I do not think anyone will be surprised when the watch flops. As jewelry it is uninspiring at best and clunky at worst, As must have gadget, it's not. All it needed to was was look good, but the iPod nana watch looked better without even trying.
You know, you are right. The nano ipod as a watch looks heaps better.
Geez I hope the watch is so much better in hand, than in pictures.
As you said, as a jewellery accessory, it looks cheap and plain, compared to dress watches.
----------
questions of methodology aside, this isn't a shock. The watch is designed to appeal to fitness freaks, frequent shoppers etc. Kids if they are shopping are using mom or dad's credit card or cash. The Watch isn't likely to work for them cause Daddy would never let them keep a card on it and use it without asking first. And kids are perhaps sporty but not 'fitness freaks' that count every step
If it's designed for frequent shoppers, it will be a flop around the world as apple pay is going to be US only for the first generation of the watch.
The fitness angle would have appealed to me, though it has very limited sensors and the battery life is a huge concern. If it's a one day charge, that's a deal breaker. It would have to last a weekend away.
Though if those two are the main selling points, teenagers are not going to care.