Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
LOL!!! It just snowed. My goodness.. If Apple donated to every place that it just snowed.. HA!!!! Tax write off stunt..
 
And yet Americans think they live in the best country of the world. It’s miles behind Europe.
I think I do live in the best country in the world. When fellow Americans need a helping hand due to events like this, we pitch in in any way we can to help, just like Apple is doing. We are so nice, we even help other places in the world when they are in need, like Europe.
 
In the context of climate and the frequency of extreme weather events, 10 years is quite a short time.
So one CAT 5 hurricane hitting the US every 10 years is “regular”? I‘m failing to see your logic. This was defined as a once in a generational weather event. 2011 was no where near this level.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So one CAT 5 hurricane hitting the US every 10 years is “regular”? I‘m failing to see your logic. This was defined as a once in a generational weather event. 2011 was no where near this level.

Yes, it is regular? I mean, let's get real, if you go to live in an area where you know there are CAT 5 hurricanes every 10 years or so, you don't take that into account? Do you think the governments in those areas don't have to take that reality into account?

2011 saw the same issues with power outages due to power generators not being adequately protected against harsh winter climate events, which is the main issue which caused the outages this time around. Texas had identified preventive measures to mitigate the problem years ago but failed to implement them.

It's that simple (cit.).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The problem is, Texas actually has extreme harsh winter events fairly regularly - the last one before this year was in 2011. They had no real excuse "not to know".

Actually in 2011 they appointed a commission to identify measures to prevent the issue in the future, e.g. protecting generators from the cold etc... but under the motto "regulation bad!" they did not mandate these measures and instead only "recommended" them.

Guess how many companies freely decided to invest money into these measures without a regulation mandating them to do so? The disaster this year is a good answer to those who think the "free market" is always better left alone.

my wife was born and raised on a ranch in central Texas. She says the worst snow she has ever seen before this was maybe an inch. Kind of hard to prepare for something like this if it never happens.

I’m from Northern Europe where snow like this is the norm, we deal with it pretty OK, but if we endured the Texas summer heat people would quite literally be dying in their thousands as no one has AC. Does Texas need to fix things? Definitely, but the extreme weather is so unusual I can’t blame them for not being prepared.
 
my wife was born and raised on a ranch in central Texas. She says the worst snow she has ever seen before this was maybe an inch. Kind of hard to prepare for something like this if it never happens.

I’m from Northern Europe where snow like this is the norm, we deal with it pretty OK, but if we endured the Texas summer heat people would quite literally be dying in their thousands as no one has AC. Does Texas need to fix things? Definitely, but the extreme weather is so unusual I can’t blame them for not being prepared.
Except that Texas was warned in 2011 that they would have these issues. They knew and did nothing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ervingv
my wife was born and raised on a ranch in central Texas. She says the worst snow she has ever seen before this was maybe an inch. Kind of hard to prepare for something like this if it never happens.

Let's have a look again at what happened in 2011 in Texas:

In Texas the storm caused widespread disruption of road and air traffic, including flights into and out of Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport and Love Field. Rolling blackouts were instituted across the state as high demand for electricity left the power grid overloaded and unable to handle the demand. Governor Rick Perry asked for citizens to conserve as much electricity as they can to help ease the overloaded power grids. ERCOT, the governing body responsible for most of the electricity distribution in Texas, reported that more than 75% of the state was affected by rolling blackouts on February 2nd; at one point demand for energy was so great that utility companies began to purchase electricity off the national grids to meet the demand.
Post-analysis indicated that the cold temperatures had caused over 150 generators to encounter difficulties; loss of supply, instrumentation failures, and gas well-head freezing were some of the source causes.

Now let's have a look at the Federal report from Summer 2011 about the outages:

The storm, however, was not without precedent. There were prior severe cold weather events in the Southwest in 1983, 1989, 2003, 2006, 2008, and 2010.
The precipitating cause of the rolling blackouts experienced in Texas and Arizona during the February 2011 cold weather event was the large number of electric generator outages. The principal cause of the gas service curtailments experienced in several southwestern states was the production declines in the supply of natural gas, which led to volume and pressure reductions in the pipelines. The task force has analyzed in detail the causes of these outages and declines, and found that the majority of them were directly or indirectly related to the weather, particularly so with respect to production declines in the gas supply.
The large number of generating units that failed to start, tripped offline or had to be derated during the February event demonstrates that the generators did not adequately anticipate the full impact of the extended cold weather and high winds. While plant personnel and system operators, in the main, performed admirably during the event, more thorough preparation for cold weather could have prevented many of the weather-related outages.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ervingv
Yes, it is regular? I mean, let's get real, if you go to live in an area where you know there are CAT 5 hurricanes every 10 years or so, you don't take that into account? Do you think the governments in those areas don't have to take that reality into account?

2011 saw the same issues with power outages due to power generators not being adequately protected against harsh winter climate events, which is the main issue which caused the outages this time around. Texas had identified preventive measures to mitigate the problem years ago but failed to implement them.

It's that simple (cit.).
Do you live in Texas or are you just armchair quarterbacking it from whatever lake of purity you crawled out of? Do you know that it rarely gets below freezing temperatures in Texas? Do you have flood insurance on your property? It might flood. Why are you not prepared for everything in life you’ve beeb warned about?

If you still don’t get it, HARSH WINTERS and TEXAS don’t really go hand in hand. It’s that simple.
 
LOL!!! It just snowed. My goodness.. If Apple donated to every place that it just snowed.. HA!!!! Tax write off stunt..
How ignorant can a person be? It didn't "just snow." Go to a different site, read some actual news, and come back with a better line that's a) on a topic appropriate to joke about, and 2) actually funny. Thanks!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: MrDerby01
And yet Americans think they live in the best country of the world. It’s miles behind Europe.
Europe is a continent, not a country. Now that that's out of the way, I'd be careful with that comparison. There are some European countries that are in some pretty poor shape...just saying.
 
How ignorant can a person be? It didn't "just snow." Go to a different site, read some actual news, and come back with a better line that's a) on a topic appropriate to joke about, and 2) actually funny. Thanks!
Let's poke the funny man.

 
Yes, severe cold weather does happen in the south. Lived here all my life, during all of the events you list. I would argue that the severity and breadth of this recent storm is outside of most precedents, but it's not really worth researching low temps and durations to make that point.

I'm not sure what your end argument here is, but the root cause of the calamity in Texas is political and admittedly self-inflicted. Texas will deal with that (hopefully) in the very near future, but for now, any assistance is appreciated, however motivated.

Let's poke the funny man.

Ignoring is a thing. ;)
 
Do you have flood insurance on your property? It might flood. Why are you not prepared for everything in life you’ve beeb warned about?

Forgot to answer to that: I have definitely flood insurance.

The way insurance works is that it takes into account the probability of an event and prices the premium accordingly. The lower the probability of an event happening, the lower the price to be insured against it, so the event being very rare is actually not a drawback.

For protection against a rare event which might completely destroy what is likely one of your largest assets, it's a no-brainer to buy the insurance IMHO.
 
I hope you don't get hate for empathy!


TBH though I don't think many places with Texas' climate would have handled this significantly better. Regions adapt to what they know - it's how northern areas don't grind to a halt in the winter, but if they get freakishly hot summers they get rolling blackouts from the air conditioners or just don't have them, and areas that get forrest fires once in a couple decades don't have enough response.

I've been fortunate enough to have lived in a few different countries in the northern and southern hemisphere and almost universally when the weather goes this far out of spec it's a total poop show and you get people asking questions like why texas doesn't have enough snow plows with a straight face
I agree with this. I grew up in California but live in Illinois now. Summers as a kid were always in the 100s. Can't recall too many power outages. Whereas now in Illinois, we've had this monster cold snap the last few weeks and have gotten a TON of snow. Power hasn't gone out or even flickered. It's pretty much business as usual here! Despite all the snow and cold, schools have only been called off once.

California, when it comes to the type of weather I'm dealing with right now...probably wouldn't stand a chance. Illinois, if it was over 100 every single day like it was where I lived in California...even though Illinois is used to hot summers...would undoubtedly struggle. It doesn't get "California hot" here but throw in our humidity and a few 100+ degree days and we struggle a bit. Not total outage in my area, but we flicker and strain a bit.
 
Yes, severe cold weather does happen in the south. Lived here all my life, during all of the events you list. I would argue that the severity and breadth of this recent storm is outside of most precedents, but it's not really worth researching low temps and durations to make that point.

I'm not sure what your end argument here is, but the root cause of the calamity in Texas is political and admittedly self-inflicted. Texas will deal with that (hopefully) in the very near future, but for now, any assistance is appreciated, however motivated.


Ignoring is a thing. ;)
Umm OK LOL.. If you can't take it don't dish it.. Again.. It's just snow at the end of the day.
 
Every 10 years is frequently enough to have the safeguards in place to deal with it. If you knew you would get hit by a hurricane every 10 years, you would be damn sure you had a response plan.

In hindsight, I imagine a majority of Texans would pay a little more for a "winterization surcharge" on their utilities in exchange for more reliability. Unfortunately the system hasn't forced it on them or even given them a choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dannyyankou
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.