Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
They will be scanning ON YOUR DEVICE. Will you let them in your house to search for evidence for crime, too? You phone and devices will have become snitch tools to use against you rather than friends and assistants to help you.

You're artificially adding drama to the phrase "on-device scanning" and I don't think you know what that really means considering the analogy you gave.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maconplasma
Can't really help you there. Cherry picking what you want to believe and what you don't want to believe makes no sense to me.
Like I mentioned earlier, I'm not on either side but don't allow some people here to try and bully or attack you because they don't agree with your views on this subject about Apple. Some people's fingers never seem to get tired of typing their Apple hatred over and over. You can PLANELY see it.
 
Last edited:
Apple could easily solve the problem of privacy and keep kids safe. Remove the camera and ban all photos from iOS. Problem solved.
Maybe the next Apple will be a company selling mobile phones with a state of the art camera, touchscreen, Bluetooth and WITHOUT a smart OS and WITHOUT internet connection.

For many people this would be enough as they use internet at home only.

The problem of "dumb phones" is nowadays that they lack a good camera, storage space and touch device.
 
  • Like
Reactions: turbineseaplane
Are all the features of the camera available via the API? If so, I wonder that developing a photo application that encrypts data and allows you to select/configure your own backend storage (local, cloud, both) would be at least one solution for images. Apple would likely not approve the application, as it bypasses functionality they wish to continue controlling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VulchR
Just switch platforms (phone, computer, tablet, watch, etc) and your privacy and security will be top notch. Check out Google and Microsoft for your next products.
Pretty sure Linux (shall we go Arch?) and Copperhead are doing an excellent job. One can also easily configure the network stack to prevent it from "calling home". A thing that Apple prevents because they implemented a functionality that allows their own traffic to bypass any user firewall.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Philip_S
So how soon until Apple starts scanning all our content for "illegal material?" When does iMessage begin scanning every incoming and outgoing text for keywords and phrases?
I assume now that Apple is about to do what Google does,many of us will choose Google services which are better anyway.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FindingAvalon
The whole China angle is it's own issue.

They basically should have two sets of iOS and rules to deal with that country if they are going to keep operating there.

China doesn't even really hide what sort of regime they are running there.

The same isn't true of other first world countries --- who at least purport to be somewhat democratic and have priorities of privacy and liberty for citizens.
100% agree. It's ingrained in their society too; citizens just go along with it at this point. There really should be two different versions of each OS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: turbineseaplane
I'd say the chances iOS 15 & its derivatives are Boycott now stands @ 20% or so !

2x of what it was just a day ago !

Apple's BIG challenge right now is what to do about the iPhone 13 family.

Go with iOS 15 ?, or go with iOS 14.8 ?

If they decide to go with iOS 14.8, I suspect they will leak it to one of their contacts, so Word Gets Out !

IMO, they don't really have much of a choice, they must go with iOS 14.8.

And naturally, I'm assuming it doesn't include what Apple announced last Thursday.
 
  • Like
Reactions: centauratlas
You do not know this and are just assuming. As nobody knows the algorithm you can not check these assumptions. And Apple could always make mistakes when implementing it.

Apple could always make mistakes with iCloud security too. Arguing software bugs specifically with respect to this feature doesn't quite make sense as the worst case scenario here would be an Apple employee looking at your photos vs all of your photos being public through an iCloud bug.

Or they could make a mistake when reporting a user and confuse the name of thiis users with yours.

That's not how it works, no. It's tied to the Apple ID email which is unique for everyone.

And do not forget, that the reward for a potential attaker with the resources of a gouvernement is potentially very high so a lot of resources could be invested e.g. when trying to influence an election or when trying to get rid of an politician.

What's the reward for causing an inconvenience of an Apple employee reviewing photos that were erroneously flagged and reinstating the account? Not much.
 
I wonder what Apple's stock price is going to do over the next few days....
I am delighted to see that Apple Stock is going the way I thougt, it was going.
Talking in pictures: The angle of the curve is not the angle, which would turn the movie into an R18 movie...
 
Next up - Apple weighs in with an opinion on who my daughter is allowed to date.
Hmmm. I could see it now - an "If You Want to Date My Daughter' app, where the potential suitor's blood type could be pulled from the Health app, his criminal record pulled from the net, photo from the Photos app, a complete map of where's he's been for the last 7 days from Maps, a word count of the number of times drugs, sex or profanity was mentioned in his texts/posts, etc. 🤔
 
Arguing software bugs specifically with respect to this feature doesn't quite make sense as the worst case scenario here would be an Apple employee looking at your photos vs all of your photos being public through an iCloud bug.
He's not talking about software bugs. Again, review current peer reviewed publications on adversarial attacks.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.