Apple has to do something to keep up with the speed, ease of use, thousands of free watch faces & apps, and free SDK, of Pebble. Not to mention
What use are thousands of free watch faces, when most look similar and pretty fugly due to the low-res and low-contrast screen?
What use are thousands of free apps, when I only can have 8 apps concurrently on the device and constantly have to shuffle?
And I can't see the ease of use if I have to do everything with just 4 buttons instead of a touch screen _plus_ 2 buttons.
the superior outdoors visibility,
From practical use I can't confirm that statement. So far the bright AW screen is as visible as the low-contrast Pebble screen for me. Granted, I only know the original Pebble. But the AW screen is fine.
Same for the AW. Depending on usage, I can get 2-3 days easily from it. The difference to 5-7 days with the Pebble is negligible in my eyes.
True. On the other hand this also means a far inferior user interface on the Pebble. Having to handle everything with 4 buttons instead of a touch screen is pretty cumbersome.
much better waterproofing,
Apple may not officially claim water proofness of the Apple watch, but there a lots of reports of people who shower and swim with the AW without problems. And Apple itself recommends a cleaning under running water from time to time.
So it's probably more a question of liability issues and reputation just in case something goes wrong with a seal. Can happen to every product, only with Apple it would generate a huge - unjustified - hype. With Pebble people would shrug and move on.
and android + iPhone compatibility.
The iPhone compatibility of the classic Pebble was flakey at best. Mine would often lose connection after leaving the BT range or just random. Pretty annoying, especially as reconnecting often did not work properly.
As a matter of fact, the only things the Apple Watch does better than Pebble are allowing you to take a phone call on your watch (with crappy sound from a too small speaker), heart rate monitoring (for some people but not others), and draw pictures on the watch face. In contrast, the range of creativity of Pebble apps is amazing.
Taking phone calls on the AW is very convenient and the speaker is not as crappy as you write. Just the opposite - for such a small speaker the sound quality is surprisingly good. Heart rate monitoring is a good thing for everyone, even if not everyone sees the benefit.
Other advantages of the AW vs the Pebble (which you either don't know about or intentionally ignored) are the deep integration into iOS, the HiRes color touch screen, the WLan connectivity (when outside BT range, but within my home WLan), the better product finish, more internal storage for apps, the problem-free loading solution (with the Pebble, the cable was so fragile when plugged in you would not even dare looking at it) and probably more that I don't think about now.
I admit that newer models may have improved on some of the problems I experienced with the classic Pebble, but from what I read the new models are just small improvements in bulky housings. Perhaps nice as a platform for programmers and modders with less money but more time, but aiming at a different target group than the AW.
Seriously? I never claimed to be the personification of a giant company made up of hundreds of people, once headed by a guy who was so obsessed with quality that he'd have thrown a huge fit if the Watch didn't perform amazingly on day 1.
- I used OSX 10.0.4 and 10.1 - they were far from "performing amazingly on day 1" (and that was on a 450MHz G4 - one of the fastest Macs available back then).
- The original iPhone lacked the then-common 3G and was limited to 2G speeds (as an officially marketed "Internet communication device" !), had only 128MB Ram and 4 GB storage as entry.
- The original MacBook Air was painfully slow - the very expensive SSD option sometimes even slower than the spinning disk variants (iirc) - and likely to overheat easily, thus throttling and impairing user experience.
- The iPhone 4 had reception problems due to the antenna construction.
There is a significant number of cases where Steve approved the release of "unfinished" products. Sometimes you just have to get something out of the door (for various reasons) and Steve knew this very well.