EJBasile said:
You know you can say that but unless gas gets over $5 SUVs won't be going anywhere. Some SUVs get the same fuel economy as minivans. What about pickup trucks. Think of how many people buy them and don't use the pickup function of them.
The popular pick-ups are MUCH cheaper than the popular SUVs and are only popular in rural areas where they are much more likely to be useful... dirt roads, more snow and less plows, etc. They also are real trucks built on a much more solid truck frame.
As far as minivans go, lets look at an example (data from fueleconomy.gov):
Honda Odyssey 2005: 28mpg highway, 20 city annual fuel costs: $1820
Honda Pilot 2005: 22mpg highway, 19 city, annual fuel costs: $2201
Both cars seat seven, but the odyssey uses 20% less fuel on average. Furthermore, maybe not in the case of the pilot, but in the case of many SUVs, the drivers are more likely to be driving alone when compared to minivans. I'm gonna take a guess and say the average # of people riding in the average large SUV is about 1.5, and in a minivan it's like 2.5. Now the avg mpg/person is about 30 for the SUV and is like 60 for the minivan. That makes the minivan twice as economical a car.
SUVs, especially the most glamourous ones like the big infinitis, H2s, Land Cruisers, all get horrid gas mileage, and are mostly bought in more urban areas where they don't even have the potential to be used for their off-road capabilities. People buy them not only because they are a fad, but because they feel safer and they ARE safer - the reason that they are safer is because there are other SUVs on the road that will slaughter any regular car in a collision. they feel safer because you are up high and can see the road. When you are in a car, that giant suburban in front of you blocks your entire field of vision, but if you are in that suburban you can see right over those tree huggers in their prius. You could get in an accident with an insight and the insight could be totalled while you only have a dented bumper.
The bottom line is that the gas guzzler tax needs to be doubled so that SUVs are priced like the unnecessary glamourous wastes that they are. In addition to that, car safety ratings should put equal weight on the damage a vehicle can do to other vehicles and the actual safety that vehicle provides for its passengers. Those dangerous vehicles need to be clearly labelled as such and, a tax should be applied to cover all money that is lost from the damage that vehicle can potentially do.
No SUV that gets less than 20mpg should cost less than 40k.
EDIT: I realize that was a rant and a rather off-topic one at that. The GMC are more work vehicles I suppose. Anyway, take it for what it is.