I had a dez moment watching the Hawks game yesterday. Wilson passed to Lynch but the defender dove and grabbed the pass, tumbled and came up with it – except, on the replay, his momentum carried the ball into the turf. He did remain in control of the ball, but it seems to me that the point of catching the ball is to keep it off the ground. If your momentum carries the ball into the ground, even if you are hanging onto it, that should not be a catch.
And no, I am not being partisan. If a play looks clean, I am fine with it going the wrong way. Not fine as in I like it, but the game should be clean (although, OTOH, I kind of object to replay rulings, because mistakes by the officials should be part of the game just like mistakes by players are).