Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

bbplayer5

macrumors 68040
Original poster
Apr 13, 2007
3,134
1,158
If you had to drop your iphone for another phone, what would it be?
 
I looked at heaps of phones (we don't have the iPhone in oz) and got a Treo 750 and the missing sync.

I have loved the phone, I mainly use it for email and to run apps (gradebook for school). It runs Windows Mobile V6 which I must admit being a Mac user leaves me feeling a little off.... but it has worked really well.

I tried the N95 and Blackberry, but I like 3G and 3rd party apps (the ones I need). Treo won, but I also bought a iPod touch just to be sure (...and got the $20 update...... LOVE the email app)

I'm going to jump all over the 3G iPhone if it ever gets here!
 
3G iphone is honestly going to be a market killer. If they allow lots of 3rd party apps, the iphone is going to be the only phone to buy.
 
Personally, I wound up with an O2 (HTC) XDA Orbit. WM6, built-in GPS, runs TomTom 6, houses lots of technical info I need for work and syncs perfectly with my Macs using MissingSync.

I looked at the iPhone, the N95, the Treo and the Blackberry models, and none really offered quite as good an overall balance of compactness vs. features I needed as the XDA.

I'm hoping that by the time I'm due for an upgrade, the iPhone will offer a few more 'business-class' features
 
I think that a 3G iPhone will just be proper amazing!

One of the main downfalls with the current iPhone is how slow the internet can be! But if it were to have 3G... It would actually immense!!! x
 
telephone4.JPG
 
Thats a really scary thought nothing out there even compares to the iPhone. If for some reason I had to do without my iPhone to me the closest second would be a small laptop Mabey Macbook Air.
 
Its funny, cos my mate was saying to me the other day "i'm going to buy the LG Viewty today... its got a 5mpx camera, HSDPA, touch screen etc etc". And I felt like saying, "there are other phones out there?" I couldn't care less...

I used to have a pretty strong interest in the mobile market. Always read the reviews on GSM Arena, Mobile-Review and whatnot. But that interest is just dead now. Its solely about Apple filling in the gaps. As a Mac user and general consumer, its light years ahead. Come 6 months with lots of apps via the SDK, an easy way of getting them through iTunes, 3.5G and a better camera, its over.

Its going to be a lot harder for the other cell companies to get the UI/UX (syncing media, enjoying media, multitouch, app quality etc) and OS right (networking, scalability, developer tools) than it is for Apple to add in a 3G radio and higher quality camera. The hard work was done by implementing an embedded OSX and gesture based interface. I look at my old 3G, Symbian based N-series Nokia in disgust.

I await their clones.
 
Its funny, cos my mate was saying to me the other day "i'm going to buy the LG Viewty today... its got a 5mpx camera, HSDPA, touch screen etc etc". And I felt like saying, "there are other phones out there?" I couldn't care less...

I used to have a pretty strong interest in the mobile market. Always read the reviews on GSM Arena, Mobile-Review and whatnot. But that interest is just dead now.


+1

(You dont happen to be my identical twin by any chance. Or are you:eek::eek:)
 
The 2nd best phone I ever owned was right before the iPhone, the Nokia N95. Besides the stellar camera on the N95 (5mp, auto focus, great zoom, etc), the iPhone destroys the N95 in just about every single category. I am always on the lookout for the next big thing, but since I purchased the iPhone, I haven't found a better phone.
 
Blackberry Curve, which quite frankly is a better all around smartphone than the iPhone.

(I'm not looking to pick a fight, I love my iPhone. But anyone who has ever had experience with smartphones will always hold a special place in their heart for RIM's stuff.)
 
The Softbank 911T/920T and the N95 8GB compare spec wise

the phones I would try:

Softbank 920T
Softbank 920SC
Nokia N73

iPhone
 

Attachments

  • images-1.jpeg
    images-1.jpeg
    2.7 KB · Views: 1,271
  • images-2.jpeg
    images-2.jpeg
    3.9 KB · Views: 1,269
  • images-3.jpeg
    images-3.jpeg
    3.4 KB · Views: 1,278
  • images-4.jpeg
    images-4.jpeg
    2.7 KB · Views: 1,263
  • images.jpeg
    images.jpeg
    3.5 KB · Views: 1,282
LOL i dont know if i would say the N95 comes in 2nd to the iphone... and that Voyager is just a regular phone, with a really bad punch screen.
 
I had a cheap Samsung flip phone that worked as a basic phone, had good call quality, and lasted through 3 years of my beating, dropping, and drowning without ever moaning. No fancy web browsing, music playback, shiny interface, or 10000 megapixel digital camera, but I honestly kind of miss it.

I would have an iPhone right now, but the it just doesn't work well enough as a phone for me, ironic for a device first and foremost touted as a phone.

So instead a I have a Sprint Mogul for the next year until my contract is up, then I'll consider switching to AT&T if they can manage to roll out their 3G services in my part of the country, and pick up a Sony XPERIA X1, which looks very promising.
 
Functionwise, the N95.

Stylewise, the Porsche P'9521, see here
 

Attachments

  • porsche-p9521-phone-716-90.jpg
    porsche-p9521-phone-716-90.jpg
    16.4 KB · Views: 115
If you had to drop your iphone for another phone, what would it be?

Really, the answer is that there isn't one. Maybe the Prada for its simplicity, but there is absolutely no comparison. The bulky plastic Nokia N-series hold no interest for me.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.