Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Aqara is the best I've found so far.

I used Logi cameras for years and they were just OK. I recently replaced them with Eufy (S9 Pros with a G3 homebase) and it has a been an expensive exercise in rage and frustration. When they weren't going offline themselves they were flooding my network and knocking everything else offline. Pure chaos. Will never buy another. And their iOS app is an awful dogs-dinner of inconsistent, half-implemented features and intrusive popups/surveys.

The cheap Aqara G100 ($40) is 10 times better than the old Logis (I have five now). The $200 Aqara G5 Pro is seriously impressive (I have just one, but may add another). All six cameras are almost instant response when viewing in Apple Home. Never had that before.

Forget Eufy HomeKit cameras and just look out the window instead.
Matches with my experiences. The Logi cameras are also prone to failure after a year.. they just stop connecting to the network and red-light-flash-of-death.

The G5 Pro is so good, especially at night. Plus, you can simultaneously use them with HomeKit + RTSP protocol so you can have a 24/7 backup recording system via something like BlueIris.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arran
AI is turning out to be the most silly invention ever. Very expensive, loads of energy use, loads of water use, increased hardware costs all for a text summary of a video and the other various minimally helpful gaslighting responses all whilst raiding the entire creative works of man and paying nothing.

Seriously disappointed in humanity at this point. AI bubble better pop soon, I hate it.
AI will be very good once we get to agentic AI. Apple's version of AI is like putting lipstick on a pig and charging for it.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: J.J. Sefton

Using Apple Intelligence camera features in the Home app will require an iCloud+ plan starting at 2TB, according to Apple.

This is actually reasonable. What is the point of a security camera if you don't store all the video data it captures? Yes, you could store it locally at home, but that requires the user to buy and set up a computer with very large storage and let it run 24x7. The computer has to be powerfull enough to run ther AI locally. Not only that, but you need to set up remote access to that computer on a VPN so you can check the video footage while not at home. Very few people could do that. For then, "cloud" is the only option that could technically work.



Me. I do have an older gaming computer with 16GB RAM and Intel i7 and some older Nvidia GPU card. I've installed Linux and on top of that, "Frigate” and have about the rough equivalent of what Apple is offering for a few bucks a month. Then I have the added cost of paying for electristy for thre PC "forever". I might switch over to Apple's system.



Frigate is free and open source, so it costs nothing but your time to set it up and a reasonably powerful computer to run the AI locally. Most people would never be able to set this up: https://frigate.video/. Apple's subscription price is lower than going this yourself. Especially when you add in the monthly cost of running a PC 24x7 and the hassle of keeping it working, replacing parts and such for the rest of your life.
 
Step #1: Add New AI Features
Step #2: Require everyone to subscribe to iCloud+ 2TB plan to get new features
(Later) Step #3: Raise price of iCloud+ 2TB plan because of all the great new features

I'm concerned that Step #3 is coming. I am fine paying $9.99/mo. for 2TB of storage with the privacy benefits of Advanced Data Protection for iCloud. But I do NOT want to pay more for the same plan to get additional AI features I don't care about or plan to use. Non-AI users should not be forced to subsidize the costs created by AI users.
 
Nothing has changed other than adding a tiny perk of a benefit for 2TB plans. On lower plan the only difference is the lack of summarized notifications and language search. I'm on the beta, and it's not worth upgrading to that plan just for the perk. If you have a working apple home, you're not forced to upgrade anything to continue using what you've got.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rezwits
Step #1: Add New AI Features
Step #2: Require everyone to subscribe to iCloud+ 2TB plan to get new features
(Later) Step #3: Raise price of iCloud+ 2TB plan because of all the great new features

I'm concerned that Step #3 is coming. I am fine paying $9.99/mo. for 2TB of storage with the privacy benefits of Advanced Data Protection for iCloud. But I do NOT want to pay more for the same plan to get additional AI features I don't care about or plan to use. Non-AI users should not be forced to subsidize the costs created by AI users.

Step #3 is absolutely coming.
We've only seen round one of the price hikes, but rest assured they are not done doing them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gummybear2026
Step #1: Add New AI Features
Step #2: Require everyone to subscribe to iCloud+ 2TB plan to get new features
(Later) Step #3: Raise price of iCloud+ 2TB plan because of all the great new features

I'm concerned that Step #3 is coming. I am fine paying $9.99/mo. for 2TB of storage with the privacy benefits of Advanced Data Protection for iCloud. But I do NOT want to pay more for the same plan to get additional AI features I don't care about or plan to use. Non-AI users should not be forced to subsidize the costs created by AI users.

It cost $20 in 2016 and has been $10 since 2017. Since then, US inflation has been around 30–35%, so no one should be surprised if Apple raises the price.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BeatCrazy
AI is turning out to be the most silly invention ever. Very expensive, loads of energy use, loads of water use, increased hardware costs all for a text summary of a video and the other various minimally helpful gaslighting responses all whilst raiding the entire creative works of man and paying nothing.

Seriously disappointed in humanity at this point. AI bubble better pop soon, I hate it.
Some of us been through other bubbles and guess what only thing that changed was amount of money being tossed around, the tech didn't go away, just like AI isn't going away.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BeatCrazy
Aqara is the best I've found so far.

I used Logi cameras for years and they were just OK. I recently replaced them with Eufy (S9 Pros with a G3 homebase) and it has a been an expensive exercise in rage and frustration. When they weren't going offline themselves they were flooding my network and knocking everything else offline. Pure chaos. Will never buy another. And their iOS app is an awful dogs-dinner of inconsistent, half-implemented features and intrusive popups/surveys.

The cheap Aqara G100 ($40) is 10 times better than the old Logis (I have five now). The $200 Aqara G5 Pro is seriously impressive (I have just one, but may add another). All six cameras are almost instant response when viewing in Apple Home. Never had that before.

Forget Eufy HomeKit cameras and just look out the window instead.
I am still amazed at the night vison of the G5, so far Aqara is shaping up to be the best cameras I have used.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BeatCrazy and Arran
Some of us been through other bubbles and guess what only thing that changed was amount of money being tossed around, the tech didn't go away, just like AI isn't going away.
Yeah, I feel like we're approaching a much-needed resetting of expectations for AI.

Like the late 90's/early 2000's dot-com boom and bust. The impatient, stupid money left the party but a robust and deliberate buildout got underway.
 
I noticed the cost of a 10TB Western Digital Purple Pro has gone up to over $500!! If you would have asked me in 2019, I would have told you this drive should cost $50 by now.
I spent $400 for a 4GB drive in 1995, the price on drives has gone down quite a bit, and they went up with some Tsunamis and then back down. (I am not advocating that we need to be raped by Western Digital) But I mean people don't respect this but 10TB is quite a bit. It's just a bummer that you work on three 4K videos that are 2-3 minutes long and that's 500GB to 1TB gone like poof, and then you kinda have to back it up for almost a year...
I get to the point where I am like, look if you want an SSD Blade of your project for me to work on and then you get the final archival blade pay $500 and I'll give it to you when I'm done, but that's where the "CHEAP" comes into play, nobody want to pay me $500 on top of fees to get an ssd that they are just gonna store and do nothing with, and then probably not even use if they erase it...
Verdict? Bad business to be in unless you ARE getting PAID...
 
Step #3 is absolutely coming.
We've only seen round one of the price hikes, but rest assured they are not done doing them.
That's crap, Netflix and Disney + some Hulu, plus HBO etc, and even Dropbox (not so much) but MS Office, those fools have raised their prices like 10 times each in the last 5-8 years, Apple has raised their prices what? I am not saying had high prices, I am saying RAISED their prices? Hardware? This is the first time I have ever or can remember Apple doing that, 2nd) AppleOne? what twice? maybe once! That is NOT their MO... They don't really RAISE prices, they may INTRODUCE, but they aren't really "JACKERS!"
Not like the other mentions...
 
Yes using iCloud+ is much cheaper and simpler than running a corporate Ubiquiti UniFi system, which is what you would need to achieve the same level of security.
While this is true, iCloud also gives you fewer features.

I have a couple of cameras on the iCloud plan, and the motion detection is sometimes not sensitive enough, and the beginning and/or the ending of the clip are truncated. I'm not impressed by iCloud cameras, and adding AI detections to that is a complete "don't care" for me.

What I really want is 24x7 recording (mainly because subtle nighttime movements do not have sufficient contrast to trigger the movement detection algorithms), and that's why most of my cameras are on a pricey $$$$ Unifi NVR setup. Getting people, vehicle, and animal detection is just a big plus.
 
I’m very happy it will support 4K.
On-topic, I’ve been choosing to limit cameras to 5 to stay on the 200GB but would make use of more.
 
While this is true, iCloud also gives you fewer features.

I have a couple of cameras on the iCloud plan, and the motion detection is sometimes not sensitive enough, and the beginning and/or the ending of the clip are truncated. I'm not impressed by iCloud cameras, and adding AI detections to that is a complete "don't care" for me.

What I really want is 24x7 recording (mainly because subtle nighttime movements do not have sufficient contrast to trigger the movement detection algorithms), and that's why most of my cameras are on a pricey $$$$ Unifi NVR setup. Getting people, vehicle, and animal detection is just a big plus.
This is why you need the Aqara G5 Pro cameras. They are not expensive, have amazing color night vision, and can run on HomeKit while simultaneously using RTSP to feed a NVR or BlueIris-on-Windows setup for 24/7 recording.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rezwits and Pow!
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.