Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone X through 14 Pro were stainless steel. iPhone 4 was also stainless steel. While steel is heavy, some argue the polished steel frame were the most premium looking iPhones. iPhone Air evokes that with polished titanium. I don't think Apple uses steel for any of its products anymore.
Ohhhhh ok so this is the first time they have used aluminum?
 
Water is wet and phones of any type can get damaged when dropped. This OP, in and of itself, really doesn't mean anything at all.
If you drop a 16 Pro Max and a 17 Pro Max from the same height onto concrete, the 17 Pro Max is going to have drastically worse damage to the metal frame. You should know this without needing photo evidence, because it's titanium vs aluminum.
 
That’s expected with the aluminum. That’s how a dent looks like on iPhones pre-stainless steel era. There’s a reason why the Air is branded by Apple as the most durable iPhone yet. This photo proves it.
 
So I need a $79 case to protect my $1200 phone from looking worse than the moldy mandarin oranges that I find in my produce basket when my kids forget about them? Hard pass. I’ll take the premium phone made with titanium. 💅💅💅
And one that thermal throttles because it is so thin 😄. Even the main camera is worse, no way in hell would I pay a premium for that.
 
If you drop a 16 Pro Max and a 17 Pro Max from the same height onto concrete, the 17 Pro Max is going to have drastically worse damage to the metal frame. You should know this without needing photo evidence, because it's titanium vs aluminum.
No, not "it's titanium vs aluminum." Alloys of titanium or aluminum are used, and alloys are not the same as the base metals might be. So yes we need real test evidence from millions of real phones, and we do not have even one yet.
 
Just what I expected and why I am disappointed with the change. 15 and 16 Pro Maxes are the first iPhone which I finally felt comfortable using without a case. Now, back to those horrible plastic coverings - or maybe I’ll just return the 17 Pro Max.
 
  • Like
Reactions: turbineseaplane
Just what I expected and why I am disappointed with the change. 15 and 16 Pro Maxes are the first iPhone which I finally felt comfortable using without a case. Now, back to those horrible plastic coverings - or maybe I’ll just return the 17 Pro Max.
Gawd we do not even have one iPhone delivered yet and folks are [IMO absurdly] saying "Just what I expected and why I am disappointed with the change."
 
Wonder how all of the Pro owners are gonna feel walking around with a shriveled orange rind while my Air is still shiny and new? Three rear cameras can’t save you from gashed corners.

I'll bet a dozen donuts that my 17 Pro Max one year from when I receive it will look exactly - and I mean exactly - as it looked coming out of the box. Will you be able to say the same about your Air?
 
Gawd we do not even have one iPhone delivered yet and folks are [IMO absurdly] saying "Just what I expected and why I am disappointed with the change."
I don’t need to have it delivered. I have seen aluminum iPhones in the past - I am typing this from an aluminum iPad Pro which got dented from a minimal fall and then replaced under AppleCare+.

I enjoyed using my phone without a case. It dropped and did minimal damage, if at all. I’ll just see if I can accommodate to a case, but very likely it’s going right back. You enjoy a cheaper looking for or a bulky case, good for you. I don’t
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tdude96
Softer metal AND a heavier phone? Of course it’s gonna be worse than the previous generations, it’ll be worse than the base model as well.

Additionally, to those saying that a case would’ve saved it, fair enough, but with iPhones of the past, having it for an extended period of time will have the aluminum develop small dents and scratches from particles that get between the case and the phone. You cannot avoid it, irrespective of how much you take care of your phone.
 
Softer metal AND a heavier phone? Of course it’s gonna be worse than the previous generations, it’ll be worse than the base model as well.

Additionally, to those saying that a case would’ve saved it, fair enough, but with iPhones of the past, having it for an extended period of time will have the aluminum develop small dents and scratches from particles that get between the case and the phone. You cannot avoid it, irrespective of how much you take care of your phone.
I've had every an iphone every generation but two since the 7. Never had a dent. Not so much as a hair of a scratch.
 
I said this months ago. Aluminum is super soft, and all aluminum iPhones have been dent/scratch prone in the past. This really shouldn't be a surprise to anyone at this point. 🤣

My iPhone 11 had a giant dent in it from a 2 foot fall onto the leg of a chair.

You know what's extremely dent-proof and light-weight? Titanium. But it's also not good for thermals, so.... dents it is.
My 11 on release date + case till now with countless drops not a single dent 🤭
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jumpthesnark
I dropped 225 on my iPhone 4, after setting it on the safety bar doing OH press. It didn’t have damage like that. The glass was certainly shattered but I used it with packing tape for another 18 months.

I don’t have to make phones last that long anymore, my main point is I’ve never had damage like that on any phone I’ve ever had.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Jumpthesnark
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.