Jon'sLightBulbs said:
...None of the complaints of 20 years ago have truly been fixed...
Er...What are you talking about? Diesel engines have come on leaps and bounds in the last 10years and in Europe they are fast gaining ground against petrol.
You specifically mention the BMW in-line 6 so lets take a look at the BMW specs for a 3.0Ltr 3-Series diesel on the left:
Max. Speed = 155mph 155mph
0-62mph = 6.7sec.s 6.3secs.
50-70mph = 5.0secs. 6.6secs.
Power = 231hp/4000rpm 258bhp/6600rpm
Torque = 500Nm/1750rpm 300Nm/2500rpm
Fuel economy = 43.5mpg 32.5mpg
Amongst all those figures the two that sell the diesel to me are the fuel economy and usable overtaking speed, the rest are pretty immaterial.
You say youve ridden in Fiat and Citroen diesel that smell and quake, have you actually driven them? Have you also driven the petrol equivalents from Fiat and Citroen? Ive got a petrol Renault that smells awful. Ive had petrol cars that would shake till they fell apart.
Compare like for like as in the BMW example above and diesels prove their worth.