Yes. Best Buy requires a two year service commitment (contract) that's the only way they get their commision from AT&T. No iPhone 3G sold in the US by Apple, AT&T, Best Buy and now Wal*mart will be sold without a two year commitment.
Dave
Please see my post as quoted again here to help clear up the confusion.Does anyone know if this is right? Does buying it at Best Buy somehow, not subsidize it nor require that you connect to AT&T? Could I buy one for $99 and turn around and sell it for $400? Or could I use the new one and sell my old one for $400?
I thought no matter if you bought at AT&T, WalMart, Best Buy, or Apple that you were getting an AT&T subsidized phone??? So, according to KuKitch, I can buy this for $99 and not have it alter or affect my current AT&T plan... and when the new iPhone is released in a month or two, I can still be eligible for an upgrade price?
Doesn't seem right to me???
If you buy the iPhone 3G at Best Buy, you will be signing up for a new two year service commitment with AT&T valid rate plan and with the required $30 data plan.
If you are not currently upgrade eligible then you can't get the cheapest price at Best Buy. The $99 / $149 type pricing is for a new line of service or an eligible upgrade. If you don't fit those two groups then you will have to pay the higher "Early Upgrade" pricing.
Again, there is no free lunch with the iPhone. Best Buy is not special, they are just trying to compete buy using the RewardsZone. They still have to meet the rules set by AT&T and Apple and they don't get paid if they don't follow the rules.
Fine Print of Best Buy Offer:
*Valid in-store only. Must be a Reward Zone® program member on or before 2/21/09. Limit one per customer. No rainchecks. Not valid on prior purchases or refurbished iPhones. In-store activation and data plan required. Not available in all stores. Apple iPhone 3G not available for purchase at BestBuy.com. Instant savings on phone requires activation through Best Buy on new lines of service with 2-year agreement on each line. The Qualified Upgrade Price requires a new 2-year agreement for qualified existing customers. Offer does not apply to Early Upgrade.
Source; http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?id=pcmcat168900050002&type=category
Dave