Hmm... in any scenario I'd rather have the reliability of EFI, but I'm with you. I remember option for "easy to fix" over "efficient." In a doomsday scenario, though, 30 mpg is better than 12 mpg.
Mechanical watches strike me as an odd thing to actually *want.* I can marvel at the craftsmanship without wanting the fragility and cost and (unless you pay serious cash) inaccuracy. Again, if a $12 watch from CVS can do the same thing but with a battery every few years, why on Earth would I want mechanical? I don't get it.
“Thats the first time that I've heard of LPs exceeding CD frequency response. On a side note... I would say its more appropriate to say people don't hear 20Hz, they feel it.”
Thats the first time that I've heard of LPs exceeding CD frequency response. On a side note... I would say its more appropriate to say people don't hear 20Hz, they feel it.
I used to be able to hear 16-24. Yes, LPs could beat CDs. CDs are deliberately restricted in bandwidth to keep the media smaller.
“for the kids it's all about tangibility, and the connection with the past.”
Okay, I can see that. Sorta.
“And again, there's a certain satisfaction to pushing a cassette into a deck and feeling a satisfying mechanical capture to the mechanism. Or in my case, watching the mechanics of a Nakamichi UDAR deck stick its "hand" out and capture a cassette, and then physical flip it at the end of the first side.”
I can see that too. I never had one of those, but my Onkyo had a tactile feel missing from an iPod. On the other hand, there's a definite sacrifice of sound quality and convenience. In the cassette days, the throwback people used open reels, often with low quality magnetic tape that wasn't quite as good as a very good cassette player.
“I get what you're saying. The people who "want to be different just like everyone else". Thats a decades-long trope and its pretty obvious in the hipster neckbeards that pride themselves in walking into the dark corners of culture before those become popular and then move on to the next small thing before it becomes big. I don't think thats whats happening here.”
When people buy VCRs, I'm pretty sure that's what's going on. It's not so much a trope as a fact of life. A trope, as I understand it, is a sorta stereotype that isn't in any way real. I might have that definition wrong.
“Right now, along with LPs the other big "new" thing is tube audio.”
Tubes have been a new thing since solid state took over! I myself grew serious respect for the tube sound when I had some antique equipment in an old job, and hooked up two monophonic tube amps to a Walkman to create a rather good sounding, very powerful for the time stereo. Tubes definitely have a different sound, warmer - like records. I can sortakinda see using tubes now and then. They do suck down power and generate heat like mad.
“It's no different than people who collected cylinder records or megaphone Victrolas when I got started in audio in the 1980s. CDs were far better but original acetate records allowed listeners to actually hear the room during the recording, whereas CDs are merely digital time slice representations of the music. The Transporter Dilemma, if you're familiar with that discussion.”
Hmmm. Not quite sure what you mean by actually hearing the room. I'll have to look it up. I know CDs are samples but so are movies. I'm not convinced we can hear the difference. All due respect to Neil Young, too, but nobody's managed to pass a blind test of high-res AAC vs CD lossless audio, as far as I know. Yet he's sure there's missing music. I think if one can't pass a blind test, the difference is like the old times with people insisting bigger turntable RCA cables were definitely something you could hear. Or weights on the record.
“Some notable names like Nelson Pass and Jim Fosgate are at the forefront, and those guys are not neckbeard Millennials sipping matcha latte in a rundown cafe - they're two of the most respected names at the top of the audio world.”
Oh, I don't doubt that tubes have a great sound. What I'd like to see is a blind test of "tube treated" digital audio against actual tube audio.