Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I write Amazon reviews too. But only when I have something to say and am very pleased with something. Unless it's constructive criticism, I don't leave a negative review, and would rather skip it.

I made a blog post entitled, "Dear Writers, I don’t want to read your book," I bet you can guess what that's about. ;)
 
I write Amazon reviews too. But only when I have something to say and am very pleased with something. Unless it's constructive criticism, I don't leave a negative review, and would rather skip it.



I made a blog post entitled, "Dear Writers, I don’t want to read your book," I bet you can guess what that's about. ;)


I would never review read a book just for reviewing even if it was a sample. I hate reading.
 
That's unfortunate.



I hate reading.

Wow. You really hate reading?? It really is unfortunate. Oh and you're currently reading Lord of the Flies for school, right? How's it going so far? I read it recently and found it to be a compelling read :)


Anyway, I rarely post reviews on Amazon. I think I've only written two reviews. One is for a classic novel called The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas because I really loved it (and which I think everyone should read). The other is also a review for a book, it was for Blood Song by Anthony Ryan as I also really enjoyed it.
 
Anyone an Amazon Reviewer?

Wow. You really hate reading?? It really is unfortunate. Oh and you're currently reading Lord of the Flies for school, right? How's it going so far? I read it recently and found it to be a compelling read :)


Anyway, I rarely post reviews on Amazon. I think I've only written two reviews. One is for a classic novel called The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas because I really loved it (and which I think everyone should read). The other is also a review for a book, it was for Blood Song by Anthony Ryan as I also really enjoyed it.


When I am required to read it for school as homework, I use spark notes like lost other people in my class do. Only time I open the book is for projects and class reading.
The book is fine, at the part where the hunters and jack do you know what to a pig.
 
When I am required to read it for school as homework, I use spark notes like lost other people in my class do. Only time I open the book is for projects and class reading.
The book is fine, at the part where the hunters and jack do you know what to a pig.

LOL. Yes, I used to use Spark Notes for Shakespeare when I was in school.

I'm interested to see your Amazon profile. Mind sending me the link? :)
 
I write Amazon reviews too. But only when I have something to say and am very pleased with something. Unless it's constructive criticism, I don't leave a negative review, and would rather skip it.

I've been buying from Amazon for over a decade and can count the number my reviews on one hand (4 reviews total:eek:). I only review if it's something if it's really, really good "best thing since sliced bread" item (Kindle Keyboard) or if it's really, really bad "learn from my mistake" item.
 
I review what I purchase. About 2 reviews a month. I'm definitely not one of those reviewers who posts a 10 paragraph review.
 
I review everything I purchase, which is on average 1-2 items a month. I generally buy items from Amazon after first checking out the reviews, so I feel I should contribute too.

I'd want a reviewer to disclose if they got the product for free because a large part of the review is value for money. I'd have to take their opinion on that matter with a touch of salt..
 
Anyone an Amazon Reviewer?

I review what I purchase. About 2 reviews a month. I'm definitely not one of those reviewers who posts a 10 paragraph review.


Neither am I. I do pros and cons most of the time. I do about 40 reviews a month.

----------

I review everything I purchase, which is on average 1-2 items a month. I generally buy items from Amazon after first checking out the reviews, so I feel I should contribute too.

I'd want a reviewer to disclose if they got the product for free because a large part of the review is value for money. I'd have to take their opinion on that matter with a touch of salt..


That's what I do:) I sometimes talk about the price. Like comparing apples wall charger to another one on amazon that I think is a much better value.
 
Stuff to review + an air mattress.
7udada6a.jpg
 
Given that you do so many reviews a month, how long do you use a product before you sit down and give a verdict? I find that you aren't able to really know how good a product is until you use it for a few months. What's your philosophy behind what makes a good product, ie function vs durability etc.?
 
Anyone an Amazon Reviewer?

Given that you do so many reviews a month, how long do you use a product before you sit down and give a verdict? I find that you aren't able to really know how good a product is until you use it for a few months. What's your philosophy behind what makes a good product, ie function vs durability etc.?


For a cases I say what features it has like a lip of the screen and the feeling if it.
For most products I say all the features, ease of use, how to set it up, price value, specs of usb power like chargers, for speakers I say how loud and how it sounds, Ect.
Takes me around 1-2 hr for a review. Sometimes longer.
 
I review everything I purchase, which is on average 1-2 items a month. I generally buy items from Amazon after first checking out the reviews, so I feel I should contribute too.

I'd want a reviewer to disclose if they got the product for free because a large part of the review is value for money. I'd have to take their opinion on that matter with a touch of salt..

That's one of the nice things about Amazon's verified purchase notice. If the reviewer actually purchased the item from Amazon, it will appear at the top of the review. I give those more weight when it comes to making a decision.
 
It is against the rules. It counts as self promoting. But since you asked for it I believe I can:
https://www.amazon.com/gp/pdp/profile/A2LTYEYGKBYXRR?ie=UTF8&ref_=cm_cr_rdp_pdp

Just out of curiosity, at the bottom of your review it says, "I was supplied a sample for test and evaluation, and I promised that my review is fair and honest."

I appreciate that you disclosed this.

But the wording may be a bit misleading. When you say you were supplied a sample for test and evaluation, that could imply that after the test and evaluation you sent your sample back. But from earlier posts, it sounded like you keep the products they send you.

Could you clarify that point?

Thank you.
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Just out of curiosity, at the bottom of your review it says, "I was supplied a sample for test and evaluation, and I promised that my review is fair and honest."



I appreciate that you disclosed this.



But the wording may be a bit misleading. When you say you were supplied a sample for test and evaluation, that could imply that after the test and evaluation you sent your sample back. But from earlier posts, it sounded like you keep the products they send you.



Could you clarify that point?



Thank you.


I keep all the products I review.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.