I threw it up on offer up and getting all these low balling offers like $200, $230 , etc. am I selling my watch for too high or am I just having really crappy luck in my area?
If it was a rare or timeless fashion accessory, it would make sense that an AW could hold or even appreciate in value.
But, AW are far from timeless and definitely not rare, as the AW is more mass-produced tech device than fashion accessory, and they are released yearly.
It would be different if the SS models came with increased performance or better battery, but since there is no functionality difference between the various finishes, the market to get a used fashion accessory (the SS part of the AW) is going to be low.
When someone can get a new S3 for $199 or a S5 for $399, any used AW would probably be hard to sell above these prices, regardless of the finish.
If someone is in the market for a SS model, that means that the appearance of the item is more important than the functionality, so they would probably be more likely not in the market for a used one.
If somebody owns a stainless steel Apple Watch , you have to be prepared to realize that it won’t ’fetch’ the higher resale value that you were expecting. But then again, it’s a tech item that’s mass produced, that generally declines very quickly, because Apple has been continuously releasing new Apple Watch models annually.
This is true, and why the Apple Watch fails as a fashion accessory. Or, at least one that holds its value.
It is a mass-produced tech device first, and will depreciate in value as such. It would be different if the AW was just a one-time release, but with updates yearly, they will not hold their value when compared to some other fashion accessories.