Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Screenshot 2020-12-10 at 14.45.11.png


From MKBHD's video - I think there is an "off" mode that just isn't enabled (presuming the option can be ticked).
 
Come on. Does anyone expect MKHBD or iJustine to say anything remotely critical of an Apple product? Otherwise bye-bye early review units.

Those things are like the illegitimate offspring of an Aeron office chair and an Apple Watch.
MKBHD had nothing good to say about the case, or the fact that a 3.5mm plug wasn’t included in the box.
 
Not a fan of these headphones.
i thought the time of big over the ear headphones was over.

Why would you think the time was over? Physics is physics. Sure you can argue that all headphones/ear buds serve the same purpose, sound in your ears, but not all experiences are even remotely similar. Over the ear is a different fit than in ear. Some people will chose on fit. Over the ear offers better mechanics for noise cancellation when you dont want something crammed in your ear.
 
Anyone else find these tech youtubers really hard to watch? There is just no substance to them. I’ll wait for the verge review.
Some of them. I do like many of them like MKBHD and Average Consumer because I do think for the most part they are unbiased. Unbox Therapy will destroy these if they aren't good as Lew is a big headphone guy.

iJustine is just painful to watch. Its like she's speaking to tween girls. Which maybe that's who her audience is but I find it beyond grating.
 
Come on. Does anyone expect MKHBD or iJustine to say anything remotely critical of an Apple product? Otherwise bye-bye early review units.

Those things are like the illegitimate offspring of an Aeron office chair and an Apple Watch.
I think he's probably one of the most impartial reviewers out there to be honest - I don't always agree with him, but I don't doubt his integrity for one second.
 
View attachment 1690795

From MKBHD's video - I think there is an "off" mode that just isn't enabled (presuming the option can be ticked).

That off is for turning off the noise cancellation or transparency features, not for turning off the headset. Air Pods Pro has the same software setting. I believe the OP was talking about a power off.
 
Actually MKBHD didn’t know what to compare them to. Everyone else seems to be comparing them to Sony and Bose, both of which are cheaper and have received good reviews. This is like the HomePod all over again. And you’re wrong about that. The HomePod was mostly compared to cheaper smart speakers from Google and Amazon, not high end speakers or theater systems. If Apple marketing was smart they’d be giving reviewers reference points to more expensive headphones so instead of reviewers wondering if they’re worth the premium they’d be saying wow they sound as good (or better) as [insert brand here] and they’re cheaper. Also why the heck is iJustine getting a review unit?!? She’s the last person I’d go to for advice on premium headphones. And neither MKBHD nor Nilay Patel had much good to say about the case so I doubt they will be dishonest when they do a more in-depth review of the sound quality.
I tend to like MKBHD full reviews but iJustine I tend to see as just a commercial for whatever product she gets.
She's pretty so she gets the clicks, can't fault her, if I was a female and could pull it off I would too. Her sister was able to ride her coattails into becoming a reviewer too. I wouldn't watch iJustine video to decide if I wanted to by a product.
 
For everyone saying Apple only gives review units to friendly reviewers, this is what Nilay Patel said about the headphone case:
“It is one of the cheaper-feeling things Apple has ever made, in my estimation”.
I doubt that’s what Apple marketing wants to hear (even if that comment might be a bit hyperbolic).
 
  • Like
Reactions: G5isAlive
Here we are..... Now that all the trolls did and will continue to do their thing. Watch these come close or blow away the sound of headphones that cost the same or even many times more.

I agree, haters got to hate. shrugs. I am encouraged by the you tubers comments, supports what realistic folks have been saying since the announcement. Though yeah, will still look forward to a more nuanced, dare I say 'informed' evaluation. I strongly believe at the end of the day Apple has hit this one out fo the park from a technical stand point. Whether it is a commercial success, remains to be seen. But that's for stockholders to worry about me, I like my HomePods even though they will never be the commercial success people seem to think is a sign of quality. I am sure I am going to like this headset as well. Yep I got my preorder in.
 
I agree, haters got to hate. shrugs. I am encouraged by the you tubers comments, supports what realistic folks have been saying since the announcement. Though yeah, will still look forward to a more nuanced, dare I say 'informed' evaluation. I strongly believe at the end of the day Apple has hit this one out fo the park from a technical stand point. Whether it is a commercial success, remains to be seen. But that's for stockholders to worry about me, I like my HomePods even though they will never be the commercial success people seem to think is a sign of quality. I am sure I am going to like this headset as well. Yep I got my preorder in.
Agreed. I too, love my HomePod and did from the start. Some people appreciate quality sound and others don't, and thats fine. Apple is rivaling high end consumer companies like Bose, B&O and other companies that are even niche. What they are doing with sound research is beyond belief.
 
Some of them. I do like many of them like MKBHD and Average Consumer because I do think for the most part they are unbiased. Unbox Therapy will destroy these if they aren't good as Lew is a big headphone guy.

iJustine is just painful to watch. Its like she's speaking to tween girls. Which maybe that's who her audience is but I find it beyond grating.

I don’t mind some of MKBHDs videos although I do find he sits in the middle of the road most of the time and doesn’t want to be too critical of anything.

Lew just criticises Apple to make a point I think.

As for iJustine, I’ve managed to stop seeing her videos on my YouTube account. No idea how I managed but I am glad!
 
Come on. Does anyone expect MKHBD or iJustine to say anything remotely critical of an Apple product? Otherwise bye-bye early review units.

Those things are like the illegitimate offspring of an Aeron office chair and an Apple Watch.

I disagree about MKBHD. Yeah he has a good relationship with Apple, but he is critical of them when he feels its warranted. iJustine on the other hand might as well be an Apple employee. She doesn't review Apple products, she fawns over them on video while acting like she's 12 years old.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.