Which analysts would this be?
Gene Munster from Piper Jaffray and Keith Bachman from BMO Capital, both said that a lot of 5C sales were into the retail channel.
Morgan Stanley issued some WAG which was totally divergent from an analytics firm. The analytics firm had the ratio btwn 5s and 5c closer to 4:1.
Morgan Stanley also said that most 5C sales were into the retail channel? Looks like a trend.
As for the lone statistic that diverges, do you mean the one from the mobile ad marketing firm, Localytics?
Ad figures have rarely, if ever, accurately reflected sales... or even often come close. All they show is how many times one of their affiliates serve up one of their ads. Such reports are basically nothing but self-serving ads for their own ad network.
--
Btw, Bachman's comments on Apple accounting echo my explanation in a previous post, although he oddly uses "ship out" to mean "sell through", and "ship in" to mean "sell in".
(Bachman) notes that from an accounting point of view, Apple recognizes Apple direct retail/web sales on ship out, and for third-party retail outlets (e.g.,
Best Buy) on ship in. "More specifically, Apple recognizes web based sales upon customer receipt, so we think much of the 5s sales will be in the December quarter. We believe sell-in of 5c units on a global basis contributed to the nine million sales over the past three days."
-
StreetInsider
Note the important point that we keep talking about, that many end user sales won't be counted until delivered. That's usually a few million right there.