I have no doult that AT&T is capable to find out if you are tethering or not, but I don't think they have the man power and resource to catch or monitor all the high data user.
I think it's related to 4.3 update. I'll be staying on 4.2.1 until this gets worked out.
Nope on modmyI they have been posting 4.01 4.1 4.2.1 and 4.3 all
It was mywI users
Lots of theories of how
And it's way more then a few, At&t upgraded the system to detect this, it's new and automated
Some AT&T iPhone users, Jailbroken and tethering via MyWi, are getting text messages and e-mails from AT&T that imply they know they are tethering even though they arent on an official tethering plan. One of our own writers, Andrew was one of those who received the message.
I use MyWi to tether as well but have not received anything yet. (I actually was just tethering today.) Im not sure how they are detecting MyWi users but I can make an educated guess.
I think its one of two things. Since AT&T offers Personal Hotspot under iOS 4.3, they may have access to data they didnt before, and theyre choosing to use it in a pretty crappy way. So if youre on iOS 4.2.1 still (almost all jailbreakers are) and they see youre generating traffic that looks like Personal Hotspot, they know youre doing so without a plan. Once a jailbreak for iOS 4.3 is released, I bet it will make it a lot harder for them to track what users are actually tethering legitimately. Option two, theyre just going after heavy data users again and trying to bluff them into switching to a tethering plan and losing their unlimited data. Andrew tethers a heck of a lot more than me. I only consume a fraction of what he does. So thats a viable answer too.
Originally Jailbreakers used MyWi because AT&T took a year longer to offer iPhone tethering than international carriers. Since then theyve used it to get around AT&Ts ridiculous fees for tethering. (Tethering is free on some international carriers as well.)
Hit the jump to read the e-mail AT&T has been sending out as well as to let us know what you think! Anyone else been getting messages from AT&T? Anyone on iOS 4.3 using official Personal Hotspot? Any PDANet users?
LOL no I tether, in fact I would join a class action suit against the charge for tethering, I contend its Double dipping. WHy pay for the same service twice?
This was a very reasonable clause back when data plans offered unlimited data. However now that they are limiting usage, it seems less reasonable to also limit what you can do.
LOL no I tether, in fact I would join a class action suit against the charge for tethering, I contend its Double dipping. WHy pay for the same service twice?
LOL yeah right....... There is no such thing as a scam being allowed, the test of the class action suit is that the Carriers have exclusive rights to us ( the feds regulate the companies ) and we have little choice in who we use, just a handful of companies. Also the idea they can just charge more for use, charge more for the same data use....... Come on they are wrong,
Its like here's a glass of water, you pay a $1 for it and you pour it on your head, oh that will be a $1 more, why? You used the water on your body and thats now a shower and they are $2, if you drank the same water it would be $1.
The data use is the same if I look at a website with the phone or on my Laptop.
I don't want to subsidize people who want to tether, and I certainly don't want to subsidize people who steal tethering via jailbreaking. So all of this is good news.
.
Sounds like ATT's masterplan to get folks off of grandfathered unlimited data .......................
I think its more simply to have its customers pay for the feature that they should have been paying for.
There are reports of "Unlimited" users getting this notice, even if they don't tether, because they use a lot of data.
It's actually pretty easy for AT&T to tell who is tethering...
All they have to do is run some sort of a packet sniffer and look at the browser agent strings. If they start seeing Firefox, Internet Explorer, or Chrome strings there's no doubt you are tethering.
I applaud AT&T for cracking down on this.
If this is the case, and I think it is, there could definitely be a class action lawsuit here as they don't have any way to prove tethering, and with Netflix, radio and hulu people can use gobs of data without tethering
I think it's related to 4.3 update. I'll be staying on 4.2.1 until this gets worked out.
It's actually pretty easy for AT&T to tell who is tethering...
All they have to do is run some sort of a packet sniffer and look at the browser agent strings. If they start seeing Firefox, Internet Explorer, or Chrome strings there's no doubt you are tethering.
I applaud AT&T for cracking down on this.
Its the other way around, actually. Since there is no 4.3 JB yet, there is no way to unofficially tether on 4.3.
And what if they aren't using a web browser?
All the carriers could fix this by making everyone pay in 500MB chunks of like a few dollars. Say 5 dollars per 500MB then allow you to tether and use as much data as you want. That way the folks that don't use a lot of data wont subsidize those who do.You are not paying for the same service twice.
Since my service charge would go up if they did that I do not agree with you. They charge for their plans based on how much data the average person uses on those plans. If they included tethering with them, the average usage would go up, and thus they would charge EVERYONE more for the 2 gigs of data even those who do not tether. I prefer the people who want to tether pay for it, and the people who do not want to pay for it do not have to... I know this is a seemingly hard concept for people to absorb and I am not sure why...
The bottom line though is simple. If they included tethering with the data packages they have now, the data price for those packages would go up in price for everyone.
...snip...
So you can like it or not like.. As someone who wants to tether I am sure you don't care that you only have to pay $5 more to tether while someone else has to pay $5 more and get no benefit for it, but for the people who don't want to tether they get screwed. They don't want to subsidize you and your tethering. What the tethering plan does is allow the people who want to tether to pay for that, while allowing people who do not want to tether to have a lower more affordable cost.
Again, if they included tethering in the 2 gig package, then the cost of the 2 gig package would become more expensive for everyone. Why? Because the average amount of data being used would go up. So everyone would pay more. Again, if they included tethering in the 2 gig package, then the cost of the 2 gig package would become more expensive for everyone.
I don't want to subsidize people who want to tether, and I certainly don't want to subsidize people who steal tethering via jailbreaking. So all of this is good news. ...snip...
That's a case you'd lose.
When you sign a contract and agree to the ToS, there likely is language that does not allow tethering. That you agreed to unlimited data for use through that specific device.
Not saying that I would never tether on my unlimited plan but it has to be done within reason.
All you can eat buffetts can still turn you away after a point.
It's specifically stated in the ToS. You cannot tether without a tethering plan.
http://www.wireless.att.com/learn/articles-resources/wireless-terms.jsp
Located in Section 6.2 of the AT&T Wireless Customer Agreement.