spotify still doesnt support homepod is....
… intentional and deliberate. (If that is what you were hinting at with the ellipsis at the end of your sentence.)

By all indication Spotify doesn’t want to support the HomePod. Spotify very easily could support the HomePod if it wanted to. There is no technical reason why Spotify hasn’t already done so.
 
I prefer AirPlay vs native support when using my HomePod. Why? Because with AirPlay and a VPN, I can listen to foreign streaming services on my HomePod here in Japan even when those services are geo-blocked.
 
How is YouTube music? The attractiveness is they bundle it with ad free YouTube plus screen off youtube.
YT Music's pretty good. One thing I miss from Spotify is using one device as a remote control (ex. iPhone) to switch tracks on the music-playing device (iPad/iMac etc). I find Apple Music cumbersome, whether it's the on the Mac or on the mobile devices.

Together with ad-free YT, it's a massive hit. Apple TV is no competition for YouTube.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pinkyyy 💜🍎
I wish YT music supported cellular streaming on the watch. If they're working on the homepod, maybe that gives us hope for the future support in apple-ecosystems.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pinkyyy 💜🍎
You can place HomePods in all your rooms and then automatically have voice control everywhere hands-free without having to turn anything else on or having to carry any device with you. That's what people want and dumb speakers don’t give you.
You have to have the associated iPhone powered on if you want to add things to a Reminders list, call someone, check or send messages, run shortcuts, etc.

If you have a "dumb" speaker next to your iPhone, for example, instead of having a HomePod, you can do all of those things. The only advantage there of the HomePod is the mic array (and probably the sound quality if you're not using a mini).
 
Not any phone or any computer. Also, phones or computers that can presently play audio to the HomePod might lose that ability once software updates start becoming impossible on one or more devices.

The moral of the story is that smart speakers gives you something that the others do not, and viceversa. No tech device ever is going to do everything all the time, much less seamlessly. And that´s ok. It´s all about needs, preferences, and compromises, like everything else in life.


Homepods, within it´s category (smart speakers world), are not, at all, by any means whatsoever, platform/content agnostic. You can´t even activate them without an IOS device. And that´s fine. If you want that, go with Sonos or Google.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pinkyyy 💜🍎
One of the biggest problems with smart speakers is that it strips the owner of the speaker from direct control of what they can enjoy on them. Much like how "the cloud" puts strangers in between people and their data, smart speakers also wedge strangers in between people and full use of a very simple piece of technology. The strangers get to decide if the speaker can natively play this or that instead of the owner of the speaker.

For this and other reasons, I'm a forever fan of "dumb" speakers, which just play... anything I throw at them... with no preferences/biases/etc and no approval by for-profit strangers and/or dealmaking requirements between strangers. I have various computing devices with the "smarts" in them if I want any of that kind of control. IMO speakers and storage do NOT need gatekeepers, toll booth operators, etc.

Speaking only for myself: those happy to have new kinds of middlemen wedged in, enjoy those kinds of services. I am able to see some very select benefits... but none of them are important enough to me to let strangers become middlemen for my data or audio.
Yep, that's why I ditched my Sonos for a Denon Home 150. It's still a smart speaker, but also has an aux-in and BT connection.
 
One thing that is great is that it doesn’t just include the catalogs from music labels, but also any music content users have uploaded to YouTube, thus filling the gaps that other streaming services leave open.
This is why i like it, you can listen to mixes, old versions of albums that have been remastered, really the audio to just about any youtube video. It's pretty sick
 
Obligatory Spotify Community link to go and add your voice if you care about Spotify implementing this, if you haven't already.

They will continue to ignore it, but it's the 9th most requested feature now, and the youngest request on the top 10 list by more than a year, so we can at least "hold their feet to the fire" about it.
 
“Dumb” speakers have no phone or computer dependencies, no OS requirements, no connection type requirements, etc. Play from phone- iPhone or your friends Android- or turntable or Betamax or Edison’s gramophone. Play from computer, or first gen iPod or Amiga output or Sony Walkman, cassette deck, Aunt Meg's SuperVHS player, CD players, reel to reel, 35mm film, Kinescope, etc.

Bring ANY device over and it will play audio on “dumb” speakers.
Ya, because in 2023, what people exactly are playing music in those formats….?
 
Ya, because in 2023, what people exactly are playing music in those formats….?

A lot of people play LPs and have a nice collection.

I have a decent amount of music that isn't on any streaming service, anywhere, including YouTube. I could rip it I guess, but I haven't. Some of it is on CD, some of it is on LP, some on cassette.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The YouTube Music iPhone App is the worst music App I've ever used. As if they did;t even try. Probably got a couple of interns and asked them to modify the YouTube App and call it a day.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.