Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I keep buying some albums on vinyl, but mroe and more I buy MP3's of bandcamp. I tend to rent movies as it's unlikely I will watch em more than once tbh, LOTR aside
 
For me physical media is all that I can store on my SSD. So I would rather pirate-proof myself with copies than rely on internet-dependent streaming services. I only pirate good, usually old stuff that I had on VHS or DVD back in the days, haven’t watched a single Netflix movie in more than 7 years, same for Apple TV or other services. Basically same with music, most that I would listen is on Soundcloud or YouTube (if I do stream) and other stuff is already in mp3 format, written on dozen of CDs I have somewhere.

It is sad that CD era is gone, but on the other hand these disks were unreliable. SSD and flash are the new frontier, too sad they don’t sell stuff on these disks. However there are a few exceptions like Nintendo who still sell games on real, physical SD-card like cartridges that are not tied to any digital telemetry, you just put it in your console and play in an instant, no waiting for download, no need to worry about installation size
 
I'm a very casual gamer these days and I think like you about physical. But I've noticed modern games rely on the updates and patches on games in order to play. do we risk the disc being redundant if the console insists on us downloading an update? or say when game is old, the disc won't work because the server won't let you play it?
A fair number of current releases nowadays (especially most Nintendo Switch games) will still work without patches, I use this site to check on which those are: https://www.doesitplay.org/
 
  • Like
Reactions: tranceking26
Physical media solves many modern problems:
- No ads
- Purposefully limited selection (ie no doomscroll)
- Ownership
- You can lend them to people
- Access to films and TV long since abandoned
And you can check it out from your local library for free.

I've been listening to books on CD on my commute lately that I check out from the library. They have a great selection and I don't spend a penny on it and I don't listen to a single ad. My library has a great DVD selection too.
 
And you can check it out from your local library for free.

I've been listening to books on CD on my commute lately that I check out from the library. They have a great selection and I don't spend a penny on it and I don't listen to a single ad. My library has a great DVD selection too.
I think some libraries have digital media you can borrow too. This is what my friend told me so I'm not sure how it works exactly, but they have a limited number of licenses of each media so you still have to "check out" and "return" media (probably through an app) and wait for someone to return a copy if they're all checked out.
 
I think some libraries have digital media you can borrow too. This is what my friend told me so I'm not sure how it works exactly, but they have a limited number of licenses of each media so you still have to "check out" and "return" media (probably through an app) and wait for someone to return a copy if they're all checked out.
Ours does. It uses the Libby app. Checkout is similar to traditional books and physical media from the library; you borrow it for a certain period of time and return it through the app when you're finished. It automatically returns it if you reach the end of the borrowing period and there are holds on the item, otherwise will let you renew it. You can borrow e-books, audiobooks, etc. There are other apps where you can borrow digital copies of movies and tv series as well.
 
Sure. My library does the same. I've not tried it, but I'm guessing it has the same faults as most other digital media. Countless ads, doom scrolling, lots of garbage options. (pure speculation)

The physical media at my library is pretty great though. Plenty of movies and tv shows on dvd that are only available on paid streaming platforms. I doubt the digital side of the library has the same options. I don't see how it could. Maybe I'm wrong?
 
I've never left. I've been ridiculed by some millennials (not even Gen Z) saying, Who is still buying CDs in 2020?” -usually from someone with a nose ring and a tendency toward extreme worldviews. Others didn’t say anything, but they also dove completely into the digital world of streaming. I think that's very bad for personal use and preservation: own nothing and be happy, rent everything and be happy.

In my opinion, I prefer to own less but to truly love and own what I buy. It’s not nostalgia, it’s how things are meant to be. I don’t want to just increase the profits of a company that no longer feels the need to provide me with an actual product. I want to have ownership of what I pay for. Sure, someone might say that discs degrade, but that happens far more slowly than the rapid changes in licensing rights, movie credits, music geo-restrictions, and the instability of online platforms. I TRULY hope more and more people rethink their habits so we can return to a norm of physical media—not just books, but CDs, Blu-rays, etc.

A call to action from my side: This winter for Christmas if you have children, nephews, nieces, or friends etc. give them some physical media - or something to play physical media. Tell them about the beauty of it the collecting, the feeling of being a real fan of a band, discovering things by searching in stores or online, and then finally holding the product in their hands. It is not consumerism; it is really is connection, culture, and ownership.
 
  • Like
Reactions: schnaps
One thing that really stinks about this realization is that new cars don't have CD players anymore (many of them). My wife's car is a 2019 and doesn't have one.
 
I’m 43 so grew up with VHS, DVD, blu ray and then I moved to digital purchases and streaming.

Maybe it’s nostalgia but I’ve oddly started thinking about buying blu rays again… I was telling a friend and he oddly was having same thoughts.. I think we both have streaming fatigue where it takes ages to find something to watch..

We both miss the days of blockbuster!

Anyone else ?
I am 70 and went from 3 channels in B/W thru Beta and VHS to DVD to Blu Ray to Ultra Blu Ray. I also now have a large lubrary on apple tv. I like the security if owning a disk as you are dependent on Apple not selling off or closing Apple TV. I still buy the occasional disk but these tend to be limited releases or Ultra Blu Ray for my favorite 10 or so Movies.
On the downloads side Apple do not milk you continually with new releases. If you buy HD it changes to 4k when available. Which is much better.
Also for use on long flight I find the difference on my smaller macbook means I am happy watching downloads and not carrying all the disks which I used to do. Additionally, although I have Blu Ray software and an external blu ray drive, apple have always had a downer on physical media.
So yes and no. UHD disks for the top 10, the odd rare Blu Ray or even DVD and apple tv for most of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: schnaps
Sure. My library does the same. I've not tried it, but I'm guessing it has the same faults as most other digital media. Countless ads, doom scrolling, lots of garbage options. (pure speculation)

The physical media at my library is pretty great though. Plenty of movies and tv shows on dvd that are only available on paid streaming platforms. I doubt the digital side of the library has the same options. I don't see how it could. Maybe I'm wrong?
The main difference is other digital media is not funded by tax-payers; our municipal taxes pay for library services including digital content. I have yet to see any ads or other issues with digital media. Obviously this varies by municipality and how your library services are funded. The only challenge I've seen with the two digital platforms our library uses for movies and tv is that you are limited in the number of items you can use each month. For one platform you get 20 tickets (items), the other you get 8. Hard to complain when it's free.
 
Last edited:
I'm a very casual gamer these days and I think like you about physical. But I've noticed modern games rely on the updates and patches on games in order to play. do we risk the disc being redundant if the console insists on us downloading an update? or say when game is old, the disc won't work because the server won't let you play it?
I think this will happen. The updates are needed so I think one will end up with a bunch of games installed and updated on different disks and then, just play offline but if the game require an online check, all those physical game will worth nothing since the 1.0 installed in the disk is just unplayable.

You can check this website to see if you can play a game totally offline: https://www.doesitplay.org/
 
The main difference is other digital media is not funded by tax-payers; our municipal taxes pay for library services including digital content. I have yet to see any ads or other issues with digital media. Obviously this varies by municipality and how your library services are funded. The only challenge I've seen with the two digital platforms our library uses for movies and tv is that you are limited in the number of items you can use each month. For one platform you get 20 tickets (items), the other you get 8. Hard to complain when it's free.
That's great to know. I should definitely start using their digital options. We have a great library where I live, and I just lost a bunch of streaming options.
 
I was just looking at my library's website. They don't do a ton with online streaming (just Kanopy), but they do have roku and fire stick devices that you can check out that are pre-loaded with paid streaming services (Max, Apple TV, Disney+, Hulu, etc)
 
The main difference is other digital media is not funded by tax-payers; our municipal taxes pay for library services including digital content. I have yet to see any ads or other issues with digital media. Obviously this varies by municipality and how your library services are funded. The only challenge I've seen with the two digital platforms our library uses for movies and tv is that you are limited in the number of items you can use each month. For one platform you get 20 tickets (items), the other you get 8. Hard to complain when it's free.
Amazon prime now has ads. So you first subscribe and pay a monthly fee. Then when they want too they say, “Ok, you bought a subscription..we now decided to charge more if you don’t want ADs…”

This is an example of why having physical media is good too. Physical media does not change the next day when I wake up.
 
Amazon prime now has ads. So you first subscribe and pay a monthly fee. Then when they want too they say, “Ok, you bought a subscription..we now decided to charge more if you don’t want ADs…”

This is an example of why having physical media is good too. Physical media does not change the next day when I wake up.
I think you misunderstood the context. We were talking about digital media available through municipal libraries. There are no ads, nor do I pay for access. Yes Amazon Prime and other services now have ad-supported tiers. Corporate greed at work.
 
I think you misunderstood the context. We were talking about digital media available through municipal libraries. There are no ads, nor do I pay for access. Yes Amazon Prime and other services now have ad-supported tiers. Corporate greed at work.
Sorry, misread. :rolleyes:
 
Typically I don't like physical media, at least not in its original form. Disc have always been a pita for me, slow, noisy to read/write, limited storage capacity, degrades with age, highly prone to damage, etc.

That said I like having physical (digital) copies of my media. I just prefer it be on a NAS and on a offline hard drive. I will rip a bluray and transcode it for watching across all my devices before I would put it in a bluray player and watch it directly.

While vinyls are physical media the enjoyment from them doesn't come from the ownership but from the experience (for me anyway). It like driving a manual transmission car, the process of the task is where I find it enjoyable even if it seems antiquated.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.