OP
I had the same problem as you did- BestBuy only had one version of it and was trying to sell the $14.99 online product for $30. I price matched target for $14.99 and bought it. Hated the look of it on the screen.
Here is what you should do (same thing I did)
I called their customer service told them I hated the screen and the rep told me she could send me a replacement regular piece, not the antiglare kind, and she sent it to me for free- no shipping cost. I love it. It hasnt turned yellow so far, it has the same texture and the screen is clear as can be. Give that a shot.