I guess they're desperate in their attempt to catch up to Spotify in terms of market share.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Music Launching Spatial Audio With Dolby Atmos and Lossless Audio in June at No Extra Cost
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Yet another common misconception about “streaming services“; yes, you can “stream”, but you can always download ahead of time and play back locally just like you do with the old music model.
When I hear that argument, I often wonder if people are being deliberately obtuse or just not understanding the concept of a music service.
It's about curiosity and wonderment.
Some people, often for their whole lives, have minds like a sponge, continuously soaking in new information/knowledge/music/etc that were previously unknown or unexposed to them. Others, sadly, have more sclerotic minds and curiosity levels, having lost their child-like wonderment entering adulthood.
I am (pleasantly) surprised as I thought Apple would charge extra for this.
And some people will insist on Kraft Mac ‘n Cheese while travelling in Italy… 🤯
I would think so. Since carplay is just an interface streamed from your phone.
AM is an incredible value now, despite the severely flawed MacOS app. If support for lossless audio extends to your own purchases – i.e. uploads and matches – that will be the cherry on top and something that is unmatched (no pun intended) by any other music subscription service. Exciting stuff.
No you don’t. As an Apple Music subscriber you can upload/match your music to your heart content.
I understand since your listening style is VERY unique. However, the majority of the world isn’t stuck in a frozen era of music in which they refuse to try anything new. So for you buying all your favourites from 1970 and being done makes sense. However, the rest of the world exists in a forward moving momentum and people enjoy trying new music and artists daily thus subscription services are much cheaper than outright purchasing tracks.
Last edited by a moderator:
Until Apple starts to support higher quality bluetooth codecs this will be pointless for most people. Cannot see them adding LDAC (which is snake oil anyway IMO) or APTX-HD.
The no extra cost thing makes sense, I had a feeling they might do it. Only additional cost would be bandwidth/storage and it is good to see the audio quality question for digital music being taken off of the table finally in 2021. Looks like Spotify have been caught sitting on their hands.
The no extra cost thing makes sense, I had a feeling they might do it. Only additional cost would be bandwidth/storage and it is good to see the audio quality question for digital music being taken off of the table finally in 2021. Looks like Spotify have been caught sitting on their hands.
Some of us have been in the iTunes ecosystem since the beginning, and we amassed impressive collections of songs/albums purchased though the iTunes store back when we were syncing this music to iPods. We don't need to pay $9.99/month to listen to this music; we already paid for it. Also, some people do a substantial amount of listening where wifi may not be readily available (e.g., while traveling or enjoying nature).
I'm always surprised by people's inability to see beyond their own use case. An Apple Music subscription works for you; enjoy. But you shouldn't question the logic of people who don't want to pay additional money to access songs they'll never listen to just because they want to hear higher-quality versions of the songs they've already paid for.
So on what hardware am I supposed to play this lossless audio on apple?
You’ve discontinued HomePod and don’t sell any airplay 2 receiver for conventional speakers..
You’ve discontinued HomePod and don’t sell any airplay 2 receiver for conventional speakers..
While FLAC / lossless isn't mentioned for HomePod in the latest announcement, the HomePod (OG) is FLAC compatible. Worst case, you can Airplay 2 the CD/Redbook quality lossless to the HomePod. Honestly it would still just be astonishing if it didn't direct stream to it though.
Not seeing a lack of civility here in responses to the outlier "all new music sucks" opinion; just some humorous responses.
if our purchaes match apple music, itll be available nonetheless
I think your point certainly sounds more logical than using a streaming service. However, when I was only using my own music that I purchased, I noticed something.
I ended up listening to the same few songs over and over and over and had an eclectic mix of genres and individual songs that didn’t always fit well together into playlists. I have a wide interest in music that changes throughout the day and year. Even after years of acquiring music, I would grow tired of hearing some songs and have to buy a raft of new ones to change it up. (And I don’t listen to contemporary pop stuff either)
With a streaming service, I immediately noticed I was listening to WAY more music, more variety, broader playlists etc. not to mention other family members having more choice.
If I’m buying each song I’d like to listen to and those of my wife, it is almost as expensive and a far worse overall experience. Really the streaming service isn’t as bad as you make it out to be. But to each their own.
And let’s remember, like our apps and software, I don’t think we “own” the music anyway. You’re leasing it. I could be wrong on this but that’s how it’s been described to me. It’s just a longer lease. But if Apple were ever to tank or cancel iTunes, you wouldn’t have access to “your” music anymore.
Not sure what to make of that, but disappointing if true. Doesn't make sense to me that you would be punished with lower audio quality for listening to your own purchases.
My understanding is, CarPlay already supports lossless audio using ALAC up to 16-bit/48 khz. So regular lossless tracks will play fine, but the high resolution lossless will likely not be supported.
You can always try 3rd party apps to convert regular MP3s into Dolby, 5.1, 7.1 Surround. I've had some luck with that in the past with audio, video...some fails.
The official Dolby Atmos conversion tool IS free to download here.
developer.dolby.com
I've never tried this program, I'll give it a shot though.
*Just need to sign up for a FREE Dolby acct.
The official Dolby Atmos conversion tool IS free to download here.
Dolby Atmos Conversion Tool | Dolby Developer
I've never tried this program, I'll give it a shot though.
*Just need to sign up for a FREE Dolby acct.