When one checks off "Activate the phone" during the Pwnage Tool pwnage, then that's explicit 'hacktivation.' (Pwnage Tool = jailbreak/unlock utility that is only on the Mac platform). If RedSn0w, for either PC or Mac, automatically hacktivates when an official SIM is not present, then I dunno -- I'm not in tune with RedSn0w, because I don't use it. I'm guessing RedSn0w is the context iLover1 may have been speaking in early on about official SIMs being present and whatnot.I've concluded I'm somehow hactivated...... Although I've come across nothing definitive, except hactivation causes excessive battery drain.
As far as your research about hacktivation => battery drainage:
Yeah, there is this article that references unlockers on baseband 06.15.00: "the issue comes from iOS 4.1 and 4.2.1 which constantly look for valid push certificates." I had originally merely assumed that poor battery performance was something endemic to iOS 4.1, since the release notes on iOS 4.2 specifically mention "Improved Battery Performance".
I too have a battery draining iPhone: specifically a 3G on 4.1 with baseband 04.26.08. Pwning to 4.2.1 with SAM may ultimately be in my future, but..
...But before I re-pwn, I am going to toggle off Data and see what effect that has (its the last one to turn off...everything else - 3G,Wifi,bluetooth,multitasking - is already off). Since I am on baseband 04.26.08 and not on 06.15.00 as that article specifically mentions, I'm not 100% convinced that the hacktivation theory of battery drainage applies to me.
I'll report later on whether Data=off seems to have any effect.