Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!
  • Did you order new AirTags? We've opened a dedicated AirTags forum.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
52,391
14,088



A U.S. Federal judge today ordered Apple to help federal investigators access data on the iPhone 5c used by San Bernardino shooter Syed Farook, reports NBC News. According to court papers, Apple "declined to provide [assistance] voluntarily."

iphone5c.jpg

The judge ruled Tuesday that the Cupertino-based company had to provide "reasonable technical assistance" to the government in recovering data from the iPhone 5c, including bypassing the auto-erase function and allowing investigators to submit an unlimited number of passwords in their attempts to unlock the phone. Apple has five days to respond to the court if it believes that compliance would be "unreasonably burdensome."
Prosecutors argued that despite providing a warrant authorizing the search of Farook's device, the "government was unable to complete the search because it cannot access the iPhone's encrypted content." The FBI argued that Apple has the "technical means" to assist the government and, in a statement, U.S. attorney Eileen M. Decker said that the order was a "potentially important step" in finding out "everything we possibly can" about the San Bernardino attack.

Authorities said they were able to access several backups of Farook's iCloud data, which were saved a month before the attack took place. Prosecutors argued that the evidence in his iCloud account indicated he was in communication with both his victims and his wife, who assisted him in the attack. They allege he may have disabled iCloud data saves after that point to hide further potential evidence.

Last October, the Cupertino company reiterated that it "would be impossible" for the company to access data on a device using iOS 8 or later, but federal authorities are asking Apple to disable a feature that erases the iPhone's data after a certain number of failed password attempts. It's not clear if Apple is able to do so.

Apple stopped storing encryption keys after the release of iOS 8, making it impossible for the company to bypass passcodes to gain access to a device. Additionally, Apple CEO Tim Cook has consistently insisted that providing back-door access past its encryption for authorities would open the door for "bad guys" to gain access to its users' data.

Note: Due to the political nature of the discussion regarding this topic, the discussion thread is located in our Politics, Religion, Social Issues forum. All forum members and site visitors are welcome to read and follow the thread, but posting is limited to forum members with at least 100 posts.

Article Link: Apple Ordered to Help FBI Recover Data From San Bernardino Shooter's iPhone 5c
 

DipDog3

macrumors 65816
Sep 20, 2002
1,188
687
The iPhone is encrypted with a combination of the passcode and hardware key. Without the auto-wipe, the FBI will be able to try all of the combinations until they find the right one.

But running all of the combinations on the phone itself, can take over 5 years for a six-digit lower-case password mixing numbers and letters.

So the FBI will need brute force it on a supercomputer, but that would require the hardware key, which is built into the phone. Apple does not know the hardware key. The FBI would have to extract the key by melting the plastic off the chip and hitting it with bursts of lasers to hopefully recover bits of the key.

With a supercomputer, the FBI could crack a simple six-digit numeric code in about 22 hours, but a complex alpha-numeric password could take over 10 years.
 
Last edited:
Comment

garirry

macrumors 68000
Apr 27, 2013
1,543
3,860
Canada is my city
Even though there are things I don't like about post-Jobs Apple, their concern for privacy is one thing I have to give them credit for. I bet that they won't disable the auto-erase features and they certainly won't allow people without a password to access backuped data (assuming they save any of their data) just because of some stupid paranoid government.
 
Comment

furi0usbee

macrumors 68000
Jul 11, 2008
1,781
1,264
So if Apple is able to turn off the auto-erase after 10 tries, and let someone try unlimited passwords. Well, if they used a 4 digit PIN, that means essentially there IS a backdoor to get in, as it won't take very long to try out all the combinations. This case could shed light on what exactly Apple *can* do with our phones, even if we lock them down to their fullest.
 
Comment

MrAverigeUser

macrumors 6502a
May 20, 2015
740
336
europe
perhaps I will upgrade from IOS 7 to IOS 8 now ….

Between the lines the US-authorities say: "Be part of the criminals that give us access to ALL Phones and computers on earth!"
Microsoft does, Google does, Amazon does, Western digital does, all US- manufacturers of NAS and Internet-routers do, and apple did at least until 2012… it´s worse than in Orwells novels...
 
Comment

AFDoc

macrumors 68030
Jun 29, 2012
2,801
540
Colorado Springs USA for now
well...that tells us that at least one person bought an iphone 5c
LoL this was classsic!!

I for one don't care what's on the phone.... if they can't figure things out without the info then they aren't very good at their jobs. Stay strong apple... F the police, FBI, or any other "authority" that tries to force a company to betray one of it's customers.... even if that customer was a douche.
 
Comment

You are the One

macrumors 6502a
Dec 25, 2014
594
751
In the present
I pray for America. You are run by a psychopathic and satanistic criminal cabal. Please wake up.

Let’s suppose America’s elections are rigged, that Bush was never fairly elected, that congress is bought and paid for with drug money and that America’s courts, media and police are totally corrupt, run by drug cartels or paid off by foreign intelligence services.

Then, were this last statement a safe assumption, and I believe this to be the case, wouldn’t every political, intellectual and social function that failed to take these “facts” into account be nothing more than folly and delusion

Problem-Reaction-Solution. That's how things work. Create a trauma, blame the unability to solve it on encryption, get rid of encryption. Move on. Same in Paris.
 
Last edited:
Comment

Jeremy1026

macrumors 68020
Nov 3, 2007
2,210
1,013
The iPhone is encrypted with a combination of the passcode and hardware key. Without the auto-wipe, the FBI will be able to try all of the combinations until they find the right one.

But running all of the combinations on the phone itself, can take over 5 years for a six-digit lower-case password mixing numbers and letters.

So the FBI will need brute force it on a supercomputer, but that would require the hardware key, which is built into the phone. Apple does not know the hardware key. The FBI would have to extract the key by melting the plastic off the chip and hitting it with bursts of lasers to hopefully recover bits of the key.

With a supercomputer, the FBI could crack a simple six-digit numeric code in about 22 hours, but a complex alpha-numeric password could take over 10 years.

Odds are its just a 4-digit passcode though. A small minority of users actually use the alpha-numeric passcode option.
 
Comment

ArtOfWarfare

macrumors G3
Nov 26, 2007
9,120
5,074
Well, if they used a 4 digit PIN, that means essentially there IS a backdoor to get in, as it won't take very long to try out all the combinations. This case could shed light on what exactly Apple *can* do with our phones, even if we lock them down to their fullest.

The fullest you can lock the phone down isn't a 4 digit passcode, though. I'm pretty sure you can set it to any length passcode and it can include unicode.
 
Comment

easy4lif

macrumors 6502
Mar 31, 2005
402
599
Southbay CA
It wont be any government that ends Apple's privacy protections, it will be people who sue for billions when the next attack happens and they find iphones on the dead bodies of the attackers.

Before you saw that wont happen,... Lots of people couldnt believe a man sued over hot coffee and won, or wealth could be an excuse a kid uses to get away with murder.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Col4bin and SusanK
Comment

2010mini

macrumors 601
Jun 19, 2013
4,532
4,524
can't his texts also be accessed from his cellular provider? How about websites he visited on his iPhone while he was home on his network or even on cellular data? His ISP would be able to access that data, no? All his social media posts are also up for grabs... So what other data are they looking for?

They were able to access his iCloud info but are having a hard time breaking the screen lock code? Wut?
 
Last edited:
Comment

techwhiz

macrumors 65816
Feb 22, 2010
1,207
1,572
Northern Ca.
You might be able to stop the wipe after X-attrmepts if you already had access to the device.
Being able to disable auto-wipe implies a backdoor.

If the FBI was smart, they would remove the flash from the phone and send the chips to the NSA.
You don't need the whole phone only the flash in a chip socket.
Ask Apple for the layout of the OS and data. Crank away...
 
Comment

The Doctor11

macrumors 603
Dec 15, 2013
5,931
1,339
New York
They want to enter an unlimited number of passwords, the only way I can think of this being done is if Apple installs a special OS on the devices that doesn't have the delete after 10 feature. At this point wouldn't just be easiest to install an OS that doesn't have passwords at all?
 
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.