Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
It's still useless here (Switzerland) for public transport and cycling routes.

I check each time a news thread like this is started, only to discover that there's been no improvement. I used to report missing local transport, but like Apple's beta feedbacks, I suspect they ignore almost everything. So, google maps it is.

Plus, I like to support some local businesses and a decent google review is always appreciated.
 
I wish I could turn off the thing where when I go anywhere it auto sets up a route home. Like, I’ll be at the gas station a block down the street and when I plug into CarPlay again it shows me the route home, every time.
 
Interesting to see how many people find Apple Maps navigation leading them in wrong directions, down closed roads, etc. Surprisingly, Apple is far superior in finding the correct location of addresses in rural areas for me (Michigan) whereas Google may be miles off. Apple does have weird quirks with lane suggestions though, often considering a standard highway exit ramp an additional lane.

When it comes to discovering new places, I only use Google. Apple needs to implement a better review system (thumbs up/down doesn't cut it), and drop Yelp...

Might be the same problem with a lot of Apple product, they seem to be surprised there is a world outside of the US and non US support comes very slowly if at all. Google seems more international in their approach.
 
I see the same things where I am in the west. Rural is a lot more accurate for AM. However, they really do need to drop Yelp.

Also, I find new places pop up on AM first typically. I’ve only had 1 place in the past year show up on Google maps before AM. I’m in a fast growing area so new businesses and addresses are a thing.
It surprises me that AM is populating new locations faster than Google; it's not something I notice in my daily use. That's great to know.
 
One of the problems with maps for me is when you start the route. The app is very slow and cannot find its orientation until you start driving, and then you realise you are driving in the wrong direction and I have to turn around. I don't understand why Aplple does not use the compass to help Maps find its start up orientation.

Have you checked if AM background refresh is enabled in Settings > Maps?
 
Apple Maps: prettier

Google Maps: better mapping (more accurate data).

Apple's focus seems to continue to be rolling out "prettier" demos whenever they talk maps.

Google more reliably gets me to the right place.

I keep re-trying Apple Maps from time to time, only to be frustrated by presumably (still) "old" data (and I've actually seen the Apple mapping vehicles in my area more than once).

I also keep wondering why Apple doesn't write some code to basically map with a number of competitor mapping apps, recognize all of the common roads/locations/etc shown by them, then compare all that "same" to Apple's own data. Where Apple's differs:
  • switch it to the common ground locations/road/etc. OR,
  • execute some form of in-person verification if Apple thinks they have it right and most everyone else is wrong. OR,
  • alert a user trying to go there that this route/location conflicts with what other sources say... then allow the steadfast fan to confirm it is correct or wrong and adjust data accordingly.
Instead, if I get the "wild good chase", you probably will too, and the next guy, and the next... until one/some of us try a different mapping app to actually get to where we want to go. Where's the corrections Apple? Why do many have to endure the same mistake before maybe some other method of corrections gets around to recognizing it and fixing it?

Admittedly, a few corrections eventually show up. One notorious one for me was the recommended path to a Walmart required driving the car into a canal with Florida gators (not the college coed type). However, if I might opt to try a "Duke Boys" leap over the canal, the Walmart was not where Apple maps said it was anyway- just an empty lot. Google Maps data knew this and knew that cars and gator-filled canals are not a good option (and the correct location of the fairly popular retailer). But that one finally got fixed in the last couple of years.

IMO: the core to maps is accurate data. All the "pretty" in the world is lipstick on a pig if the data is not good. Google Maps can have data errors too but they subjectively seem fewer- even in 2023- than Apple Maps. Or more simply:
  • When I want to get to a new place in one try, I'll use Google as "best shot."
  • If I don't mind perhaps having to drive around when what I seek is not where AM thinks it is, I might "gamble" (more) on Apple Maps. If "it" is not there or the recommended road is not there, I then switch to GM and it will get me to the right place.
No "hate" at all- just using what seems to be the best tool for the job. For me, the best gauge is dominated by accurate, up-to-date data. Bacon tastes just as good with no lipstick... especially when you can find the bacon in one try instead of two.
 
Last edited:
Might be the same problem with a lot of Apple product, they seem to be surprised there is a world outside of the US and non US support comes very slowly if at all. Google seems more international in their approach.
Feature release is certainly a US benefit. It's difficult to judge where people are experiencing the most navigation problems since not many mention the approx. location.

Traveling outside the US, I don't use driving navigation so I can't comment on that. I am curious though as to what people use for looking at reviews. Finding great places to eat/visit seems to require a mix of TripAdvisor/Google Maps but neither have the level of photos/reviews that I find for locations in the US.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pinkyyy 💜🍎
Feature release is certainly a US benefit. It's difficult to judge where people are experiencing the most navigation problems since not many mention the approx. location.

Traveling outside the US, I don't use driving navigation so I can't comment on that. I am curious though as to what people use for looking at reviews. Finding great places to eat/visit seems to require a mix of TripAdvisor/Google Maps but neither have the level of photos/reviews that I find for locations in the US.

Honestly I could live with the navigation problems but the biggest problem is searching for a store/restaurant/place and being told it doesn’t exist or Apple Maps pointing to something in a different country with a not so similar name. It must be close to 1/3 of the times I use Apple Maps that it just doesn’t have the place I am going to so I have to find the address on Google to input that.

That combined with all the CarPlay bugs and weird design choices with Apple Maps makes it hard to use for me as my go to navigation. Wish it was as easy as just jumping in the car and typing in where I want to go but it’s a hassle so much of the time.
 
Plus, with Waze, I've noticed potholes getting fixed when I report them; not always, but quite often.
Far more likely, I'd suggest, is that the agency in charge was already aware of the pothole when you reported it to Waze and they don't even check Waze. Potholes are usually easy to patch, of course, but it still does take time to get resources in place and do the job, provided weather's cooperative, etc.
 
Honestly I could live with the navigation problems but the biggest problem is searching for a store/restaurant/place and being told it doesn’t exist or Apple Maps pointing to something in a different country with a not so similar name. It must be close to 1/3 of the times I use Apple Maps that it just doesn’t have the place I am going to so I have to find the address on Google to input that.

That combined with all the CarPlay bugs and weird design choices with Apple Maps makes it hard to use for me as my go to navigation. Wish it was as easy as just jumping in the car and typing in where I want to go but it’s a hassle so much of the time.
Searching is absolutely awful in Apple Maps. Much worse outside the US, but even here, entering a normal business name will either show me some obscure place across the country or results from my current location when I'm trying to plan for a trip and have the map centered over a specific location. Fixing search and reviews would essentially replace Google Maps for me.
 


iPhone users are increasingly finding reasons to choose Apple Maps over Google Maps, with some customers commending its clear public transport directions and visually appealing design.

apple-maps-3d-feature.jpg

That's according to anecdotal reports collected by The Wall Street Journal (paywalled). While Apple Maps comes preinstalled on all iPhones, the overwhelming majority of iPhones in the U.S. have Google Maps downloaded as an alternative, according to Canalys.

But that hasn't stopped some users becoming particularly impressed by how far Apple's transit route information has come. The app is often recommended by users for its cleaner view versus the more cluttered design of Google Maps.

For example, Jane Natoli, a Google Maps "power user" told WSJ she finds herself using Apple Maps more in her everyday life after her iPhone prompted her to use it in the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport. The app knew she was at the airport and offered recommendations for shops and restaurants in her terminal. It had clearer information that was easier to interact with than Google Maps, said the 42-year-old.
A recent graduate from Georgia Tech shared a similar sentiment. At night while driving, she said she finds that the roads are easier to look at on Apple Maps, and there are fewer points of interest cluttering her view. "Apple's really good at making things look pretty," she told the outlet.

Apple Maps launched in 2012 and was quickly criticized for having incomplete and inaccurate mapping data, which led some iPhone users on dangerous routes. Apple CEO Tim Cook offered a rare public apology for the frustration it caused customers, and then iOS chief Scott Forstall was ousted just one month later.

Since then, Apple has made significant improvements to Apple Maps, building in new features and correcting lingering errors. Real-time traffic information and navigation options for pedestrians were added to Maps in 2013, which is also the same year Maps was extended to OS X. In 2015, Maps was updated with "Nearby," a feature that offers up local points of interest and transit directions in a handful of cities.

In early 2020, Apple completed a complete overhaul of its maps in the United States, featuring significantly greater detail including updated building massing, parks, sports field, pools, and more. A new Look Around feature in select cities is similar to Google's Street View, and the updated maps have been rolling out to more countries in the time since. In iOS 17, coming in the fall, users will be able to download maps for offline use in Apple Maps – something Google Maps users have been able to do now for quite some time.

Praise for Apple's offering isn't by any means universal. One user told WSJ she was frequently led astray by Apple Maps as she walks around Boston, while another user said his experience with Apple Maps via CarPlay had often added time on to his commute by taking him through neighborhoods with stop signs in an effort to avoid gridlock.

Apple Maps still gets a bad rap among some users, but Apple's continued efforts to improve the app appear to have helped reverse some of those opinions. "Maps has come a long way, and people have noticed," Craig Federighi, Apple's head of software, said during WWDC in June. Are you more or less likely to use Apple Maps these days? Let us know in the comments.

Article Link: Apple Maps Gradually Winning Over Google Maps Users, Report Suggests
I love apple Maps. It's got an app on my Mac, iPad, phone, and watch. I prefer an app over a website any day. I use it exclusively and have ditched all other map phone apps (Waze, Google Maps, etc). The only exception is my Garmin device which works when my phone overheats, and works in the mountains where no phone can pickup a signal.
 
Apple Maps is nice looking and I prefer the CarPlay interface over Google Maps.

That said, Google Maps has a feature for EVs that shows the most energy efficient route (sometimes upwards of 20-40% more efficient) and the time difference. That's huge, imho, for maximizing efficiency on all kinds of trips. Apple needs to implement something similar. I'm more than happy to add 5 minutes of travel time in order to save 33% on energy usage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pinkyyy 💜🍎
Apple Maps biggest downfall is its business hours listings. It's fine for big box retail and chains, but for mom and pop shops and small retail, the hours are incorrect a vast majority of the time. It's almost a joke.

The Apple Maps interface is much better than Google's because it's cleaner and more focused. I've seen iterations of Google Maps that are beautiful, such as the version in the dashboard of Polestar cars, but for some reason that hasn't made it to the mobile or web version of their maps product.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pinkyyy 💜🍎
Not winning me over. For the very first time, had to use AM. I was in a town I wasn't familiar with. Worked okay I guess but did give me one minor error in directions. Next morning fired up AM again and it would would NOT speak the directions. I had done nothing to change that from the day before when it gave me clear spoken directions. Spent a couple of hours trying to get it to speak again but no joy.

Google maps on the other hand worked flawlessly for the remaining 3 days.
 
Apple Maps has been better than Google Maps for years. I know it can be area specific but I travel all over the place and so far every time Apple Maps > Google Maps. It finds more and navigates better.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: freedomlinux
One of the problems with maps for me is when you start the route. The app is very slow and cannot find its orientation until you start driving, and then you realise you are driving in the wrong direction and I have to turn around. I don't understand why Aplple does not use the compass to help Maps find its start up orientation.
It does use the compass. The Core Location API includes something called “course” which is what Apple Maps and other navigation apps tend to use for turn-by-turn navigation because it attempts to correct for cases where the heading of the phone doesn’t match the direction of movement.

It should roughly match the compass when you start navigation, though — unless you’re starting it while driving (please don’t) — because absent any movement data that’s the only data it has to work with. If it doesn’t, it’s either a software bug or hardware problem. I’ve had a finicky compass on a past iPhone where the heading was reported about 10–15° left of the actual heading.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pinkyyy 💜🍎
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.