Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
my only question for you is how many homepods and apple tv's do you own, how many homekit devices do you have...because if it only works with one, that doesn't mean anything...I honestly believe they only test with one homepod and apple tv, because once you start putting them all over the house, it just doesn't work...I have 7 apple tv's and 10 minis and big homepods scattered around the house...any of them have an issue, whole system goes down, something happens, you have no clue which one is the problem, so you are basically wasting hours unpluggging homepods and apple tv, or restarting iphones and ipads, just to get the ****** lights to turn on...it's CRAZY! and don't get me started with members of the home, and personal voice, that is just a MESS! Look at any youtubers who cover homekit, when they open their home app, they always have no response on devices, always...it's basically impossilbe to have homekit open with everything connected properly when you have hue, wemo, myq, lutron, tv's, ecobee, logitech, faucets all connected to homekit...it's not Siri haters, it just the truth, and if you only tell Siri "silence my alarm" and you think it works and it's perfect...PLEASE!! LMAO!
I have 4 ATVs and 3 HomePods, 15 HomeKit devices... honestly the system scaling hasn't been much of an issue for me. I don't mean to oversimplify but I've never had to unplug anything except when my stereo pairing used to get messed up before they fixed that issue with a software update.
 
My favorite thing is when you ask Siri to do something, it can’t get to the device but you can just press a button in the home app and the device turns on.

HomePod+Siri is one of the biggest disappointments in apple’s product line. Not even considering the weird home hub problems like the primary forgetting how to figure out sunrise/sunset for automation triggers OR the original HomePod always being a thread device connectivity problem if it ever happens to become the primary.
 
Not sure what people do with their homepods but I never had a single problem with the lights or other homekit accessories and they are mostly from Meross or Eufy. The only thing that frustrates me is that Siri sometimes understand different words that I say and I triple checked, my English is fine.
Hey Siri play I want it that way
Siri: here's I wanna die
Siri are you ok?
 
Hey siri turn the fan off, ok fan is on 🤦‍♂️

Siri is decent with requests usually but still needs plenty of improvements. Someone needs to teach her what on and off means though.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: sos47 and sorgo †
Lots of Siri haters... I find that I usually get what I want from her. I was pleased this morning when I heard my phone alarm clock blaring in the distance while I was in the shower, figured I'd have to put up with it's incessancy or go running wet and naked to silence it (didn't think the phone would hear me from inside the shower), then remembered I have a new HomePod mini in the bathroom, asked Siri to silence my alarm, and Siri instantly responded "I've silenced the alarm on one of your devices". Not a difficult task, but I never knew it could do that, and it worked just as I had hoped!
Cool welcome to 2010
 
  • Haha
Reactions: sorgo †
I have 4 ATVs and 3 HomePods, 15 HomeKit devices... honestly the system scaling hasn't been much of an issue for me. I don't mean to oversimplify but I've never had to unplug anything except when my stereo pairing used to get messed up before they fixed that issue with a software update.
15 devices is not even close to larger scale, I have 15 devices in my kitchen alone that are connected to homekit…large scale is 12 wemo light switches, 8 lutron light switches, over 40 Hue devices (lights, motion sensors, switches), garages doors, 6 tv’s in the house, 15 wemo plugs, over 20 aqara devices, whole security system etc……my whole house is connected to homekit, that is large scale (and I’m in a typical middle class home)…homekit and don’t get me wrong, neither do the others truly work…to get everything to work, you need multi automation platforms…it’s a cluster fck, and nope homebridge is not a solution either
 
TBH Siri needs more than a fix, it needs to be thrown in the garbage and built again from the ground up.
Agreed. It’s amazing how inconsistent it has been over the years, never really improving by any significant measure. Commands / words it used to recognize would all of a sudden have difficulty with. Most recently, the Apple Watch no longer starting workouts when issuing commands through AirPods and the random muffled Siri voice issue which is a first.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fwmireault
Why is it I can ask Siri on my HomePod mini to turn on/off lights etc, and I’ll get “one sec” or “lights aren’t responding.” Yet if I open the HomeKit app I can access them and they work instantly?

Siri really needs to be blown up and start over. Shame how Apple was ahead of the game when it launched and have done very little with it ever since. Another “hobby” I guess.
 
Last edited:
Lots of Siri haters... I find that I usually get what I want from her. I was pleased this morning when I heard my phone alarm clock blaring in the distance while I was in the shower, figured I'd have to put up with it's incessancy or go running wet and naked to silence it (didn't think the phone would hear me from inside the shower), then remembered I have a new HomePod mini in the bathroom, asked Siri to silence my alarm, and Siri instantly responded "I've silenced the alarm on one of your devices". Not a difficult task, but I never knew it could do that, and it worked just as I had hoped!
You can also pause media on nearby devices. Very handy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Return Zero
My favorite is when my wife asks Siri to do something and Siri replies "Who's speaking?" God, that pisses my wife off. It happens several times per month. It's me, my wife, and a 9 year old boy (who sounds nothing like my wife). Why is this so difficult? Then there is the shortcut I created to turn off all my lights when I go to bed. I set it up so I say "Hey Siri, Good night" and she replies "Good night?" like she is asking a question. It's so weird.
Only several times per month?! Literally multiple times per day here. And it's only me and my wife; we sound nothing alike. Does anyone know – would something fix this? Resetting something? Signing in and out of our accounts? Anything?
 
HomePod Updates are the scariest thing to see lol, and my HomePods currently suck…. So what does that say?!

Since the last update, Siri has been unable to control most homekit devices about 70% of the time, it ALWAYS has an issue when telling it to play Apple Music.

“sorry… this is taking too long” is possible the most annoying phrase I’ve ever heard now, and hear it 7-8 times per day, along with “one second”.

All of this is separate from the HomePods randomly cutting out when music is playing and been an issue for a few updates now.


Yeah Apple Music is cutting out for me too. I really really really really want to fix this. Only with Apple Music
 
  • Sad
Reactions: sorgo †
HP Mini just needs to be easier to use. It’s different for IOS and MacOS. Make it simple and work the same on every platform.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sorgo †
Even after the update my OG's keep telling me didn't find my bedroom lights even though the other devices have not problem with simple order.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: sorgo †
The mini’s are great speakers for casual listening but the Siri part of them is really frustrating.

Every new release has been worse than the previous one.

One thing that’s still happening today: you say Play X, the lights on the HP turns ON, the Home app show the mini’s as “Playing”, you can pause/play from the control center and change the volume…but there’s no sound being played. It’s the most infuriating thing, plus if you consider that the bastard comes with FOUR mic’s. Can’t Apple use one of them to check if the audio is ACTUALLY playing?

At circuit level it would be easy as well, just check how much current the amplifier is using.

Other insulting thing:
Me: Play X on Living Room
Siri (using the Living Room mini’s): I can’t find any capable device in this room
Me: 💀🤬

Finally, the light on top. Is never consistent. And is too dim to even see the +/- sign’s.

13CE6CB4-D989-4D78-A868-48F3E526043B.jpeg
 
Please please please have fixed the gapless playback. 🤞

We play brown noise to drown out sound, and now there's a random 2-5 second delay between these gapless audio sleep track when they are supposed to repeat, and they don't loop properly at all. As a result, our entire household hasn't slept the same since 15.4 was released. 😴

update: in my initial tests, this bug has been fixed! yay!
 
Last edited:
15 devices is not even close to larger scale, I have 15 devices in my kitchen alone that are connected to homekit…large scale is 12 wemo light switches, 8 lutron light switches, over 40 Hue devices (lights, motion sensors, switches), garages doors, 6 tv’s in the house, 15 wemo plugs, over 20 aqara devices, whole security system etc……my whole house is connected to homekit, that is large scale (and I’m in a typical middle class home)…homekit and don’t get me wrong, neither do the others truly work…to get everything to work, you need multi automation platforms…it’s a cluster fck, and nope homebridge is not a solution either
Don’t take the is the wrong way but when you get that complex in a home system it’s going to be a clusterfk no matter what platform (as you even stated yourself). My uncle has a giant mansion with a massively expensive Control4 whole smarthome automation system and the technician basically lives in his house because he has to call him out so often for issues. You may be in a middle class home but I think most would consider you a smarthome superuser of sorts 😂 As I like to say… mo money mo problems :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: sorgo †
My user experience with Siri on my HomePod has only gotten worse as time as gone on. Most of the time it's 'hold on' or 'just a sec', and never getting to an actual response. Scratch that. There is the occasional 'I can't do that on HomePod'.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: sorgo †
15 devices is not even close to larger scale, I have 15 devices in my kitchen alone that are connected to homekit…large scale is 12 wemo light switches, 8 lutron light switches, over 40 Hue devices (lights, motion sensors, switches), garages doors, 6 tv’s in the house, 15 wemo plugs, over 20 aqara devices, whole security system etc……my whole house is connected to homekit, that is large scale (and I’m in a typical middle class home)…homekit and don’t get me wrong, neither do the others truly work…to get everything to work, you need multi automation platforms…it’s a cluster fck, and nope homebridge is not a solution either
So what you’re telling me is you live in a microwave.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.