Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
Not open for further replies.
As a pediatrician:
No child that young is going to be responsible enough to not destroy a laptop. That having been said, if you must...something along the lines of a ToughBook.

I'd recommend a used iMac, in a public place in the house, with use under supervision and with parental controls on. And limits on time. Children best learn from interaction. At least opposed to TV there is some of that with computing.

Very reasonable response.....I appreciate the input. For what it's worth, I'm a physician as well, and my sister-in-law is a Pediatrician, so believe you me, we've touched on some of these same issues before.

I continue to be amazed at the level of pontification, and the tacit assumption that all other parents are drooling idiots, that is manifest in some of the responses to my OP. By no means am I a perfect parent, but geez, some of the stuff brought up in other responses.....unbelieveable. There must be a lot of "perfect" parents out there.....
 
I'm pretty sure the OPs child gets plenty of exercise and playtime.

That being said building computer skills in this day in age IMO is just as important as learning to read/write etc. I would have LOVED to been able to grow up with computers when I was little because thats what I was interested in.

I would suggest either a desktop so the child cant drop or break it or something like an Asus EEEPc running Xandros linux. Xandros is easy to pick up and also exposes the kid to something other then Windows. Also linux has tons of educational programs and software available.

Thanks for your helpful response.....I have been looking at the Asus machines too.....
 
I have to wonder - everyone who thinks a 3-year-old has no business having his own computer, how many of you actually have, or recently had, a 3-year-old?

My son got his first computer when he was 3 because my wife and I wanted ours back. I'm not saying he was writing code or using Facebook, but he started learning his letters, counting, shapes, colors, etc. on a computer before he even turned 3. He's 4 now and uses Wikipedia to look up information on planets and volcanoes and such. No, he doesn't touch-type, but he can hunt and peck enough to type "Jupiter" in the search window and navigate to a page. When he wants to know more about volcanoes, he looks it up online. If you think kids that age aren't capable you're sorely mistaken.



I haven't read anything more incorrect than this in a long time. Like I said, they don't do the things you would do on a computer, but that doesn't make it a poor tool for them.

And yes, many 3-year-olds can read well enough to use a computer. They aren't reading War and Peace, but they can navigate around with a mouse and click what the program tells them to click.



You've obviously forgotten that a 3-year-old doesn't have the kind of attention span it would take to spend all day on a computer and become a loner. They very seldom do anything (other than sleep) for longer than an hour or so before they want to move on to something else. My son will leave his computer to go outside and ride his scooter, or drive a remote control car, or read a book, or whatever else a kid that age would do (regardless of whether you think they're capable of doing it).

VERY well said.....
 
For those who asked earlier if anyone here has had a 3 year old- I actually have had two three year olds myself...they are now 6 and 8. I also am an elementary school teacher and teach 2nd and 3rd graders.

For the OP. I think many comments were sarcasm:rolleyes:
I also think many comments were not sarcasm and rightfully so.

Unfortunately it is easy for one to jump to conclusions these days with so many unqualified parents!!! YOu would be amazed at the stories I hear and see about parents and their "babysitting methods" NO longer are some parents solely relying WAAAYY too much on the neglectomatic for neglectful parenting, but have moved on to more undesirable methods of childcare and TV, computers, video games, handheld electronics, talking bears, etc. Don't get me wrong- I have had plenty of electronics in my childs' hands,

So I would say it is not a big jump for someone to think that if you really need to buy your 3 year old his/her OWN computer then they must be going to spend quite a bit of time on it.....or else you would just let them jump on your lap and your computer for a few minutes and bang/tap around.

OP-I commend your preschool program for doing all the things you list, but I believe a computer really has no place in a preschool program. Some preschools embrace them and some don't. It all depends on how it is used, how often, and how much screen time the children get at home or other daycare situations in a day. I would question why they have it, what their learning objectives are for the computer, and why they feel like early childhood education necessitates this method of instruction. Most anything that a preschool child can learn from a computer they can learn from a book or other method.

(Note- this is coming from an elementary teacher who has a SmartBoard installed on his wall with an LCD projector mounted above and has students use computers (Mac and unfortunately PC's), iPods, and many other technological items at various times throughout the day. However, there is a time and a place for technology to be used and there are sound, research based reasons it should be used in specific educational settings. In my mind it isn't necessary and we really don't know the true effects considerable screen time has on very young children- there are some good studies being done now, but it will be a while before results are in.)
 
Just let him use your computer with parental supervision, don't buy him one at 3, that's just money down the toilet because he is just going to break it.

Wait until atleast 6-7 about the time they should learn how to take care of their stuff, then buy them a cheap used one, make it very clear to them to take care of it, and don't buy them another if they break it. ;)
 
i got my first ever computer (not shared) at age 21.
I guess having a personal computer when you're young, especially at 3, can be beneficial since it will help with some development and also provide some exposure to the technological advancements of today's society, but sometimes sharing is caring! If that was my kid, i'd just let him sit on my lap as i teach him how to use my comp.
 
but sometimes sharing is caring! If that was my kid, i'd just let him sit on my lap as i teach him how to use my comp.

This is good advice if you feel you must start your child off early but be sure to do small amounts of this. Remember, you child will learn how to use a computer in elementary school at a more appropriate developmental age. There are certain ages where things are better to be taught and education is a very planned process of helping children learn what they should learn at the age appropriate time. It bugs me that many parents (not necessarily you or anyone reading this) push their kids to learn everything before they even enter school. Those are the kids that are pushed to start reading, given math workbooks at age 3 or 4 or even 5, pushed to do "extra math" practice in the evenings or weekends after Kindergarten class, among other things are they are usually the ones who end up getting bored in school or put too much pressure on themselves (and can often end up not being the highly successful ones) because it becomes so difficult for the teacher to engage the child among other reasons. Only the best teachers are able to engage this type of child and at the same time move the rest of the class forward all while controlling behavior.

Our children are being bombarded with screen time in so many ways. It won't be long until that crib lights toy is replaced by an LCD screen! A small amount of screen time for children younger than 5 is fine, but please please if you hae small children limit that time. I was a stay at home father for 6 years with my two little ones. I know how hard it is to resist screen time with kids. (I have to admit my own kids probably caught a little too much Sports Center out of the corner of their eyes while I would sit on the floor and play ball with them!! But I was almost always playing with them and they didn;t just fixate on the screen!!) And choose screen time which has some purpose other than babysitting. The little einstein videos which show regular baby toys set to classical music are a good choice.

In fact, too much screen time can have very detrimental effects as well in both development and behavior areas. Children who get too much screen time often have more severe ADD and ADHD symptoms, and are usually much more difficult to engage in an educational setting unless there is a screen involved!

The most important thing parents can do for their children to help them be successful in school and later in life is to :

1. Read, Read Read. Read to them, let them flip through books, have book always lying on the table, let them see you read books, go to the library. My wife read to our kids even before they were born. The day they were born we read to them. Every night since birth they have had several books read to them at bedtime as well as dozens throughout the day. When they got to where they no longer wanted to eat the books we let them "read" on their own and even as they fell asleep. They could not read yet, but could look at the pictures and enjoy books. When they get older, like second or third grade and actually start reading on their own, don't stop reading aloud to them. This is still an important age for an adult to read aloud to children. It helps them learn how to read with emotion and builds reading fluency. Even if a parent can't afford to buy books, get them from the library, get a library card for your child at an early age, make it a thing they *love* to do every week!

For the record, I was not a "reader" as a child. I was actually a horrible student- part of the reason why I am not a teacher- I don't want children to get lost in the shuffle. My son, who also loves to play video games with me, is a far better reader than I was as a child. He is in the third grade, scores in the 99 percentile in his reading scores and can read anything we put in front of him. My daughter scores in the 78 percentile in her reading scores as well. I believe both of my children doing well is a direct result of what I describe above (no, not the sportscenter exposure!:rolleyes:) but the READ READ, READ paragraph! Neither of them read at a particularly early age and that is by no means my goal of the above advice. However, what it did do was provide them a love of books and love of learning. My son wakes up at 5AM and pulls out a Charlie Bone book and reads it for an hour and a half before even asking for breakfast- and that is a big deal if you knew my son- he loves to eat!:D

More than enough advice for today!

Now I have to go eat myself- I love to eat too!;)
 
3 is too young for their own computer. A laptop is to delicate for them to use anyways.

I have a 5 year old who loves having her own signon for our iMac. She gets her own password and I can limit the sites and programs I want her to use. She also has limits on how much time she can spend on it before it logs her out. That being said I have a 2 year old who is almost three. I don't let her anywhere near my computer.

I would like to purchase a mini in a year or two that the kids can share. I have seen some really cool keyboards at Costco with huge keys that kids can use. I have to agree with the folks who recommend the leapster products. My five year old would love a Nintendo DS, but we played it safe and got her a leapster 2. I made the mistake of letting her play a few games on the Wii with me and now she wants to play all the time. I have to tell her no more than yes. Save yourself the hassle and wait as long as you can!
 
I have to agree with the folks who recommend the leapster products. My five year old would love a Nintendo DS, but we played it safe and got her a leapster 2. I made the mistake of letting her play a few games on the Wii with me and now she wants to play all the time. I have to tell her no more than yes. Save yourself the hassle and wait as long as you can!

We started with the leapster for my son, my daughter now uses it. My inlaws purchased a Wii and DS for my son but not before he was 7 and 8 respectively. I had an old PS2 I had on occasion let my son try when he turned 7 and never let him touch my PS3 as of yet! :D

That being said, he never plays video games during the week, and only on Friday evenings (about 1 hour), Sat. and Sunday about 1 to 1.5 hours max) He is in charge of setting the timer, and quitting when the timer goes off. He has become very reliable with managing his own screen time. We do allow some TV on top of this video game time, but it also depends on how much outdoor time he has. The more outdoor time the more flexible we are with screen time. (his tv time involved such highly educational stuff as phineas and ferb:rolleyes: but also Survivorman and How it's Made)
 
I would highly reccomend a desktop, much safer for a youngster to be using. My nephew (2) is using my brothers old dell dimension with windows xp which is perfect for the web, sites like sesamestreet.com and such. Thats what i would reccomend, a 3-4 year old tower with winxp. If you feel a mac is a better choice, look into a iMac g4 and set it up with tiger... or if you really want to go with a laptop.. id say either an iBook G4 or a 2-3 year old dell laptop is best. nothing new.. thats just foolish.
 
My son turns 3 in February, and we'd like to build on basic computer skills that he is learning in preschool (believe me, I'm still struggling with the fact that I have to even post this!).....I wonder if the next generation will start driving at 4, or something like that.....

Anyway, they use a Windows based machine at school, so I've been thinking about a Windows box for consistency sake, then getting him a Mac when he's a little older.

Alternatively, maybe I should just start him on a Mac -- would be looking at an older MacBook or something like that if I went the Mac route.

Any suggestions, or specific systems anyone might recommend? I'm willing to go up to $500-$750, prefer to stay lower - most bang for the buck, so to speak.....

Thanks!

I would definitely get the little tyke a MacBook Air. At his age, he can't be very strong, so "light and thin" FTW.

The next question is: what productivity apps should he use? I would forego the MS-suite and even Apple products for Open Source freeware such as Open Office. After all, spending habits are determined early on in life, and it's never too early to teach them the value of money!

Then you have to ask yourself: which professional apps to get him? It's never too early to learn a trade; and the pro apps available on the Mac will nurture creativity that will serve him well, no matter where he goes in life. Eschew "iProducts" (iMovie, GarageBand) in favor of the Express products (FinalCut, Logic). The dumbed-down consumer-level products are intended for busy adults with no time to learn things, rather than a young child with a veritable sponge for a brain, and he would soon outgrow them; the full products, on the other hand, are just too richly featured, and the Air would be obsolete by the time he needed the additional features. Why pay for something he will never use?

Finally, don't forget the essentials extras: an external drive to backup his valuable documents and creations; a videocam (firewire!); and a MIDI keyboard. I would suggest buying some plastic or rubber pads to glue onto these items, so when he teethes on them he will not leave any permanent marks!
 
I would definitely get the little tyke a MacBook Air. At his age, he can't be very strong, so "light and thin" FTW.

The next question is: what productivity apps should he use? I would forego the MS-suite and even Apple products for Open Source freeware such as Open Office. After all, spending habits are determined early on in life, and it's never too early to teach them the value of money!

Then you have to ask yourself: which professional apps to get him? It's never too early to learn a trade; and the pro apps available on the Mac will nurture creativity that will serve him well, no matter where he goes in life. Eschew "iProducts" (iMovie, GarageBand) in favor of the Express products (FinalCut, Logic). The dumbed-down consumer-level products are intended for busy adults with no time to learn things, rather than a young child with a veritable sponge for a brain, and he would soon outgrow them; the full products, on the other hand, are just too richly featured, and the Air would be obsolete by the time he needed the additional features. Why pay for something he will never use?

Finally, don't forget the essentials extras: an external drive to backup his valuable documents and creations; a videocam (firewire!); and a MIDI keyboard. I would suggest buying some plastic or rubber pads to glue onto these items, so when he teethes on them he will not leave any permanent marks!

ROFLMAO :D
 
If you get a laptop for your child you can always do this:
minifig-macbook.jpg


Or better yet this:
bibi-macbook.jpg


And when teeth are coming in this will happen:
chewedmacbook.jpg


Just beware of teething on the cord:
unibodymacbook.jpg


And that toy Craftsman hammer can always fix hardware issues:
broken-MacBook-LCD-screen-l.jpg
 
Get an old colored powerbook G3 $50 on eBay will run tiger be more than enough to learn on! Or you can always get a netbook and dual boot windows linux and OS X just make sure it has an N70 Atom processor. I think its a great idea for a 3 year old to start learning basics of all OS'S.
 
My children started using computers around that age. Our middle child started the earliest and now (13) instructs his teachers on how to write simple video games for class demonstrations (and, btw, dear readers, he is a normal, well adjusted individual so put that in your pipe and smoke it). I purchased a cheap but durable looking PC for the kids and it lasted about 7 years. Their skills actually outgrew the machine before it wore out so don't spend too much.
 
My 4 yr old uses a 17" imac G4. It uses simple finder so it is easy to navigate and have parental controls which only allows quicktime and a few games to be opened. She has 2 folders, one with Disney/Pixar movies, the other with educational games. She loves the Dr Suess app. We have the computer set up in the family room on a little desk. My almost 2 yr old loves to sit next to her and watch too. I would not spend more than what i paid for the G4 which was $200
Its fast enough to run the low graphic games and I compressed the movies enough to run smooth. I also bought a screen protector for the screen ;)
 
I would definitely get the little tyke a MacBook Air. At his age, he can't be very strong, so "light and thin" FTW.
...
Finally, don't forget the essentials extras: an external drive to backup his valuable documents and creations; a videocam (firewire!); and a MIDI keyboard. I would suggest buying some plastic or rubber pads to glue onto these items, so when he teethes on them he will not leave any permanent marks!

You'll confuse a 3 three year-old too much with a MacBook Air and a Firewire videocam.
 
No No and No

Forget a computer or other electronic games. get him some blocks and tinker toys or other toys that make him use his imagination and creativity.
Focus on teaching him how to learn and where to get information and not off the internet. Teach them social skills and such.
Hell go find some large boxes and I bet he will have more fun and learn more from that than a computer.

I for one am disgusted at how clueless the young kids are today on reality. How inept they are at solving problems and coming up with new ideas.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.