Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
59,323
23,304


The AirPods have been around since 2016, and at this point, there have been several iterations along with the launch of the AirPods Pro and the AirPods Max. With three options available, you might be having some trouble figuring out which you should buy.

airpodsd-3-purple-4.jpg

This guide walks through the different AirPods models that you can purchase right now, highlighting the similarities and the differences between them to help you pick the best option.

AirPods vs. Sony, Bose and Other Third-Party Options

First off, if you're curious why you should choose AirPods at all when there are so many headphone brands on the market, it's because AirPods offer the best integration with Apple's iPhones, Macs, iPads, Apple Watches, and Apple TVs.

Bose-QC-Earbuds-II-v-AirPods-Pro-2-Thumb.jpg

There are features that third-party manufacturers cannot match, such as quick one-tap device pairing, one-tap switching with devices where you're logged in to your Apple ID, Spatial Audio for TV shows, movies, and music, Hey Siri integration, and Find My support for some models. If you have an Apple device, Apple-designed headphones are your best bet.

All AirPods models are wire-free and are designed to connect to your devices using Bluetooth.

Beats Headphones vs. AirPods

Apple owns the Beats by Dre brand, and there are several wireless earbud options that are competitive with AirPods, including the Beats Fit Pro, Beats Studio Buds, and Powerbeats Pro. These earbuds offer many of the same quick pairing and automatic switching features as the AirPods, and could be worth checking out if you prefer the Beats style and fit.

beats-fit-pro-2.jpg

Beats earbuds are more fitness oriented than the AirPods, AirPods Pro, and AirPods Max, with the Beats Fit Pro and Powerbeats both aimed at those who need a more secure in-ear fit.

In-Ear AirPods vs. Over-Ear AirPods

There are two general types of AirPods, including the over-ear AirPods Max and the in-ear AirPods and AirPods Pro that are smaller and designed to fit in the outer ear. If you're looking for ear cups connected by a headband that are worn over the ears and on the head, the AirPods Max are the only option that Apple offers.

airpods-max-lifestyle.jpg

AirPods and AirPods Pro have a similar small earbud-like design, and the difference between them is that the AirPods Pro have silicone ear tips for a better sound seal, while the AirPods do not.

AirPods vs. AirPods Pro and AirPods Max - Noise Canceling

Aside from design, the major difference between the AirPods, AirPods Pro, and AirPods Max is noise cancellation. The AirPods Pro and AirPods Max offer Active Noise Cancellation, and the lower-cost AirPods do not have noise cancelling capabilities.

airpods-pro-noise-cancellation.jpg

AirPods 2 and 3 Overview

The first earbuds that Apple came out with were the AirPods, and as of now, there have been three iterations in total. The AirPods 3 are the most recent version, priced at $179, while the AirPods 2 are a prior-generation version available at a more affordable $129 price point.

AirPods-3-Feature-Red.jpg

When you think of AirPods, it's probably the AirPods 2 and 3 models that come to mind, as they feature Apple's tipless in-ear design with longer white stems that come down. Compared to AirPods 2, AirPods 3 feature a Force sensor for more music control gestures, Spatial Audio support with dynamic head tracking, better water resistance, longer battery life, improved sound quality, a better skin detection sensor for improved accuracy when pulling them out of your ears, and a MagSafe charging case (or Lightning, for a $10 discount).

If you can afford it, the AirPods 3 are enough of an upgrade over the AirPods 2 to justify the extra $50, and these are your quintessential earbuds perfect for yourself, kids, giving as gifts, and more. The AirPods were last refreshed in 2021, which was when Apple introduced the third-generation AirPods.

AirPods 3 Key Features:
  • In-ear design with vent system
  • Force sensor controls
  • H1 chip
  • MagSafe Charging Case with Find My
  • Spatial audio
  • Skin detect sensors
  • 5 hours battery with Spatial Audio
  • 24 hours listening time with charging case
  • IPX4 water/sweat resistance
  • Dual-beamforming microphones
Bottom Line: The AirPods 3 are Apple's iconic earbuds that have a universal comfortable fit for everyday use when listening to music, making calls, and more. They're simple, affordable, easy to use, and they pair perfectly with Apple devices.

The AirPods 2 are a more affordable version of the AirPods 3 but without MagSafe charging, and neither version of the AirPods feature noise cancellation, so if that's a feature you're looking for, you need to upgrade to AirPods Pro.

AirPods Pro Overview

The AirPods Pro are Apple's newest earbuds, refreshed in September 2022. The second-generation AirPods Pro are Apple's in-ear noise cancelling earbuds, offering the ANC capabilities of the AirPods Max in an earbud size similar to the AirPods. Notably, the AirPods Pro have Adaptive Transparency, which lets you hear what's around you while drowning out extra loud sounds like sirens, noisy concerts, and more, which can damage hearing.

airpods-pro-purple.jpg

As Apple's newest product, the AirPods Pro feature an updated H2 chip with more advanced noise cancellation technologies, IPX4 sweat and water resistance, and longer battery life. If you want small, portable earbuds that have noise cancellation features for everyday use, the AirPods Pro are the way to go. Apple sells the AirPods Pro for $250, a price that includes a MagSafe Charging Case.

Key Features:
  • In-ear design with silicone ear tips and vent system
  • Force sensors and touch-based controls
  • H2 chip
  • MagSafe Charging Case with Find My
  • Spatial audio
  • Skin detect sensors
  • 5.5 hours listening time with Spatial Audio
  • 30 hours listening time with charging case
  • IPX4 water/sweat resistance
  • Active Noise Cancellation
  • Adaptive Transparency
  • Dual-beamforming microphones
  • Lanyard loop
Bottom Line: If you want an in-ear form factor with Active Noise Cancellation, the AirPods Pro 2 are the earbuds to pick up. Apple improved ANC this year compared to the original AirPods Pro, plus battery life has increased and there's now a MagSafe charging case that can charge via Lightning, MagSafe charger, Qi charger, or even an Apple Watch charger, so it's super versatile. The AirPods Pro are Apple's best in-ear earbuds.

AirPods Max Overview

The AirPods Max are Apple's first and only Apple-branded headphones that are designed to be worn over the ear. Offering higher quality audio than the AirPods or AirPods Pro, the AirPods Max are on par with over-ear options from companies like Sony and Bose.

airpods-max-blue-image.png

The AirPods Max feature Active Noise Cancellation and a Digital Crown for volume adjustment, plus they have the longest battery life of any of the AirPods at 20 hours. There is no charging case, though, so there's no extra battery life. For over-ear headphones, the AirPods Max are comfortable, but some users find them heavy and tight on the head, and they are not as universally comfortable as the AirPods or AirPods Pro for all people.

Apple has not updated the AirPods Max since 2020, and they are due for a refresh.

Key Features:
  • Over-ear design with magnetic ear cups
  • Aluminum build, padded headband
  • Noise control button, Digital Crown for volume adjustment
  • Active Noise Cancellation
  • Transparency
  • H1 chip
  • Position and case-detect sensor
  • Up to 20 hours listening time
  • Spatial Audio support
  • Three microphones for voice pickup
  • Smart Case preserves battery charge
  • Charges via Lightning
Bottom Line: For those looking for an over-ear headphone solution, the AirPods Max are worth picking up, though it is worth noting that the AirPods Max have not been updated since 2020 and so we could see a refresh soon. AirPods Max are similar to the AirPods Pro with Active Noise Cancellation, but with an over-ear fit. They're much larger than Apple's in-ear options, and have a high-quality aluminum build with comfortable fabric-covered ear cups.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which AirPods Are Cheapest?

The prior-generation AirPods 2 are Apple's cheapest earbud option at $129, but they can sometimes be found on sale for under $100 from third-party retailers. They have many of the same features as the AirPods 3, but lack the Force sensor for additional gestures, Spatial Audio, and MagSafe charging case. Battery life is also lower.

If you don't need bells or whistles like Spatial Audio, the AirPods 2 can save you some money, but the AirPods 3 offer better sound quality, better voice quality for calls, and they work with Spatial Audio for TV shows, music, and movies.

Which AirPods Have the Best Noise Cancellation?

Both the AirPods Pro 2 and the AirPods Max have Active Noise Cancellation functionality, but it differs somewhat because the AirPods Max are over-ear headphones and the AirPods Pro are in-ear.

The AirPods Pro 2 are newer and Apple introduced a more advanced Active Noise Cancellation technology. Both work to drown out typical noises that you might want to block like airplane sounds, fans, air conditioners, and road noise, but the AirPods Pro 2 require a good in-ear fit for the best noise cancellation, while the AirPods Max don't need much adjustment as over-ear headphones.

The best ANC is a matter of opinion and it's best to pick based on fit preference. If you want in-ear buds, get the AirPods Pro, but if you prefer larger over-ear headphones, it's best to go with AirPods Max.

Which AirPods Are Most Comfortable?

The AirPods Pro and the AirPods are both regarded as highly comfortable for most people with their ergonomic designs and included vents, but the AirPods Pro may have the edge because of the silicone tips.

Ears are all different, so it may be best to try out the AirPods, AirPods Pro, and AirPods Max in the store to see which is the best for you.

Which AirPods Have the Best Microphone Quality?

If you're getting AirPods primarily for phone calls, microphone quality may be a concern. Both the AirPods 3 and the AirPods Pro 2 have dual beamforming microphones so you sound clear to the person on the other end of the call, and call quality between the two is similar.

Noise cancelation in the AirPods Pro will block out more sound that you're hearing so you may be able to hear the person on the other end better, and the AirPods Pro have Bluetooth 5.3 vs. Bluetooth 5 for the AirPods 3, so there may be some sound improvements because of that. For the best possible sound quality, the most recent AirPods Pro 2 are ideal.

As for the AirPods Max, they have three microphones that are used for voice pickup, including two shared with Active Noise Cancellation and then one additional microphone. There are also multiple microphones for Active Noise Cancellation, so you can count on high quality sound for phone calls.

Which AirPods Have the Most Features?

The AirPods Pro 2 are Apple's newest AirPods and they have the most advanced feature set. There's next-generation Active Noise Cancellation technology, Adaptive Transparency for drowning out loud noises like sirens and construction work, a lanyard loop, a case with built-in speakers for locating them via Find My, and more.

If you want the newest and best AirPods, it's the AirPods Pro you're looking for. The AirPods were last updated in October 2021 and the AirPods Max haven't been updated since their December 2020 launch. We are expecting an AirPods Max update at some point in 2023 or 2024, which prospective buyers should be aware of.

Read More

We have dedicated roundups for all of the AirPods options, which go into much more detail on all of the available features.
Guide Feedback

Have questions about choosing AirPods, notice something we left out, or want to offer feedback on this guide? Send us an email here.

Article Link: AirPods: 2023 Buyer's Guide
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: SnappleRumors

Pezimak

macrumors 68000
May 1, 2021
1,936
1,758
Do they let you try on AirPods and AirPods Pro? How does that work, do they boil them between try-ons?

I think they did before Covid, not so sure now? I got a pair of Airpods Pro 1 for Christmas and love them. Best way to make them fit I’ve found is open your mouth, pull the top of your ear and put them in, then let go of your ear and close your mouth. This opens then closes your ear canal.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ignatius345

klasma

macrumors 65816
Jun 8, 2017
1,405
2,524
The AirPods 2 have the killer feature that you can control them just by tapping, like when you’re wearing a beanie or gloves. Another feature is that the mic stems extend far enough to still work well when you wear a beanie or headband over the ears. This is why I won’t buy any of the newer models.
 
Last edited:

multipasser

macrumors regular
Dec 11, 2010
103
173
iPod Air Pro 2's are the worst product of apple I own!
I dont like the how fast they drain the battery (without NC).

And when I'm in bed and I just want to insert the left POD, it does NOT connect.
I need also to insert the right one for my iphone 14 to recognise the airpods. Annoying.
 

ridgero

macrumors regular
Dec 16, 2017
186
498
The ANC of the AirPods Max is much worse since they updated it.

Plus they improved the ANC on the AirPods Pro 2. For me their is not much difference in terms of ANC quality anymore between Pro and Max.Tried it ln plane/train.
 
Last edited:

JippaLippa

macrumors 65816
Jan 14, 2013
1,024
1,023
I'm very pleased with the airpods pro 2.
I used to have some slightly better sounding earbuds from technics, but the airpods are much more comfortable, have much better transparency mode and they improved the audio quality from the previous gen enough for me to define them as good sounding.
The only thing I don't like is the connection to the mac, which is still unreliable...for desktop use I still think cabled headphones are king.
 

wilberforce

macrumors 68030
Aug 15, 2020
2,716
2,920
SF Bay Area
The AirPods 2 fit perfectly for me and don't fall out. I prefer the fit to the AirPods 3, and I don't like sealed in-ears like the AirPod Pros and the Beats Fit Pro. Everyone's ears are different, of course, so it's good that there is choice.
Sure, just pointing out for others that the "killer feature" of being able to tap the earbuds (and I absolutely agree it is a killer feature) is also available on BFP, which are great earbuds in their own right and similarly integrate into the Apple ecosystem
 

retrocool

macrumors member
Jan 29, 2004
32
17
I've got £20 JLab go earbuds and they work just fine. Airpods are 'affordable' compared to the Max version, but it's a whole lot of money when you can get 90% of the value for 10% of the price. I can get spare pairs for when I lose them or even to pair with different devices so I don't have to deal with the friction of switching. And still have loads of luverly £££ in the bank.

Mind you, once Airpods Pro can do a decent impression of a hearing aid I might be tempted.
 

frifra

macrumors 6502a
Nov 29, 2008
900
625
If you are wondering whether to get the Bose QC (Quiet Comfort) EarBuds II or the AirPods Pro 2:

TL;DR: Get the AirPods Pro 2, better quality and quick and easy pairing with iPhones/iPads. Bose Pairing or connecting every time is hit and miss and the app is slow and cumbersome.


Long Version:

*CONTRA* Bose QC Earbuds II
- Case feels cheap and earbuds are difficult to take out compared to Airpods Pro

- Sometimes I only get sound on one Bose earbud or one of them has extremely low sound. It only gets fixed if I put it back in the case

- Switching between iPad Pro / iPhone Pro only works with the Bose app or BT settings and not directly like with the AirPods Pro

- If you use both Bose earbuds and put the right one back into the case, the left one shuts off

- Bose microphone quality is quite bad

- Even with activated Bose ear detection the microphone stays connected if you take them out and put them on the desk. If you now send a voice message to someone the mic of the Bose earbuds is used instead of the mic of the iPhone

- High level of background noise / white noise. Difficult to listen to silent music or nothing at all - no matter if ANC is set to full/minimum/off.

- The software of the Bose case can only be updated via a PC (maybe also Mac?)

- Bose app is often quite slow and sluggy especially if you want to change settings or switch between devices or to show that the earbuds are connected

————————-

*PRO* Bose Earbuds
- Volume can be changed by swiping up and down (only downside is that this can happen accidentall, e.g. when taking of your mask)

- Change of music tracks (forward / backwards) quicker than with AirPods Pro 2 as you only need to tap

- Adjustable ANC Mode, 2 of them can be saved individually

- Good adjustable fit as they come with silicone rings and ear “plugs”



=> For me there were too many downsides with the Bose QC Earbuds II. Also the customer service from Bose directly (where I bought them from) was subpar. Telephone support was even worse.

Also, in Germany Bose lists a wrong return address and then refuses to accept a prepaid package so that you have to send it again.
 
Last edited:

Matsamoto

macrumors 6502
Oct 31, 2018
389
2,972
Halmstad, Sweden
Byers guide 2023 for me:
I'm not gonna buy any Airpods. Ever🙂

Have been using APP Gen 1 for 3 years and it has been the crappiest experience.
Connectivity issues, battery drain in one bud, one bud that don't charge. Music stops randomly etc.
Most of this bugs in the same day, for 3 years.
Also got the charging case and both buds exchanged through AC+.
Same problem with them also.
I don't know if it's software or hardware related or a mix of both.

So I'm not willing to spend almost 400 euro on APP 2 and AC+ to take a chance if the buds are good this time.
So Apple won't get any money from me😁
 
  • Like
Reactions: japanime

Shirasaki

macrumors G5
May 16, 2015
14,109
8,791
Something that AirPods Pro 2 did better compared to AirPods Pro 1 is handling multi-device connection. It’s easier to transition between devices with tolerable delay, though the Mac side still REQUIRE You to respond to the pop-up or it will not connect. Old AirPods Pro 1 just can’t handle this and Shure SE215’s bluetooth accessory handles their multi-device connection (as generic Bluetooth device btw) BETTER than Apple’s own device with Proprietary chip.

Outside of that, the fitting feels just about right. Ability to adjust the volume without invoking Siri is a definite plus (I hate Siri with passion). Bluetooth range is about the same sadly. And there’s no improvements in terms of the connection (after pairing). Sometimes it happens in 1s, sometimes I have to put down, put back up, then put down several times, and wait for about 5s to get it connected, which is just bad.

Not to say I’m terribly satisfied, but better than previous generation for sure. And oh, that speaker on the case is great. Wonder why it was not there in the first place. Lanyard is also a nice touch.
 

GustavPicora

macrumors member
Jan 22, 2010
84
23
I've had my airpods pro 2 for 2 months already, and I love them. Sound and noice canceling is amazing, and that is coming from Bose QC35. The only problem I have with the Airpods Pro2 is, that on an incoming call, when I press the earbud to answer the call, it takes like 10 secs for me to listen to the other person. So most people calling me just hang up.
During those 10 sec aprox, I feel how my airpods try to connect, (noise canceling turning on and off, left-right-left) and so on, until finally I can hear the other end.
Things I have tried:
- Restart airpods,
- Unpair
- Factory restore
- (on iPhone) forget network settings.
- Firmware update and OS update

Nothing, nothing helps.

I have no problems whatsoever when making a call.

Has someone had this issue?

G.
 

clickerman

macrumors member
Jul 23, 2010
37
15
I recently bought the Airpods gen 2 and they kept falling out of my ear. So I bought some $29 earbuds, and they seem every bit as good as the Airpods, and they don't fall out. If they go bad, I just get a replacement.
 

SnappleRumors

Suspended
Aug 22, 2022
394
512
AirPods vs. Sony, Bose and Other Third-Party Options

First off, if you're curious why you should choose AirPods at all when there are so many headphone brands on the market, it's because AirPods offer the best integration with Apple's iPhones, Macs, iPads, Apple Watches, and Apple TVs.

Apple‘s AirPods integrate better with Apple products than third-party options. Well that’s sounds fishy. 🤔

I prefer the Samsung Galaxy Buds2 Pro even though some of the features won’t work on Apple products.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.