I went to the Apple store to check out the new glossy screens. After further review they suck worse than I thought. I tried to play a movie on a pro and stood back 5 feet and I could see my image in the screen. The Apple store looked like a walmart. When You walk around in a walmart and try to look for dvds the shine from the cover makes it hard to concentrate. But hey, what do I know. Other people in the store(old people and young punks) looked quite happy with them.
I can certainly understand hesitancy with glossy screens.
I ask: is your house lit like a Walmart? Are many of your working conditions? For your sake, I hope not. I think many would agree that massive overhead fluorescent lighting is one of the worst lighting conditions one can have. No doubt, reflections in similar lighting conditions are likely to be terrible. And that is a downside to a glossy screen.
The glossy-only option delayed my upgrading from my old 12" PB to a MacBook for many years. When the Santa Rosa MacBooks came out, the hardware upgrades were enough to put me over the edge and I've been thrilled with my MacBook.
I even really like the glossy screen. The crispness and color saturation is great.
But glossy/matte is definitely a personal choice. I used to be biased against glossy out of association with low-end laptops (seems that's where glossy screens first arose). Now I just see it as another choice.
Except that Apple doesn't offer a choice. Which is a bummer. I can only imagine that Apple's increase in lack of options is to decrease overhead and increase profit. But it's definitely a bummer and causing me to lean towards replacing my MacBook (whenever that happens) with a ThinkPad. Boring looks and design, good options, features, and price.
Of course, no OS X, but I'm hoping by then I can run OS X virtually, and that would be good enough for me. Of course, I'm the example to not allow OS X to be run virtually. Except, if Apple allows OS X virtually, they would at least get $130 from me instead of nothing. Something is better than nothing, right?
Except that I tend to get the impression from Apple that they don't feel that to be the case.
Sigh. Apple seems like it will always remain an enigma.