I think you might be in the minority on this one. It’s not over exaggerating in my mind. I’d certainly see the difference in everyday situations....every time I looked at the screen. Take a look at this review for example. They describe the nMBP as being almost twice as bright in reality.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Air returns - Why?
- Thread starter raqball
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I had both... AIR is really solid... MBP is nice but not light years ahead like people make it seem.
Sorry, this is very over-exaggerated.
Borrowed the MBP Touch Bar for an evening last night, in order to compare with the new MBA side by side.
The MBA on full brightness is comparable to the MBP Touch Bar on -2 points from full brightness. Take that for what it's worth.
What I can say however, is that the display appeared very, very yellow, out of the box compared to the MBP.
I was ready to bring the MBA back, but then I tried calibrating the display by increasing the white point to >7500, as suggested by other users.
This actually improved it a lot! Made it very close to the MBP, in terms of color. Text looked sharper as well (I guess it's to do with contrast).
It's still not as good as the Pro, but it's now improved to the point where it's not really a problem for me.
Hope this helps someone else.
It’s not me saying it, it’s laptop magazine reporting their findings based on the 2018 Air vs 2017 MBP they tested. The results they found
- 2018 Air: Rated nits - 300, Tested nits - 234
- 2017 MBP: Rated nits - 500, Tested nits - 458
- Results: MBP Almost 2 times brighter (ie 95.7%)
Look, I’m not bashing the Air. I bought one (one of the $200 off models at Micro Center) and really wanted it to work for me. But it’s going back. The display is unacceptable for me. I can fully understand how the display can be acceptable for someone else though. However, there is no denying the fact that the display is the dimmest in Apples lineup for a modern display, colors are washed out and muted and contrast is low.....even when compared to the 12 inch MB. The real question is, can one overlook this “feature”? Some can....some can’t.
Last edited:
This, especially this. I get it that the display is less than the rMBP displays. I don't understand why the rMBA display is noticeably behind the rMB.
I went ahead and purchased it this morning (I was waiting to see if there were any issues that came up first within my 14 day return window). I did it through the support page and it was pretty straightforward. Entered serial number, and then let me purchase. I'll let you know if it asks for any additional steps (like remote check) once the order is processed.
ETA: Just got processed and coverage was applied with no additional steps. This may change closer to the 60 day cutoff but at least at the two week mark it was fine.
Last edited:
After all the feedback I have read from the new MBA 2018 I was very indecisive but last night I found what I think it's a pretty good deal at Dell.com and I ordered a XPS 13 9370 i7-8550U, 16GB RAM, FHD and 512GB for 1074eur + tax. I will miss the higher resolution of the MBA but in a 13" laptop is not a big difference and the XPS scree is very good from what I've heard. I just hope I haven't made a mistake ordering this Dell.
Same here! Mine is going back today :/ I also got that good deal at micro center but the display brightness is just....sad. Really sad. I also compared the MacBook Air 2018 against a 2017 MacBook Pro and 2017 MacBook and was amazed at how crappy the lack of brightness made things (also how the screen almost looked to be a yellow tinge in comparison to the other two). I also put an older MacBook Air (my husband's laptop) next to the new one and that even seemed brighter.... It was hard to focus on words on the display because they seemed so faded and matte like and I always had the laptop up to almost max brightness (which made my battery drain super fast). It really was a bummer for me to have to make the decision to return it because I absolutely LOVE the form factor. I really wish Apple had focused more on making it the same brightness as their other laptops especially since it is not crazy difference in price anymore. I also miss many of the things about the original MacBook Air that made it so special. Not sure where Apple is going these days. I am becoming more and more attracted to the older generation products they put out not just because of the design and headphone jacks but because of prices of their products nowadays. I think many of us will be holding on to our older gadgets for an extended period of time.
Lads, you keep talking about the screen, but what about the camera? Are you happy with it? It seems to be shockingly bad. Very very very low iso. Thinking about returning the device..
I agree. It almost seems like the company is being run by an accountant... oh, wait...
Seriously though, how much more costly would 256GB drive be as standard, or the slightly brighter display or a slightly better camera. The more I think about, the Air is really full of compromises. Some of those compromises, like the screen, are in part due to the desire for the 12 hour battery life. When Apple researched the original Air that was the big selling point. It's part of the Air's DNA and I get it, but it should not come at the expense of the overall user experience in my opinion.
I've done a couple of Zoom sessions and have some concerns. I think I need to figure out how to A/B test that. Honestly, the 720p camera in the rMBA doesn't seem any better than the 480p camera in the rMB, and as an impression, feels well behind the 720p camera in my 2015 rMBA. Not a dealbreaker for me, but another annoyance?
Sad. Apple is designing to get every last cent of profit. If someone actually wants a better quality they will have to spend more dollars. They could have easily made this one of their greatest laptops with decent profit at current price point.
[doublepost=1542840656][/doublepost]
May be rated at 720p but are they using cheaper/inferior camera?
I remember, trying to calibrate my MBA screen back in 2012. It improved a lot.
Sorry, this is very over-exaggerated.
Borrowed the MBP Touch Bar for an evening last night, in order to compare with the new MBA side by side.
The MBA on full brightness is comparable to the MBP Touch Bar on -2 points from full brightness. Take that for what it's worth.
What I can say however, is that the display appeared very, very yellow, out of the box compared to the MBP.
I was ready to bring the MBA back, but then I tried calibrating the display by increasing the white point to >7500, as suggested by other users.
This actually improved it a lot! Made it very close to the MBP, in terms of color. Text looked sharper as well (I guess it's to do with contrast).
It's still not as good as the Pro, but it's now improved to the point where it's not really a problem for me.
Hope this helps someone else.
Exactly right. The company is either making incorrect compromises (too thin for proper cooling or adequate ports, butterfly keyboards), or is launching products with things users don't want (Touchbar, too little RAM or GB on base models).
Agreed.
First Mac was a 2009 white MacBook, great laptop in it's day! Remember Leopard and Snow Leopard? Then a 2011 MBP 17, which I still enjoy and use with 1 TB SSD and 16 GB RAM from OWC, and now this average at best 2015 rMB.
The Jobs era featured mostly the Mac with iOS starting to explode late in his career until he was done in 2011. Today, Apple's 2018Q4 $ revenue is 59% iPhone, 7% iPad [66% iOS] and 12% Mac. As someone pointed out, Apple is being run by accountants as they understand where their big revenue really originates as do app developers also understand; it is the iOS world.
I have come to understand the Apple Jobs Mac era is long gone and if I want to enjoy Mac OS X, I am forced to buy overpriced, very mediocre hardware from Apple replete with compromise and arguable design flaws.
It is what it is.
First Mac was a 2009 white MacBook, great laptop in it's day! Remember Leopard and Snow Leopard? Then a 2011 MBP 17, which I still enjoy and use with 1 TB SSD and 16 GB RAM from OWC, and now this average at best 2015 rMB.
The Jobs era featured mostly the Mac with iOS starting to explode late in his career until he was done in 2011. Today, Apple's 2018Q4 $ revenue is 59% iPhone, 7% iPad [66% iOS] and 12% Mac. As someone pointed out, Apple is being run by accountants as they understand where their big revenue really originates as do app developers also understand; it is the iOS world.
I have come to understand the Apple Jobs Mac era is long gone and if I want to enjoy Mac OS X, I am forced to buy overpriced, very mediocre hardware from Apple replete with compromise and arguable design flaws.
It is what it is.
Yes it really does feel as though the new Macbook Air is just riddled with compromises...a real shame :/ I actually pulled out my old 2011 Macbook Pro 15 inch today to see if it was dim compared to the new Macbook Air...I thought surely it would be because it is so much older...but amazingly it is still brighter and the colors seem more correct on my old Macbook Pro 15 inch.... just wow...I actually returned my MacBook Air to Microcenter last night - Great deal but I think I'll wait to see if Apple corrects things...I hope they do. I'd definitely repurchase one in the future if they corrected the screen brightness. I guess we will have to wait and see. On a side note I personally hope they start moving away from the Touch Bar on Macbook Pros and just implement the Touch ID. One good move they made on the new Macbook Air.
I actually really like the Touch Bar and don't quite understand why so many don't. I personally think the Touch Bar is the first step toward all glass keyboard. Apple is obsessed with making everything thinner... I would not be shocked if they had an all glass keyboard with haptic feedback engine built in to simulate typing on physical keyboard somewhere in the lab. It seems like the next logical step at reducing the size requirement of a keyboard.
It’s been done, check the Lenovo YogaBook series, and no thanks!
It is harder to touch type on non-physical keys. The feedback is worse (non existant on Touch Bar), more chance of typo’s and a flat actuation point which makes it worse for typing fast or comfort. Just compare writing a long email on your iPhone to a MacBook.
Seeing them side by side in the store is what sealed the deal for me, too. Enjoy your new machine!
Going to go the route you guys went; really want to like the MBA but have to first see if I can live with that display, if not, tbMBP like you both now have. I have the 21" LG UltraFine monitor Apple sells, which I use at home so that might help. We'll see...
Where I started was a 2015 rMPB (3.5 pounds) and a 2017 rMB (2 pounds). Managing two laptops was do-able but unnecessary, so I wanted the rMBA to be the one. 2.75 pounds was a good compromise between those two machines.
The rMBA had some compromises I didn't like, especially the display, although it had some other very attractive features. What I need to decide is whether I want to go back to having one laptop that's a MBP. My commute includes a lot of walking and the difference between 3.5 and 2 pounds was very noticeable. Need to see how 3 pounds, which is a different compromise, works for me.
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm coming from 2016 MBP and yes, screen is a little bit dim but not bad! It´s okay, and I think its better that screen is not too light like oled - my eyes say thanks! I just tested to change screen options. If u choose "Rec. ITU-R BT.709-5" - its like my old MBP - more lighter and more deeper colors… Love my MBA!