I have both the SuperDrive and one of those "cheap drives on Amazon" (with a mechanical tray). I still regularly use both to rip my audio CDs (I never stopped buying physical media) and to burn .mp3 CDs. The quality of that cheap drive is no different than the SuperDrive.I wish they had updated the SuperDrive in its later years. Yes, you can buy cheap drives on Amazon but you tend to get what you pay for.