Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[WW] Battle of Plains d'Abraham - see results of DAY 4!

Wouldn't vote for rick now either (excluding Moyank obviously). Just wanted to point out that neither of us seems clear to me.

Ravenvii is suspicious just because he outed himself that late imo. I'm going to look at Mo's votes and posts day 1-2 but don't really think there's much to be found since we made it pretty easy for the wolves to lay low.

Pluto plays weird anyway. :D Always worth a second look. My question to you still stands btw, Pluto.
 
For what it's worth:

rick seems rather unsuspicious to me after re-reading the thread. He did stress to check out those who voted for Koodauw day1 multiple times out of the blue, which includes Moyank who is a known baddie now.

Pluto plays fairly lamoyant, appears when asked but his postcount sure dropped after the first day/night. Still to be seen if his nephew's uncle's of second degree birthday really is the reason.

Ravenvii, came out late with his super power. Maybe there's a reason, if he's a baddie there would be plenty of reason to come out this late. Would be probably my no1 after Moyank's demise.

Tomorrow just re-appeared after signing in. :p

scepticalscribe, difficult to read for me, constantly contributing. Voted for Pluto (1st vote), techGod (2nd vote after mine) and me day1. Called me " less intellectually well endowed". Which is probably correct. Don't have a bad feeling tbh.

Twietee runs rampage, and not in a good way. No baddie either. :(


Mo, raven and pluto would be my favs so far, but I'll check out the thread later once more. With Raven being a WW and one of Mo and Pluto being infected. I just don't think he'd come out that late and the probability that he was a Morpher who got infected and choose the vacant Oracle seems highly unlikely - would've been one helluva gamble. Also he was a runner-up day two and involved in Koodauw's killing - not a good infction candidate if you ask me.

ninja'd by rick.
agreed re raven, I have my doubts re Pluto but nothing substantial
 
twietee said:
For what it's worth:

rick seems rather unsuspicious to me after re-reading the thread. He did stress to check out those who voted for Koodauw day1 multiple times out of the blue, which includes Moyank who is a known baddie now.
Click to expand...

twietee, there is no way im bad, geez. you are trying way to hard.

all we had at that time was day 1 voting, so of course im going to look at who voted for a good guy to die, chances 1 out of 3 are bad. and boom, it turned out correct.

now with raven looking like he outed a baddie, what a great infection that could be.

i tried super hard to get moyank killed, which wasnt happening if it wasnt for me. why in the heck would i do that if she had no heat on her. whateva.
 
rick snagwell said:
twietee, there is no way im bad, geez. you are trying way to hard.
Click to expand...

You didn't read the rest, did you?

And as long as you can't prove your innocence you're somewhat suspicious to me.

But, if you prefer it that way :

Mo


raven

Pluto
Tomorrow

scepticalscribe







rick

----------
rick snagwell said:
now with raven looking like he outed a baddie, what a great infection that could be.
Click to expand...

You think the infection isn't in play already?

----------

Alright, not that you're totally luring me in: your day1 vote doesn't really count in my book. You said it yourself: you do that all.the.time. For going that hard after Moyank you actually never voted for her afterwards. Not even when you had to choose between her and QoS! Care to elaborate?

You just moved some inches further to the top again. If you are a goodie: you weren't such a bad candidate for an infection yourself. If you are a baddie: voting for your fellow wolf isn't unheard of either.
 
rick snagwell said:
i see pluto dying tonight.
Click to expand...

Why is that? Either you or raven should be the top candidates for a nightly dinner, right? Geez, the more I think about you, the more I question my own list.

Hopefully the Hunter is alive and lucky this night. Would be 2 villagers vs 2 (possible) wolves the day after tomorrow when no protection occurs. Let's cross our fingers Mo isn't the Kami! If yes, this looks like a huge set-up..
 
Plutonius said:
The WW's never kill me in these games (villagers are a different story :D) so I'm not too worried (Note - Hunter, don't waste your protection on me).

I see SS or Tomorrow targeted tonight.
Click to expand...

True, could be.

I was never tageted by wolves either. They prefer me to bring mischief upon my very own village. To be honest, I voted for all three innocently lynched now - I should be under heavy suspicion by now.

Any ideas though? What do you think of ravenvii? I always have a hard time to read him due him being totally erratic (for me that is).

Do you have a list?
 
twietee said:
Do you have a list?
Click to expand...

Based on Moyank's voting,

Day1: WWs usually take different picks day 1 unless forced otherwise.

koodauw: 3 (moyank, ravenvii, twietee)
twietee: 3 (techgod, chrmjenkins, scepticalscribe)
ravenvii: 2 (dontpanic, queenofspades)
Dontpanic: 1 (plutonius)
moyank: 1 (ricksnagwell)
queenofspades: 1 (koodauw)
ricsnagwell: 1 (tomorrow)

I would somewhat clear Ravenvii but not Twietee (Twietee had to vote along with Moyank as self preservation). It doesn't mean that Twietee is a WW.

Rick is still possibility since the one vote for Moyank was early and meaningless.

Myself and Tomorrow also had meaningless votes.

If Twietee isn't a WW, SS is a very good choice for a WW since you tend to attract more attention for meaningless votes. If Twietee is a WW, I would mostly clear SS.

Day2:
3 - Chrmjenkins : Sceptical Scribe (157) ; Twietee (189) ; Ravenvii (199)
3 - Ravenvii : Rick Snagwell (151) ; Queen of spades (186) ; Chrmjenkins (202)
2 - Queen of spades : Don't Panic (159) ; Plutonius (188)

Did not vote : Tomorrow, Moyank24

If we assume Ravenvii isn't a WW based on the day1 voting and his oracle question, none of the three are WWs (i.e. doesn't matter who people voted for).
Ravenvii also had the oracle power so he wasn't the collapser. The collapser could have ended the day when Ravenvii was selected but instead waited for Chrmjenkins.

Day3:

Unfortunately, everyone voted after the oracle question.
 
twietee said:
For what it's worth:

…...
scepticalscribe, difficult to read for me, constantly contributing. Voted for Pluto (1st vote), techGod (2nd vote after mine) and me day1. Called me " less intellectually well endowed". Which is probably correct. Don't have a bad feeling tbh.




Mo, raven and pluto would be my favs so far, but I'll check out the thread later once more. With Raven being a WW and one of Mo and Pluto being infected. I just don't think he'd come out that late and the probability that he was a Morpher who got infected and choose the vacant Oracle seems highly unlikely - would've been one helluva gamble. Also he was a runner-up day two and involved in Koodauw's killing - not a good infction candidate if you ask me.
Click to expand...

Did I say or write that? How dreadfully discourteous of me. I do apologise.

For now, I think that Pluto and ravenvii could do with some attention; and for the sake of whatever divinity we say we subscribe to, would someone please ensure that Moyank is unable to wreak any further havoc?
 
Last edited:
When the lost of Queen of spade really sinked in, Scepticalscribe ran to the secret closet of Don't Panic, a range nice old scotch where nicely packed.

She knew about them, Don't Panic, Melrose and her were collectors of fine drink. All her friends were gone crossing Styx's river. She will drink to honor them, to ease the pain, to find peace, maybe bring them a bottle if she really hold it tight.

Sadly, silhouettes where already there waiting for her....

"That's almost too easy..." someone said

Those were the last word Scepticalscribe heard before the gunpowder exploded .....

It's now Day 4 until Tuesday 7 PM EDT Lock majority = 4
 
You rowdy old wolves... I can sense you guys. Might I state I am watching from the sidelines curious as to who will be your next victim. Go my dear wolves, go and eat them all!

Oh, poor Scepticalscribe, she didn't make it... tragic indeed.
 
rick snagwell said:
wow, i must be tired as klfdjas;flaskd. i swore we already handled that. lol


moyank!

why is raven voting for me!?
Click to expand...

Actually, I'm wondering if the game is over. We have 6 living players and theoretically 3 of them are WW's.

If the game is not over, the WW's would try to get in early votes to lock it down (i.e. Ravenvii is probably a WW). Since, you, I and Tomorrow voted for Moyank, that makes Twietee the 3rd WW (if there are three).
 
Plutonius said:
Actually, I'm wondering if the game is over. We have 6 living players and theoretically 3 of them are WW's.

If the game is not over, the WW's would try to get in early votes to lock it down (i.e. Ravenvii is probably a WW). Since, you, I and Tomorrow voted for Moyank, that makes Twietee the 3rd WW (if there are three).
Click to expand...

dammit, knew it too.
 
Sheesh..Might report Moyank's vote for being frivolious..

If the next wolf is the kami, we are f'd (infection being in play). If we don't kill Moyank, this might be the very first game not one single wolf got caught...... technically.

I might revisit my rick, raven, mo24 theory. Pluto, yep, defo up there too, Tomorrow I don't really see it, would've been too boring.

Since I don't think Raven got infected, there could be a 50/50 shot at Mo24 being the Infectée and hence not the Kami.
 
Plutonius said:
Day1 voting: I would somewhat clear Ravenvii

..

If we assume Ravenvii isn't a WW based on the day1 voting and his oracle question,
Click to expand...

Can't follow you. Why is ravenvii clear because of his voting? Why is he clear because of his oracle question? If anything that would make rick look good, who suggested asking QoS and Moyank - nobody interfered - and would make ravenvii look really weird asking different names instead.

I'm crossing fingers that Moyank isn't the kami, but got a really bad feeling.
Man, Pluto, why did you have to play so dubious this time? :D Would have preferred to go for rick (than raven) if it wasn't for you..
 
Plutonius said:
Based on Moyank's voting,

Day1: WWs usually take different picks day 1 unless forced otherwise.

koodauw: 3 (moyank, ravenvii, twietee)
twietee: 3 (techgod, chrmjenkins, scepticalscribe)
ravenvii: 2 (dontpanic, queenofspades)
Dontpanic: 1 (plutonius)
moyank: 1 (ricksnagwell)
queenofspades: 1 (koodauw)
ricsnagwell: 1 (tomorrow)

I would somewhat clear Ravenvii but not Twietee (Twietee had to vote along with Moyank as self preservation). It doesn't mean that Twietee is a WW.

Rick is still possibility since the one vote for Moyank was early and meaningless.

Myself and Tomorrow also had meaningless votes.

If Twietee isn't a WW, SS is a very good choice for a WW since you tend to attract more attention for meaningless votes. If Twietee is a WW, I would mostly clear SS.

Day2:
3 - Chrmjenkins : Sceptical Scribe (157) ; Twietee (189) ; Ravenvii (199)
3 - Ravenvii : Rick Snagwell (151) ; Queen of spades (186) ; Chrmjenkins (202)
2 - Queen of spades : Don't Panic (159) ; Plutonius (188)

Did not vote : Tomorrow, Moyank24

If we assume Ravenvii isn't a WW based on the day1 voting and his oracle question, none of the three are WWs (i.e. doesn't matter who people voted for).
Ravenvii also had the oracle power so he wasn't the collapser. The collapser could have ended the day when Ravenvii was selected but instead waited for Chrmjenkins.

Day3:

Unfortunately, everyone voted after the oracle question.
Click to expand...

Alright Pluto, here we go:

May be all theoretical by now, but who knows.

Day 1: You said it yourself: my vote can be explained as being self-preservation. Why does that make me look worse than ravenvii, who was the first to cast a second vote on somebody at all? Can't follow you at all.

SS is (unfortunately) cleared now.

rick, tomorrow and you with seemingly throwaway votes. Which would still look good if one got found out later (regarding Rick and Tomorrow - you voted for DP who is cleared).

Day2: Mo24 and Tomorrow MIA but Moyank was around at deadline:

this is what the voting order looked like ~4h before deadline:

2 - Ravenvii : Rick Snagwell (151) ; Queen of spades (186)
2 - Queen of spades : Don't Panic (159) ; Plutonius (188)
2 - Chrmjenkins : Sceptical Scribe (157) ; Twietee (189)
1 - Rick Snagwell : Chrmjenkins (180)

not voted yet : Tomorrow, Moyank24, Ravenvii


Cpt. Moyank, a known traitor and follower of the late General Wolfe, was posting after that without voting.

Assuming that not two wolves get missing at the very same time, Pluto's vote, cast shortly after QoS vote for raven (his second- making him the top lynching candidate) could be read in a way to save raven, as could be mine after that for chrmjenkins. And, here's the thing: after both raven and chrmjenkin's voted for each other, the collapser occurred. Me. I wasn't sure of it, but alas, I thought chrmjenkins was a real baddie and ravenvii innocent. Wouldn't exactly do it the same way again. ever. I promise! :D

Now, and here's the second part that make me hope not all is lost: Pluto hinted (#246) at knowing why the collapser acted the way he did without any further comment. Strange imo, because totally out of the blue. Unless he's the infected Seer who was trying to nod at me, so I wouldn't suspect him too much. He did that when I called him out (#229 even voted for him Day 3) for being MIA.

Day 3: Makes me hope Rick made a good call with QoS and Mo, ravenvii (assuming him being a WW, btw outed himself after Pluto got the first and only vote at that time Day3) waited, nobody really opposed, and made the call. You are wrong that all votes had been cast after the Oracle asked its question. I voted for you, rick for me (strangely after ravenvii outed himself). There was (somewhat strangely) no debate wheter QoS or Moyank should be voted for. Cut-throat.

So I'd say Mo and Raven being the WWs with Pluto being infected.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back