Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Bug Reports...

Bug Reports are not for pointing out your difference of opinion on design. When you flood Apple with these kind of "I'd like it better if it were like before" reports, well somebody from Apple has to read that. It takes time away from getting to actual bugs.

That's not to say that things in iOS 7 can't change from a design perspective. We've already seen the fonts change. That's just not what "bug reporting is".

Maybe you guys will get lucky and apple will change it, but it won't be because you submitted a design choice as a bug.

Good luck.

(Also, there is no way they are changing this.)
 
I still don't know what animation you're talking about. Could you point me to it?

When on a screen with back navigation (Settings works as an example), slowly swipe the screen left to right. You will see the back menu option will fade out from blue and fade in as black becoming the main page title heading.
 
When on a screen with back navigation (Settings works as an example), slowly swipe the screen left to right. You will see the back menu option will fade out from blue and fade in as black becoming the main page title heading.

Oh, that's neat. I never noticed that before. It seems like it would be a simple thing to have the blue border simply keep fading away until it's gone while the text fades out, changes color, and fades back in.
 
I've been looking at this thread and the mockups of the buttons and to be honest I'm not sure where the big confusion is coming from. The stock ios 7 back text is blue and has an arrow signaling that it takes you back. I don't think that's confusing or inherently different than the mockup buttons. Maybe someone can clarify this for me. Just an FYI...I'm not trying to be confrontational, just trying to have a good discussion. :)
 
You are missing the forest for the trees. Before you think creating a border and a button to go back makes sense do this first...

Edge swipe left to right to navigate backwards instead of tapping the back button. But do it slowly and take a look at the animation the "back button" does. It slides to the center in a clever with the arrow moving alongside it. It's very cool and sheds some method to this madness in iOS7. I like it just like it is.
 
I've been looking at this thread and the mockups of the buttons and to be honest I'm not sure where the big confusion is coming from. The stock ios 7 back text is blue and has an arrow signaling that it takes you back. I don't think that's confusing or inherently different than the mockup buttons. Maybe someone can clarify this for me. Just an FYI...I'm not trying to be confrontational, just trying to have a good discussion. :)
its not so much about complexity as it is about simplicity. At a glance the human brain will identify actionable items with a border in a much faster and simpler manner over purely text ones that simply use a different color.
 
I've been looking at this thread and the mockups of the buttons and to be honest I'm not sure where the big confusion is coming from. The stock ios 7 back text is blue and has an arrow signaling that it takes you back. I don't think that's confusing or inherently different than the mockup buttons. Maybe someone can clarify this for me. Just an FYI...I'm not trying to be confrontational, just trying to have a good discussion. :)

its not so much about complexity as it is about simplicity. At a glance the human brain will identify actionable items with a border in a much faster and simpler manner over purely text ones that simply use a different color.

Exactly. If you do not feel the difference yourself, you'll just have to trust our word that there are people who do feel this effect.

I mean, I've been using iOS since the very first iPhone, I KNOW where the command for going back up a level is, yet I still find myself taking an extra half second longer to find the "back" text now that it's a text and not a button.
 
Exactly. If you do not feel the difference yourself, you'll just have to trust our word that there are people who do feel this effect.

I mean, I've been using iOS since the very first iPhone, I KNOW where the command for going back up a level is, yet I still find myself taking an extra half second longer to find the "back" text now that it's a text and not a button.

I do think this way, too. The text blends with the contnent , but should be separated clearly (conflicting goals?). Additionally, for usability in general, actions should be buttons (or button-like) vs. menus or links that can be text because they communicate specific info and need more attention anyways.

Here it seems like usability was traded in for an animation that some didn't even notice. Also the blue/white filled tabs/buttons on top here you can't clearly distinct whether blue or white is the active one.
 
Those iOS6-ish buttons are ugly now. Everything is fine like it is. Let's hope it never makes to the final OS.
 
Ok. I understand what you guys are saying now about the button shape helping to identify an actionable item more quickly. When I look at the stock ios 7 back text I do find the bolded arrow to stand out more than the text. I found that the arrow caught my attention pretty quickly allowing me to recognize the back text. Also the blue color stands out pretty clearly from the other text on the page also signaling that the text is actionable. This is similar to a hyperlink on a web page or email. Also, it may be possible that all the user needs is a little time to adjust their eyes to what is now a "button." I would venture a guess that when we all first got an iPhone we had to adjust to the new workflow of using the back shaped button. I know when I taught my mother in law how to use the iphone it took her a while to get used to how to go back. Now she knows to use the top left to go back. In fact, she never realized for a long time that the button was shaped like an arrow. I know this is anecdotal and not necessarily attributable to all users but it may help to show that it's more about the consistency of the placement of the back button in the upper left and getting used to a certain workflow than the shape of the actionable item. Granted the shape could be one more thing to help out, especially new users. It's a very interesting debate nonetheless. A study in how people learn and interact.
 
I agree this has been a good discussion. I'd like to add just a few more thoughts on why I think the text-only approach Apple has adopted doesn't quite work. Right now, colored action item text is has no constraints on its length in most cases. As a result, it is often allowed to literally run into the page title.

attachment.php


When I look at the above screenshot, I see "Settings Mail, Contacts, Calendars" all as one line of text on first glance. This is because the word settings is so close to the page title that it looks like it is part of it. It's only when I look more closely that I see that the word settings is actually separate. But, the point of a UI is that I shouldn't HAVE to look a second time to navigate it easily.

The text-only approach is also inconsistent. In some cases, the navigation text actually pushes the page title way off center. This can be confusing to people who are used to the page title always being centered. It also just looks bad.

attachment.php


In other cases, the UI shortens the navigation text to keep the page title (mostly) centered. In this case, you can't really tell what the back button says unless you already know your way around the OS. I would also submit that this method also looks cluttered.

attachment.php


I know that getting rid of buttons is one of the ways Apple is trying to shove off the "dated" UI paradigms from iOS 1-6. But this feels like change for the sake of change rather than a true design improvement. And yes, as several people have pointed out, you can eventually train yourself to recognize that the blue text represents an actionable item. I've pretty much reached that point. But, I'm pretty technically minded. I worry about my parents and my grandmother, all of whom have iDevices and none of whom are into technology. Especially in the case of my grandmother, this change will, without a doubt, make her iPad harder to use. And even in my case, I still have to hunt for the actionable text from time to time because it is so often allowed to slam into the page title.

For comparison here's what that last screen from the messages app looks like on iOS 6. I'm not trying to start a debate on iOS 6 vs. iOS 7. However, I think it's pretty clear that the actionable items are more clearly marked. And, because the buttons use a smaller font size, the entire word "Messages" can be fit into the back button.

attachment.php


Personally, I think Apple really needs to bring back some sort of button outline like the one I posted in my original post. It would make the navigation elements more uniform by giving them a defined size and would also make them easier to identify. This is just my opinion though. If Apple does stick with the "text-only" approach, I hope they will at least consider making the actionable items have a smaller font size. This would allow them to fit longer words in a smaller space, and would help separate them from the page title. Apple could still do their "slides in to become the page title" animation by adding a simple scaling effect.

Anyway, just my two cents! :)
 

Attachments

  • Nav-3.png
    Nav-3.png
    18.7 KB · Views: 805
  • Nav-4.png
    Nav-4.png
    18.9 KB · Views: 623
  • Nav-5.png
    Nav-5.png
    34.4 KB · Views: 628
  • Nav-6.png
    Nav-6.png
    33.6 KB · Views: 631
Great post!! Clearly thought out and a critique I'm hoping apple considers. I agree that the actionable text needs to be resized in order to have the title centered. The actionable text should be given a defined area and adjust the font size to fit that area so that the titles can maintain a center position. It makes for a cleaner and easier to understand layout. Also I think it would just plain look better. Would someone be able to mock up the previous posters idea?
 
That's a fantastic idea, I hate the idea of borderless text being buttons in iOS 7, keep submitting your idea into Apple and see if you can get other devs to submit similar suggestions.
 
Wow, that really looks horrible, like a step backwards; looks like an hybrid of iOS 6 and 7.
 
Buttons look antiquated. Words should suffice.
We should just use words for everything since a lot of things are antiquated (seems simply by the virtue that they have been around for a long time...for a reason).

We can use all text browsers, like Lynx, since we don't really need visual dividers on pages, or headlines be bigger in articles, etc., etc., etc. We can just use command line/terminal to interact with our operating systems since who needs those extra visual elements when you can do essentially everything you need by typing in things and reading them.
 
I disagree with the mockup. Colored text is just as recognizable as a button. Webpages use colored text for hyperlinks, PDFs & eBooks do the same. We all know those are clickable when we see them on digital interfaces. It's getting the user to associate that kind of interface with a phone/device. Once they figure it out then it all makes sense and is more streamlined with the modern world. To me the colored texts are signs for future vision or version of the iPhone without any physical buttons.
 
Last edited:
They might do something, but even if they do, it likely won't be because of this thread or similar threads.

If they get enough complaints about something they might. But I agree with a previous poster who said dislike of certain design choices aren't necessarily "bugs". We've seen some UI changes between betas 1-4. My guess is we'll see some more before GM. Whether that's because of feedback from beta testers or just internal decisions made by Apple we'll never know. Unless some juicy gossip gets leaked to 9to5Mac, Gruber, etc. Maybe they have it and are saving it for when the new phone comes out. :)
 
We should just use words for everything since a lot of things are antiquated (seems simply by the virtue that they have been around for a long time...for a reason).

We can use all text browsers, like Lynx, since we don't really need visual dividers on pages, or headlines be bigger in articles, etc., etc., etc. We can just use command line/terminal to interact with our operating systems since who needs those extra visual elements when you can do essentially everything you need by typing in things and reading them.

Chill out... they have an arrow there still, you dont need the border around it.
 
After the terrible icon designs, I think the most commonly voiced complaint about iOS 7 is Apple's decision to replace navigation buttons with colored text. This ostensibly makes the interface "cleaner" (a term that seems to be used to justify any change made in iOS 7, no matter how questionable). But, it also makes it way more difficult to navigate the UI at a glance. Since the navigation bars are now white (the same color as most content backgrounds) and the navigation text "buttons" are the exact same size and font as the page title, it is rather difficult to tell the difference between actionable UI elements and the content. This is ironic since Apple made a huge deal about how iOS 7 is supposed to defer to your content.

What's even more bizarre is that buttons haven't been completely eliminated from the UI. There are a few instances (like in the AppStore screenshot below) where actionable text has a blue outline. This makes a sort of "virtual button" that is instantly recognizable as something that can be pressed.
Screenshot1.jpg


My proposal would be for Apple to redo all action buttons in this style. It doesn't fundamentally alter the iOS 7 style. But, it makes nav bars much more user-friendly.

Before
attachment.php


After
attachment.php


Also, notice how the existing outlined buttons in iOS 7 use a smaller text size. This would reduce instances in the UI of action text being shortened (see the Messages app) to the point of being unreadable. I have no idea if Apple will ever do this. But, I live in hope!

What do you all think? Is this an improvement over the current iOS 7 UI?

I love iOS 7 so far, but this is really nice. You should really submit it to Apple, as I think only posting it here won't do much.

Very nice.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.