Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
66,067
34,920



Apple has removed messaging app "ToTok" from the App Store after an investigation by the New York Times concluded that the app was actually a spying tool being used by the United Arab Emirates government to mass surveil its citizens.

appStore.jpg

According to the report, which cites U.S. officials familiar with a classified intelligence assessment, the app was being used to mine data from users' contact lists and track locations by offering a localized weather forecast.

ToTok's privacy policy notes that it "may share your personal data with group companies," but it turns out that the app is linked to Abu Dhabi-based cybersecurity firm DarkMatter, which is under investigation by the FBI for possible cybercrimes. A U.S. intelligence assessment also linked ToTok to Pax AI, an Abu Dhabi-based data mining firm.

In the time that it was available on the App Store and the Google Play store, the app was downloaded by millions of users in the Middle East, North America, Europe, Asia and Africa. The app was particularly popular in the UAE, where other messaging apps like WhatsApp and Skype are partially blocked. Users who installed the app on their devices are being advised to remove it, as any surveillance capacity could still potentially operate unhindered.

The UAE has reportedly been using surveillance technology to crack down on internal dissent in the country, including hacking Western journalists and holding human rights activists in solitary confinement over Facebook posts.

It's not the first time we've heard reports that apparently legitimate apps are being used as fronts for governments to spy on their citizens. An October report from the Open Technology Fund (OTF), an initiative funded by the U.S. government, revealed that an "educational" app teaching the Chinese Communist Party's policies includes code that amounts to a backdoor into users' Android devices.

A separate report elaborating on the findings said that the app, known as "Study Xi, Strong Nation," essentially gives the Chinese government the capacity to determine "the location of every citizen at any single point in time."

Note: Due to the political nature of the discussion regarding this topic, the discussion thread is located in our Political News forum. All forum members and site visitors are welcome to read and follow the thread, but posting is limited to forum members with at least 100 posts.

Article Link: Apple Pulls Emirati Chat App 'ToTok' From App Store for Allegedly Spying on Users
 
Last edited:
This is one of the reasons I mainly stick to Apple’s native apps for the majority of my needs. I do use some 3rd party apps for special purposes (business, cycling and special interests) but I regularly review and limit what apps have access to various phone features such as location, contacts, and cameras & microphone.
 
I was in Dubai last month and WhatsApp and all other apps were working fine. I’m not sure how to treat some of these articles of sensationalism...
 
  • Like
Reactions: orthorim
I was in Dubai last month and WhatsApp and all other apps were working fine. I’m not sure how to treat some of these articles of sensationalism...

I lived in Dubai from 2005 to 2008. At that time, Skype was definitely blocked (on the Mac since there were no iOS apps). Most everyone used a VPN to avoid the blocks. Back then, Etisalat was the only telecom provider and later a second one (du) came onto the scene. Telecom was very tightly controlled in those days.
 

Gotta love the glowing reviews there …

What is an amazing App!

I write this review for those who know nothing about one of our most efficient eGov platforms that has been called “Absher”, which means “at your service”. Simply this app makes our life very convenient; it saves us time, effort, money and much more than that. No body outside Saudi Arabia could imaging where were we before Absher! Since it was launched 11 years ago, Absher has been greatly contributing to the quality of our lives. Yes, it improved it big time. Moreover, it has supported and enhanced both security and efficiency of other eGov services. I know that many countries on the G20 list are still far away from reaching what Absher has brought to us. There are more than 25 eService on Absher that any good citizen of a country would be thrilled and delighted to have access to within his/er country. We are grateful and thankful to the great men and women behind Absher platform. My parent’s generation, my generation and next generations can’t/won’t thank you enough for your outstanding achievements. All the best!

The exact same glowing review was posted twice by different users. What a coincidence …
 
disgusting...
I've been there several times in the last ten years. A place full of hypocrisy ...
[automerge]1577108715[/automerge]
I was in Dubai last month and WhatsApp and all other apps were working fine. I’m not sure how to treat some of these articles of sensationalism...
I don't know about other apps, but WhatsApp is working for sure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marekul
I like how it states "Fast & Secure" like all the falsely advertised apps and services for being "private" and "secure"
 
I was in Dubai last month and WhatsApp and all other apps were working fine. I’m not sure how to treat some of these articles of sensationalism...

WHATSAPP and other VOIP apps are all blocked. For sure. I am living here for16 years and they have been blocked for many years.

If you are using your home country number then WhatsApp calls will work for you. Else not.
 
The difference with WeChat is that the Chinese are aware that they are being monitored. And, seem not to care. There are a bunch of videos out there interviewing people about the software.

Edit:
Here are two links
 
  • Like
Reactions: dabotsonline
WHATSAPP and other VOIP apps are all blocked. For sure. I am living here for16 years and they have been blocked for many years.

If you are using your home country number then WhatsApp calls will work for you. Else not.
Thats not true, I left UAE now after 15 years there, but my Whatsapp No was always my UAE Etisalat number and still is until they close my sim down

Many VOIP were troublesome and Facetime was removed on all UAE Iphone handsets permanently. Skype on your laptop has been fine for years and most handsets now

Although VOIP is not technically illegal no one has approached TIA (Telecom authority) in UAE for approval as its not in Etisalat or Du advantage presumably

Additionally many VPN apps are also blocked as too Apps that are deemed not acceptable because of content

This app I understand in nothing to do with UAE government, but a UAE Company, until proved otherwise
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.