Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
If so, how is it working for you so far? Mine should be here tomorrow.

*crosses fingers*

As an AT&T iPhone 4 customer in NYC, I'd like to know this too. At my apartment I get incredible voice and data but in my office in SoHo my data is horrible in the middle of the day (voice is still good). It definitely has to do with congestion b/c early in the morning my data is perfect.
 
will be home soonish.

im in lower manhattan and will post some screenshots/review soon.

Thanks would be very helpful in helping me make a decision on whether to switch to Verizon or not. I posted these two speedtests in another thread but they're appropriate here as well. My voice is perfect in the city but my data speeds in my office in the middle of the day are close to non-existant (as seen below). It's really frustrating and the main reason I'm contemplating making the switch.
 

Attachments

  • photo 2.PNG
    photo 2.PNG
    428.5 KB · Views: 92
  • photo 1.PNG
    photo 1.PNG
    451.5 KB · Views: 76
Thanks would be very helpful in helping me make a decision on whether to switch to Verizon or not. I posted these two speedtests in another thread but they're appropriate here as well. My voice is perfect in the city but my data speeds in my office in the middle of the day are close to non-existant (as seen below). It's really frustrating and the main reason I'm contemplating making the switch.

You would need an apples to apples 'time of day' comparison in the same location. The previous poster said they are located on the lower east side?
 
You would need an apples to apples 'time of day' comparison in the same location. The previous poster said they are located on the lower east side?

LES is very close to my SoHo office and those "speeds" are pretty consistent from around 10:30am to around 5pm.
 
LES is very close to my SoHo office and those "speeds" are pretty consistent from around 10:30am to around 5pm.

LES is where I live. I dont have screenshots (nor can I get some at this point, because my AT&T iPhone is gone, so either take what I say or leave it), but I can confirm those (average) speeds, they are sometimes the same at night as well because its a "going out" area for all the NYU freshman who's parents pay for their iPhones.

In general NYC is horrible for AT&T data.

I can post a speed test on my Verizon iPhone once I get back home tonight.
 
LES is very close to my SoHo office and those "speeds" are pretty consistent from around 10:30am to around 5pm.

Another factor is if and I say if Verizon network is good now but gets congested in the future. At one time 3G data was pretty good in NYC. I'm sure AT&T is aware of the issue and hopefully fixing it and then you would get the 3G you had once.

Remember the grass maybe greener for a short while.
 
Another factor is if and I say if Verizon network is good now but gets congested in the future. At one time 3G data was pretty good in NYC. I'm sure AT&T is aware of the issue and hopefully fixing it and then you would get the 3G you had once.

The one thing I will say about Verizon's network capacity, is that it's leaps and bounds above AT&T's. I would be extremely surprised to see Verizon's network get congested. They have the most underground cabling of any current wireless provider, and the most bandwidth available for it's wireless network. It's possible the network could get bogged down but I highly doubt it.
 
The one thing I will say about Verizon's network capacity, is that it's leaps and bounds above AT&T's. I would be extremely surprised to see Verizon's network get congested. They have the most underground cabling of any current wireless provider, and the most bandwidth available for it's wireless network. It's possible the network could get bogged down but I highly doubt it.

Correct me if I'm wrong but wasn't 3G data in NYC good up until late late last year?
 
hate to ask stupid beginner questions but how do i do a screenshot and post it ? I just downloaded speedtest app and want to post results?
 
hate to ask stupid beginner questions but how do i do a screenshot and post it ? I just downloaded speedtest app and want to post results?

Make sure your speedtest results are showing, then press the power button and the home button at the same time. That takes a snapshot of the screen and stores it in the folder all photos taken from the phone go. You should be able to figure out how to post it from there.
 
hate to ask stupid beginner questions but how do i do a screenshot and post it ? I just downloaded speedtest app and want to post results?

Press both the on/off button and the home button at the same time. It will save the screen shot to your iphoto.
 
LES is where I live. I dont have screenshots (nor can I get some at this point, because my AT&T iPhone is gone, so either take what I say or leave it), but I can confirm those (average) speeds, they are sometimes the same at night as well because its a "going out" area for all the NYU freshman who's parents pay for their iPhones.

In general NYC is horrible for AT&T data.

I can post a speed test on my Verizon iPhone once I get back home tonight.

Wasn't data great in NYC up until late last year?
 
I'm hoping to see if there is decent 3G coverage in NYC. I'm heading there for business in a couple weeks with my AT&T iPhone and need to be able to utilize it.

But the real test is comparing the same amount of Verizon users to the same amount of AT&T users. An early Verizon test won't really tell a good story.
 
I'm hoping to see if there is decent 3G coverage in NYC. I'm heading there for business in a couple weeks with my AT&T iPhone and need to be able to utilize it.

But the real test is comparing the same amount of Verizon users to the same amount of AT&T users. An early Verizon test won't really tell a good story.

Prepare for drop calls or not being to make a call at all :D
 
I'm hoping to see if there is decent 3G coverage in NYC. I'm heading there for business in a couple weeks with my AT&T iPhone and need to be able to utilize it.

But the real test is comparing the same amount of Verizon users to the same amount of AT&T users. An early Verizon test won't really tell a good story.

There are more Verizon customers in NYC than AT&T customers. Granted, the Verizon customers probably didn't consume as much data up to this point.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.