WRONG. Take a look at the second pic I posted above. (The angle is particularly difficult to replicate) Unless this guys is a pro @ PS, there are always traces of the edit.
----------
You think he added in the entire area with the volume keys on the right side?
I don't think so.
Edit: People also said the 5 on the A5 processor was PS'd because it was crooked. They were wrong.
Ok dude, you're killing me. This is a rendering. Also seen here for a different phone on their site. http://www.otterbox.com/commuter-series-cases/commuter-series-cases,default,sc.html
No one is moving the keys to the other side of the iPhone. The box you show the back of says nothing about the 4S on it. You can keep this charade up as long as you want. This is complete garbage!