The question was which between the two. If you want to discuss whether or not they are good phones at all, there are numerous threads for that.
But in this thread, the question began with the premise that those posting would have bought at least one or the other (perhaps both to see which they liked better). Since you haven't done any of the above, we're really not interested.
I personally couldn't disagree more with your assessment.
I couldn't careless what of mine you are interested in or not. You don't agree with me? Good for you. You won a prize now because 99.99% of the posters on this site do not agree with me. I prefer it like that.
And I happen to think the two phones the OP listed are pieces of crap, hence why I told him to choose neither.